- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper discusses a very important topic - human-AI collaboration, in particular, co-inference. It proposes using a shared editable state, something that is already common in systems like OpenClaw or Claude that maintain .md files that can be edited by humans and AI. What this paper adds is not clear - a more direct, interactive way to edit? So the general approach might be known, there is certainly a lot more to be done in that direction and I could easily see many papers in that direction. The current submission fails to provide good motivating examples. The intro talks about problems how agents claimed to accomplish a task but did not. But it is not obvious how your approach really solves this - Does a user have to overwrite the AI? The evaluation essentially confirms that the approach work, but it is not surprising that editing the state has an impact - it is already the reality for many systems. So overall I fail to see the big insight from these evaluations. So while I like the idea and the abstract problem, the evaluation showing its relevance for a meaningful benchmark comparing it against other techniques is absent.
Critical strengths
see above
Critical weaknesses
see above
Questions for authors
see above