- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces CINEPERSONA, which addresses the separation problem of identity, action, and camera control in character video generation, which often leads to mutual damage when combined. It proposes to cut the reference video into 3x3 short segments sorted by time and use dual-path encoding: the implicit pathway retains the overall visual clues, while the explicit pathway extracts character identity, action posture, and camera. Subsequently, CINE-ROPE injects the target camera trajectory into the generation model and uses three-axis guidance to adjust text, identity, and camera/action conditions. The results report improved identity, action, and camera metrics on the newly established CINEHUMAN-BENCH.
Critical strengths
-
The method has a clear motivation and targeted ablation experiments. CINEPERSONA integrate time-ordered reference fragments, implicit/explicit dual pathways, and CINE-ROPE mechanisms; they retain rich clues in the reference video, provide structural conditions, and inject target camera geometry information into the backbone network. The results of ablation experiments show that when the reference segment order is disrupted or the CINE-ROPE mechanism is closed, the rotation error will increase, while the identity consistency index remains relatively stable.
-
The paper constructs CINEHUMAN-BENCH, a dataset comprising 50 identities and 400 video clips, while simultaneously assessing identity, motion, camera shots, and video quality. Among them, camera metrics are computed using MegaSaM and validated using ground-truth trajectories from synthetic scenes as well as human evaluations. This tests the core arguments of the paper more effectively than just reporting on overall perceptions or individual indicators of identity, making the paper's results more convincing.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper does not discuss the ActCam, 3STC-HIA, and Tri-Prompting, which have previously involved character identity consistency and combinations of action and camera movement. It is necessary to supplement the qualitative and quantitative comparisons of these work.
ActCam: Zero-Shot Joint Camera and 3D Motion Control for Video Generation. El Khalifi, O. et al. (2026).
3D Scene-Adaptive Trajectory-Controllable Human Image Animation with Camera Movement. Liu, D. et al. (2026).
Tri-Prompting: Controllable Video Generation with Scene, Subject, and Motion Prompts. Zhou, Z. et al. (2026).
Questions for authors
-
Can the reference video and target trajectory be different? When inference, the model extracts the camera pose of the original video from the reference video while receiving the user-specified target camera trajectory. Please explain: Can the target trajectory differ from the camera movement in the reference video? How do the reference video and target trajectory usually pair during training? How many examples of “the same reference video, different target trajectory” has the model seen?
-
Why does shuffling cells lead to a significant increase in camera error? In Table 4, after shuffling cells, the rotation error of the generated video relative to the target trajectory increased. Since the target trajectory is input separately, why would the order of the reference segments have such a great impact on the ability to follow them? Please explain whether the target trajectory is same as the camera in the reference video, and analyze whether the increase in error indicates that the model depends on the camera movement clues in the reference video. It is best to report the results of the same reference video paired with multiple different target trajectories to test whether the model can truly switch camera.
-
Can the action also be controlled independently of the reference video? The paper extracts action poses from the reference video but does not explicitly demonstrate a target action input separate from the reference video. The guidance during inference also places “camera/action” on the same axis. Please clarify whether users can specify new actions independently, whether action control and camera control can be adjusted separately, and which experiments have verified this independent control.
Auhor-Reviewer Discussion Peroid is About to Finish
Dear reviewers,
Thank you for your reviews and constructive feedback.
The author-reviewer discussion period will be finishing soon. Please take a moment to review it and consider whether your concerns have been adequately addressed. It would be helpful if you could briefly indicate:
Whether the rebuttal addresses your main concerns;
Whether any significant issues remain unresolved;
Whether your overall recommendation has changed.
If appropriate, please also update your review and recommendation in the system.
Thank you for your time and valuable contributions.
Best regards,
AC