- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes OQ-ATOMS for open-vocabulary 3D semantic segmentation. The method introduces query-addressable atoms that preserve multi-view semantic evidence, together with provenance-weighted readout and a conservative evidence-gated update mechanism. Experiments on Replica and ScanNet report improvements over existing methods. However, most of the reported performance advantage comes from the underlying dense backbone rather than the proposed components, while the deferred commitment mechanism is evaluated separately from the main results. Furthermore, inconsistencies and duplicated baseline visualizations in Figure 4 raise concerns about the reliability of the experimental presentation.
Critical strengths
None.
Critical weaknesses
- Serious inconsistencies and insufficiently supported experimental results.
Figure 4 raises substantial concerns about the reliability of the experimental presentation. The visualizations for HOV-SG and RayFronts are identical in both Replica examples, despite their substantially different quantitative results in Table 1. The figure caption also incorrectly identifies the third column as the proposed dense evidence stage. Moreover, the qualitative results provide little visible evidence of the substantial improvements claimed in Table 1. These inconsistencies make it difficult to assess whether the reported visualizations faithfully represent the evaluated methods.
- Unclear technical contribution.
The main performance gains appear to come primarily from the dense backbone rather than the proposed method. According to Table 2, the actual improvements from atoms and provenance readout are only 2.08 and 0.49 mIoU points on Replica and ScanNet, respectively. Meanwhile, the deferred commitment mechanism emphasized throughout the paper is not responsible for the headline results.
Questions for authors
None.