- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes CrossLJP, a framework that leverages cross-attention to construct an additional interaction context, which is combined with the original representations to produce more informative case representations for legal judgment prediction. The authors conduct extensive experiments, including comparisons with various baselines, ablation studies, and evaluations across datasets in different languages, to demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed approach. However, the methodological novelty appears limited, as CrossLJP mainly integrates existing techniques, including frozen pretrained encoders, task-adapted encoders, and cross-attention mechanisms. Furthermore, the rationale for selecting different backbone encoders for the semantic and decision representations remains unclear. The paper would also benefit from a stronger justification for using relatively older embedding models, such as Nomic and BGE-M3, rather than more recent alternatives, as well as additional experiments comparing different embedding models to validate the encoder selection.
Critical strengths
- The proposed CrossLJP module utilised cross-attention to construct an additional interaction context. As a result, the interaction context is retained together with original representation to form an informative case representation.
- The authors have done extensive experiments for baselines comparison, ablation study, different language datasets and so on.
Critical weaknesses
- The novelty of the proposed CrossLJP module appears limited, as it mainly combines three existing techniques: frozen pretrained encoders, task-adapted encoders, and cross-attention mechanisms for representation aggregation. The authors should further clarify the methodological contributions beyond the integration of these existing techniques.
- The authors should clarify the rationale for using different backbone encoders for the semantic encoder and decision encoder, rather than adopting the same backbone for both components.
- The proposed CrossLJP module relies on embedding models such as Nomic and BGE-M3, both of which were introduced approximately two years ago. More recent embedding models, such as Qwen3-Embedding, have demonstrated strong performance on legal retrieval tasks in the MTEB benchmark. The authors should justify their choice of these relatively older embedding models. Additional experiments comparing different embedding models as backbone encoders are recommended to further investigate the impact of encoder selection on the performance of CrossLJP.
Questions for authors
Why the semantic encoder and decision decoder using different backbones? Why not use more recently and more powerful encoders?