- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper addresses a general theory of card counting. A count is a statistic of the discarded cards. Eg, "Hi–Lo", made famous from TV (eg, 21), adds/subtracts when low/high cards are discarded (namely, 2–6/10–A); a high count (normalised by the number of cards remaining) indicates favourable conditions.
The paper introduces a unified mathematical framework for defining, and deriving, optimal card-counting systems - something that the paper claims is absent in the field. This is connected with other topics, such as information theory (obviously) and representation learning.
The method is evaluated on a variety card games and comparisons with strategies, demonstrating the flexibility of the approach
Critical strengths
Overall, I liked the paper. It isn't my area - I come from probability, including card shuffling, but not card counting. Nevertheless, I found the introduction compelling, and a clear case for the paper was made:
- I feel quite strongly that progress can be held back by lack of clear definitions of what people are trying to do. As much as anything else, it hinders comparisons of approaches, when different authors have different goals
- Whenever I see "... without a unified mathematical definition of what constitutes an optim[um]. This paper introduces a framework for defining and deriving [such optima]..." I'm very happy
- Setting up a clear framework that crosses games - eg, "Spanish 21 is a key test of the theory because it changes both the deck composition and the game rules, precisely where transferred counting systems may become mismatched (§4.3) - is very important
I definitely recommend this paper for acceptance. That said, I cannot give a really detailed review, as I just don't know the topic so well. I leave the more nuanced comments to the other reviewers. But, on the more abstract question of "Is this type of paper important?" my instinctive feeling is a strong "yes".
The fac that I could not check all the details precisely, including understanding what the standard baselines are, leads me to restrict my rating to "3/4: Weak acceptance" - instinctively, I'd like to give "4/4: Clear acceptance", but my understanding can't justify that.
Critical weaknesses
For someone not in the field, I felt that the paper was a bit inaccessible.
- The abstract was a bit jargon-y:
- I couldn't understand the description of the main results from the abstract alone
- Likely, these are understandable to someone in the field, but I feel that the abstract could be more accessible
- Even explaining what a "count" is exactly, just as "a statistic of the discarded/used cards", would have helped a lot
- The structure of §2 felt a little like a braindump:
- It just felt like reading a list of statements, but without understanding why
- There was no foreshadowing or guidance, to understand what the purpose was
- Again, this might be simply because I don't know the area
Unrelatedly, I do think that it perhaps oversells a little:
- The impression given by the introduction (§1) is that this is for quite general card-counting systems
- It actually only handles the case in which the count is a weighted sum of the number of each rank discarded so far (§2.2)
- The "framework for defining and deriving optimal card-counting systems" (§Abstract) only applies to this one-dimensional projection
There were several other minor notes that didn't affect my understanding substantially, but could be fixed or clarified.
- The notation :
- Why not start at ? Is it already exposed, hence not needed to be conditioned on? Where is the number introduced?
- I realised after that "" → "Ace", and this is "(2, 3, ..., 10, J, Q, K, A)". This could be made clearer
- Betting function and the -notation:
- The expression "betting function" wasn't known to me
- It wasn't clear how could be enforced
- Sometimes it's but sometimes just
- This is likely due to not really understanding the definitions fully
- Typo in §2.5:
- The second display is missing an on the right-hand side
- Notation in §2.6:
- Why did the notation change from to ?
- I guess that the point is to be able to use
- Tbh, I didn't really like
- Why not ? Indeed, this is the case in §2.8
- It's not like was defined for any and then using
- Zero-gradient in §2.6 (bottom of page 4):
- Surely this is a condition on , not a statement?
- That is, it's at the local maximum/minimum
- Citation format:
- Should use
\citeprather than\citefor many in-line citations, such as in §2.9 - This is really a nit-pick!
- Should use
- Notation change (§2.8 → §3.1):
- The notation in §3.1 suddenly changes to instead of
- §2.8, in which is used, is even referenced to explain this sequence
Questions for authors
None
3 comments
Comment to Reviewer SGZ8
I am not sure why you can't see my response, but I will paste it here:
$\textit{ Thank you for the positive and thoughtful review! I really appreciate your comments and suggestions, and I'll use them to improve the clarity and accessibility of the paper.
Regarding the generality of the framework, I think you raise a fair point. The generality comes from defining the components of card counting mathematically, allowing the framework to be applied across different games and rules. The restriction to one-dimensional linear counts is intentional, as our goal is to develop counting systems that a human player can realistically maintain and use in real time. I'll make this distinction clearer in the paper. }$
I want to take this opportunity to thank you again for the positive and useful review.
Thanks for responding, even so close to the deadline. Idk why I can't see it. Perhaps an AC+ should look into this?
My identifying information has been removed and it's been uploaded anonymously, of course.
Regarding your response, that all sounds fine and reasonable. I don't think that it's enough for me to raise my score. Indeed, I didn't raise concrete enough concerns for that. My lack of familiarity with the area - other results, baselines and the like - limits my judgement. But, from a slightly outsider point of view, I certainly enjoyed the more qualitative aspects of the paper
I have received an email entitled "[ICLR 2027] Discussion reminder", saying,
However, on my view of the page at least, the authors have not posted any response to my review - which, assuming that my view is accurate, is somewhat disappointing. If they have, and I just can't see it, please accept my apologies - I am not refusing to engage, I simply cannot see the comment.