acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Can Newer Models’ Gains Be Backported to Older Language Models?

Abstract

Organizations keep a deployed language model for its latency, license, or validated behavior long after a successor release solves tasks it cannot. Distillation imitates a teacher wholesale, and model evolution migrates assets forward. Neither moves one verified gain backward into a model that must stay in service. A newer release fixes some of its predecessor’s mistakes but makes new ones of its own. A backport should inherit the fixes, verified task by task, and none of the new mistakes. CBack tests whether that is possible, first refusing version gaps indistinguishable from zero. Each verifier-rejected predecessor trajectory is then paired with a verifier-accepted repair, a version event. Preservation is normalized by the predecessor’s own resampling churn, and cost separates successor queries from a model’s own tokens. Of eight audited scopes in two model lineages, four carry a resolvable gain. All four recover, only one under successor guidance, and none needs successor access. Failure-gated querying instead yields 3.2× more admissible repairs per successor token than uniform querying. On GSM8K, two successor-free arms learn only from the predecessor’s verified samples, and only the one that also trains against its own failures recovers on a sealed test split. We conclude that failure-aware contrast improves recovery and the repair’s source decides how far. With its own repairs and no successor query, the deployed 1.5B model recovers 0.575 of that held-out gap and flips fewer of its successes than resampling does.

Primary area:
transfer learning, meta learning, and lifelong learning
Keywords:
capability backporting, knowledge distillation, verified self-repair, language model adaptation, capability preservation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_Hnv9OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies capability backporting for LLMs: transferring a verified capability gain of a newer model (successor) back into an older deployed model (predecessor) without disturbing the predecessor's existing successes. The authors propose CBack, a four-stage protocol. It first checks whether the version gap is statistically resolvable, then collects verifier-labeled failure–repair pairs, trains a LoRA patch with a length-normalized pairwise preference objective (functional backporting), and finally evaluates the patch by capability-gap recovery (CGR), negative flips normalized by the predecessor's own resampling churn (NFR/churn), and separately accounted costs. The repair in each pair comes either from the successor (FB-S) or from the predecessor's own resampled outputs (FB-P).

Experiments use Qwen2-1.5B to Qwen2.5-1.5B and Phi-3-mini to Phi-3.5-mini on GSM8K, MATH, and MBPP, comparing against positive-only SFT, DPO/SimPO, verifier-only GRPO, and two logit-based distillation methods (GKD and DistiLLM-2). Only 4 of 8 audited scopes pass the gap gate. The authors report that all four can be recovered without querying the successor, that the logit-based methods regress the predecessor, and that on the sealed GSM8K test split FB-P recovers 0.575 of the gap with fewer flips than resampling. They conclude that failure-aware contrast drives recovery, while successor access mainly improves data acquisition efficiency.

Critical strengths
  1. Novel and practically motivated problem formulation. Framing the transfer of a newer model's localized gains into a deployed older model as backporting, with explicit attention to preserving the older model's existing successes, is an interesting and relevant perspective for real-world LLM deployment, where replacing a model is often constrained by latency, licensing, or validated behavior.

  2. Careful evaluation protocol. The resolvable-gap gate avoids reporting recovery on gaps indistinguishable from zero, normalizing negative flips by the predecessor's own resampling churn makes preservation meaningful under stochastic decoding, and the sealed GSM8K test split is opened only once after all settings are fixed. The authors also report unfavorable results transparently, such as the drop from development to sealed test and the collapse of FB-S on MATH.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Unclear methodological novelty and disconnect from the backporting premise. The best-performing method, FB-P, pairs the predecessor’s own correct and incorrect responses and applies a length-normalized DPO objective that Table 13 shows is nearly indistinguishable from SimPO. This is also closely related to Iterative Reasoning Preference Optimization (Pang et al., 2024), which is neither cited nor compared against. More fundamentally, FB-P does not use the successor at all and consistently outperforms FB-S wherever both are evaluated. The reported gains therefore appear to reflect verifier-guided self-improvement rather than capability transfer from a successor, leaving both the methodological novelty and the central backporting claim unclear.

