1、 Selecting the "best" checkpoint using the test dataset introduces the risk of information leakage. Even if the authors do not designate a validation set, the test set should not be used to determine the optimal epoch. Doing so leads to an overly optimistic report of the "best" results and renders any comparison with the "last" checkpoint results unfair. Overall, this evaluation approach lacks practical utility; while it may employ the same selection strategy as the baseline, the baseline itself might not be well-suited to this paradigm—it is possible that a superior model could have been identified for the baseline had a validation set been used instead.
2、 Key implementation details are missing, hindering reproducibility. The paper fails to explicitly specify the following hyperparameters and module details:What specific statistical measures are included in the channel-wise statistical features sc used for routing? How is the number of views K determined, and what is its default value? What is the architecture of the relation encoder for each view—is it a Transformer, an attention mechanism, or an MLP? How are the adapter tokens initialized? Furthermore, what are the specific implementation details of the Bi-SSM, including its state dimension and whether it is causal?
3、 The validity of the training objective in this paper is questionable. During the training phase, both the input and the output are subjected to noise, whereas in the testing phase, only the input is corrupted. In essence, this means that during training, the model is fitting the noise distribution rather than the original data distribution. Such a design is highly unreasonable, rendering the evaluation metrics entirely meaningless.
4、 First, adding noise to the input training data only to subsequently remove it using an AF (adaptive filtering) module seems redundant. Second, the suitability of adaptive filtering for various types of noise is questionable; the method employs a learnable low-pass mask while preserving the zero-frequency component. However, this approach has drawbacks: "constant" noise often manifests as a low-frequency bias or even a zero-frequency component, meaning the preservation of the zero-frequency component may hinder the removal of such noise. "Missing" noise creates gaps in the time domain, and applying a direct Fourier transform may introduce artifacts. Finally, while low-pass filtering might be effective against Gaussian noise—which acts as a disturbance across the entire frequency spectrum—it risks the loss of authentic high-frequency dynamics.
5、 Multi-view representations may degenerate into a single space, lacking empirical validation of their diversity. In the formulation Vk=Diag(a:,k)E, each view retains all channel tokens, merely applying different reweighting. If the routing assignments A are too similar across different views, the views will exhibit significant overlap—potentially collapsing into a single, unified space. Consequently, the notion of "multi-view complementarity" currently serves more as a design motivation than a concept backed by empirical evidence. Notably, this paper lacks ablation studies on the number of views (K) and provides no metrics to assess whether these multiple views truly capture distinct perspectives.
6、 Bi-SSM processes data along the view dimension; however, views lack a natural ordering.The views V1,…,VK represent latent relational perspectives and possess no inherent fixed sequence. Since Bi-SSM is a sequence-sensitive module, its performance may be unstable depending on the arrangement of these views.
7、 Insufficient baselines and a lack of robust TSF (Time Series Forecasting) methods.The paper only compares its approach against PatchTST, TimeXer, and Dynamic-TMoE—methods that were not originally designed for multivariate forecasting tasks involving noise. Furthermore, although the authors claim to follow the evaluation protocol used for the "RobustTSF" model, they fail to include a performance comparison against that very model; the rationale behind this design choice remains unclear. Consequently, the absence of these relevant baselines undermines the claim of "superior performance."