  2. Limited experimental scope and insufficient empirical support. The effective evaluation covers only two small models and three tasks, while only 4 of the 8 audited model pairs exhibit a transferable gap. The gap gate uses development splits drawn from training data and may therefore be affected by differential memorization, as acknowledged in Appendix F. Moreover, GRPO performs best on MATH and MBPP, while FB-P only marginally and non-significantly outperforms it on GSM8K. MATH and MBPP also lack sealed-test results and complete baseline comparisons, limiting the reliability and generalizability of the conclusions.

Questions for authors
  1. Role of the newer model. Since no resolvable scope requires successor access and FB-P outperforms FB-S wherever both are run, in what concrete setting would the successor be necessary for recovery rather than only improving acquisition efficiency? Is there evidence that any recovered capability actually originates from the successor?

  2. Sealed test results for MATH and MBPP. Appendix J states that MBPP items 11 to 510 were sealed, but sealed results are reported only for GSM8K. Could the authors report sealed test results and the full set of compared methods for MATH and MBPP?

  3. Reliability of the gap gate. The predecessor scores 0.711 on the GSM8K development split but 0.471 on the sealed test split, and Appendix F acknowledges possible differential memorization. Would the gating decisions for the 7B, 0.5B, and Phi-3 scopes change if they were made on held-out test data?

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Hnv9 (1/2)

On self-improvement and the backporting question (W1)

leaving both the methodological novelty and the central backporting claim unclear.

Our response. FB-P is deliberately successor-free: it tests whether a newer model's measured advantage can be recovered inside the deployed predecessor without successor supervision. Its success answers the backporting question while separating recovery of a version gap from transfer of successor knowledge. This distinction is central to CBack: a deployment can recover part of the upgrade without obtaining its training answers from the newer model. The matched-positive control below tests how that recovery occurs, and the held-out comparisons test where it holds.

FB-P uses a DPO/SimPO-family objective, with an identical-pair comparison in Table 13. We have added IRPO and positioned FB-P as a related one-round control. The contribution is the controlled investigation of version-gap recovery and the successor's role.

A separate explanation is that FB-P improves simply because it trains on useful verified positives, rather than because of pairwise training. To test this, we trained positive-only SFT on exactly FB-P's 879 verified self-repairs, with the same initialization and LoRA configuration. We then matched training tokens and selected SFT's learning rate on development data, so the comparison addresses both the positives and the training budget. Results use five seeds and paired task-and-seed intervals:

Positive-only controlDevelopment CGRHeld-out CGRFB-P lead in held-out accuracy
Same 110 updates and learning rate−0.221−0.60328.4 points [26.3, 30.7]
Matched tokens, development-selected learning rate0.279−0.38423.2 points [20.2, 26.1]

FB-P's held-out CGR is 0.575 [0.516, 0.636]. Pairwise training therefore retains an advantage at fixed positives in this GSM8K setting. The learning-rate grid was {3e-6, 1e-5, 3e-5}, with the upper edge selected, so this conclusion is within that tuning budget. All methods were scored on the same sealed split.

The missing held-out comparisons (W2 / Q2)

MATH and MBPP also lack sealed-test results and complete baseline comparisons

Our response. To check whether the recovery finding extends beyond GSM8K, we evaluated eight arms on the registered MATH test split, six on Qwen MBPP and two on Phi-3 MBPP, all at the frozen operating point. Figures 3–4 and Appendices S–T contain all results. To distinguish confirmation from selecting a new route on test data, the table below reports the routes chosen on development data:

Scope / selected routeHeld-out gapHeld-out CGR [95% interval]Flips / churn
GSM8K / FB-P+0.2410.575 [0.516, 0.636]0.56
MATH / GRPO+0.2950.065 [0.046, 0.084]0.91
Qwen MBPP / GRPO+0.1010.247 [0.072, 0.414]0.92
Phi-3 MBPP / GRPO−0.005 [−0.024, 0.015]Undefined: gap does not replicate—

Three original route choices recover a positive fraction with flips below resampling churn. The fourth has no positive held-out gap.

The route ranking also matters. On held-out MATH, self-improvement SFT recovers 0.046 [0.029, 0.062], versus FB-P's 0.016 [0.004, 0.028], while all successor-guided arms regress. On GSM8K, FB-P's accuracy lead over GRPO is only 0.017 [0.001, 0.034], and its lead over SimPO is 0.008 [−0.004, 0.020]. This is why the revision separates the GSM8K mechanism test from the cross-task finding of successor-free recovery.

FB-P was not trained on MBPP: self-repair produced 46 and 33 pairs, below the fixed acquisition gate of 50. Those arms are marked absent. The next comment gives the gate audit and the evidence about successor access.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Hnv9 (2/2)

The gate on held-out data (Q3)

Would the gating decisions for the 7B, 0.5B, and Phi-3 scopes change if they were made on held-out test data?

Our response. The held-out audit changes three decisions. With the same rule throughout, 4/8 scopes pass on development and 5/8 held out. The changed cases are:

ScopeDevelopment gapHeld-out gap [95% interval]Held-out decision
Qwen 7B GSM8K−0.003+0.061 [0.049, 0.073]Pass
Phi-3 MATH−0.012+0.031 [0.024, 0.038]Pass
Phi-3 MBPP+0.044−0.005 [−0.024, 0.015]Stop

Table 1 and Figure 2 show all eight scopes. The two newly passing scopes were not trained and are not counted as recoveries. The gate must therefore be applied on data representative of the intended deployment. A measured gap on one split is not a property of the version pair on every distribution.

We also verified that development task IDs and adaptation tasks are disjoint (Appendix B). This addresses adaptation-task reuse, while the split sensitivity remains an observed result. Pretraining exposure is not established by this check.

The role of successor access (Q1)

Is there evidence that any recovered capability actually originates from the successor?

Our response. The three held-out recoveries in our first comment were achieved without successor supervision. That directly establishes non-necessity for those recoveries. The collection logs show a separate benefit from successor access: repair coverage at a given sampling budget.

On failed GSM8K training tasks, at one sample from each model, only the successor repairs 385 tasks and only the predecessor 115. With four self-repair attempts against one successor attempt, both repair 787, only the successor 92, only self-repair 256, and neither 176. The successor thus supplies useful repairs sooner and covers some tasks missed within the self-repair budget.

Table 16 gives complementary held-out evidence: tasks solved only by the successor within four samples contribute +0.042 to the aggregate gain of both FB-S and FB-P. This is consistent with the successor-free recovery, although equal point contributions do not identify the provenance of each learned capability.

Successor supervision could become necessary when self-sampling cannot supply useful verified answers within the available budget. Our experiments demonstrate an acquisition advantage and successful recovery without that supervision. We have made this distinction explicit in the introduction and conclusion.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Follow-up on the controls and interpretation

Thank you again for your careful review. We hope the completed comparisons have helped clarify both the source of recovery and the interpretation of our results. We would like to bring those answers together here.

  1. First, to test whether recovery requires successor supervision, we evaluated the successor-free controls on held-out data. Recovery is confirmed on GSM8K, MATH and Qwen MBPP. Thus, recovering a version gap does not by itself demonstrate transfer of successor knowledge. FB-P uses an established objective for this control, and we now explain its relationship to IRPO explicitly.
  2. Second, to separate the training objective from the choice of positive examples, we trained SFT on the same GSM8K positives, matched tokens and selected its learning rate on development data. FB-P retains a 23.2-point held-out accuracy advantage. Within the tested tuning budget, the benefit therefore persists beyond the choice of verified positives alone.
  3. Finally, the held-out gate audit shows three changes among eight scopes, including the Phi-3 MBPP gap failing to replicate. We consequently report both splits and restrict the original count to development data.

We would value your thoughts on this interpretation and would be glad to discuss any remaining alternative explanation.

Reviewer_BeSiOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

The paper addresses the problem of backporting newer language model gains to older ones; that is, rather than fully migrating to a newer model, use the performance gains in the new model to update the older model while preserving the existing performance.

The paper proposes CBack, which tests whether the new model's gains are backportable. CBack first finds the event pairs where the older model fails while the newer model succeeds using a verifier. It then uses these verified pairs to update the older model.

Their experiments show that not all model updates yield a measurable gain. Among the ones with a gain, successor-guided pairwise training improves performance only on GSM8K. The authors conclude that failure-aware contrast (looking at pairs where the older model failed) could be an effective alternative to successor-guided training.

Critical strengths

The paper addresses an interesting and well-motivated problem, particularly given the rapid pace at which language models are released and practical constraints that can prevent adopting newer versions.

The experimental section includes extensive comparisons and interesting negative results. I find it particularly interesting that all four scopes with a resolvable version gain admit improvement without successor guidance. These findings help distinguish the benefits of successor supervision from those of verifier-guided self-improvement.

Critical weaknesses
  • The presentation would benefit from clearer explanations. Some paragraphs are dense and difficult to follow. Examples: the last paragraph of the introduction, parts of Section 4.2, a sentence in Section 4.4: "Does an update work because a model's own failure enters it, or because of where its positive comes from?" and later sentences in the same section, and the second sentence of the conclusion. Figure 1 also seems overcrowded. My recommendation against acceptance is mainly due to these presentation issues.

  • A more thorough comparison to the prior work is needed to assess the novelty of the paper. For example, Section 2.1 in [1] explicitly studies backporting, so the claim of the paper that "Every established route for moving capability between models runs the other way." needs revision/justification. Generally, I could not fully understand what the paper contributes beyond existing verifier-guided training and self-improvement approaches. A more precise explanation would help.

[1] Efficient Model Development through Fine-tuning Transfer

Questions for authors
  • Please refer to my second point in the Weaknesses. In particular, could you please comment on how your setup and approach differ from [1] and from existing verifier-guided training and self-improvement approaches?
2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer BeSi

Thank you for identifying the passages that made the paper difficult to follow. We have rewritten each of them, starting with a concrete definition of the setting.

Presentation: the passages you identified

Some paragraphs are dense and difficult to follow.

Our response. The introduction now begins its protocol description as follows (p. 2):

CBack tests whether a newer model's measured gain can be recovered in an existing predecessor. A scope is one model-version pair, task family and verifier, for example Qwen2-1.5B-Instruct to Qwen2.5-1.5B-Instruct on GSM8K. The protocol has four stages (Figure 1b).

To make the protocol concrete, Section 3.2 (submitted §4.2, p. 4) follows one recorded failure–repair pair before introducing the acquisition rules. We then explain the purpose of the controls in Section 3.4 (submitted §4.4): holding positive examples fixed tests the objective, while holding the objective fixed tests the repair source. To keep this explanation consistent, we use scope throughout and work through its metrics numerically in §2. The four-stage introduction also provides a reading order for Figure 1(b). Finally, the conclusion distinguishes development recovery from held-out confirmation.

Prior work: what the comparison establishes

what the paper contributes beyond existing verifier-guided training and self-improvement approaches

Our response. You are right that Lin et al. [1] study backporting. We have corrected the forward-only description in the introduction and Related Work. Their method transfers a newer release's fine-tuning weight difference into an older base model. CBack studies repairs to an already post-trained predecessor, using verifier-accepted text, and measures recovery together with changes to existing successes and resource use.

With this distinction from weight transfer in place, we ask two empirical questions. First, does recovery require successor supervision? The new held-out tests confirm recovery without it on GSM8K, MATH and Qwen MBPP. Phi-3 MBPP's version gap does not replicate.

Second, is the GSM8K improvement explained by the verified positive examples alone? FB-P recovers 57.5% of the gap, while positive-only SFT on the same repairs stays 23.2 accuracy points behind [20.2, 26.1], even after matching training tokens and choosing its learning rate on development data. Thus, pairwise training retains an advantage at fixed positives in this setting.

To compare with [1] directly, we also evaluated its weight-transfer construction on our Qwen pair (Table 20). Held-out accuracy is 0.444, versus 0.471 for the deployed predecessor, and does not separate from the base model without transfer. We include input-template and answer-extraction checks so the comparison can be assessed beyond the headline score. This result concerns this pair, rather than weight transfer generally.

We now also cite IRPO [2] and describe FB-P as a related one-round preference control. These established objectives let us distinguish which recovery routes work and whether successor supervision adds value. That controlled finding is the contribution we foreground.

[1] Lin et al. Efficient Model Development through Fine-tuning Transfer. EMNLP 2025. https://aclanthology.org/2025.emnlp-main.131/

[2] Pang et al. Iterative Reasoning Preference Optimization. NeurIPS 2024.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Follow-up on presentation and contribution

Thank you again for the time and care you have put into reviewing our paper. We hope the revisions have made the setting and contribution easier to follow. Two changes are particularly relevant to your comments.

  1. First, to make the protocol concrete, we now walk through one failed answer and its verified repair before introducing the comparisons. We then explain why each comparison is needed: holding the positive examples fixed tests the training objective, while holding the objective fixed tests the source of the repair. This connects the terminology to the questions the experiments answer.
  2. Second, following your pointer to Lin et al., we corrected our inaccurate description of their work as forward-only transfer. We also make clear that the training objectives are established methods. Our contribution is the controlled study they enable in an already post-trained predecessor. Held-out GSM8K, MATH and Qwen MBPP confirm recovery without successor supervision, showing why recovery of a version gap should not itself be taken as evidence of successor knowledge transfer.

We would be happy to discuss any part of this explanation that still seems unclear.

Reviewer_EqsgOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper addresses a novel model upgrade verifier, CBack, which tests whether version upgrades preserves the gains and obtains new gain.

Critical strengths

This paper addresses an interesting upgrade method called backport, which enables more structured upgrades in LLMs compared to Distillation or standard model updates.

Critical weaknesses
  • Main concern. The overall writing of the paper includes numerous expressions or phrases that are written with no clear definition or chosen with ambiguous words, which make hard to follow for authors who are not familiar with backport.
    • Ex) Neither moves one verified gain backward into a model that must stay in service. -> what is verified gain?
    • Ex) Recovering “80% of an upgrade” therefore means nothing until that upgrade is shown to exist. -> what is 80% of an upgrade?
    • Ex) Cost stays in separate coordinates, so successor queries are never netted against a model’s own tokens. -> what coordinates?
    • Ex) A task x ∼ Dc belongs to a capability slice c fixed before any training. -> what is capability slice?
  • I’m not convinced how meaningful the “backport” is as an upgrade compared to non-backport version updates. More concrete results on why backport should be considered compared to distillation or standard update, e.g., its net gains is higher than those, or it provides complementary aspect that the other two cannot. Current justification is merely “wapping it in can violate contracts on latency, hardware, licensing, or behavior”.
Questions for authors

Please see weakness.

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Eqsg

The deployment question

I’m not convinced how meaningful the “backport” is as an upgrade compared to non-backport version updates.

Our response. Consider a deployment where a LoRA update is supported, while replacing the model requires a different integration and validation process. CBack asks how much of an upgrade can be recovered while retaining the deployed predecessor. The patch still needs validation. If replacement is available, using the successor directly obtains its full score.

We therefore measure recovery, changes to existing successes and adaptation cost together. The following example gives the quantities and their measured values.

The terminology, with one numerical example

what is 80% of an upgrade?

Our response. A scope fixes a model pair, task family and verifier: Qwen2-1.5B-Instruct, Qwen2.5-1.5B-Instruct, GSM8K and a final-number verifier. On held-out data the two models solve 47.1% and 71.2%, giving a 24.1-point version gap. We analyse recovery only when this gap is at least 3 points and its paired lower bound exceeds zero.

A failure–repair pair contains a rejected predecessor answer and a verifier-accepted answer to the same training task. Training on the predecessor's own such pairs gives FB-P, which reaches 60.9%. Its gain divided by the version gap is 57.5%, using unrounded scores. This is what a fraction such as “80% of an upgrade” measures.

The measured comparison with distillation

All rows use the sealed GSM8K evaluation of 1,319 tasks and five seeds (Tables 3 and 21):

RouteAccuracy gainGap recovered
GKD+0.0470.195
DistiLLM-2+0.0570.235
Uniform sequence-level KD+0.0580.241
SFT on successor repairs+0.0600.250
FB-S, pairwise training on those repairs+0.0860.356
FB-P, predecessor-only repairs+0.1390.575

FB-S and repair SFT use identical positives. FB-S also trains against the failed response. The whole table compares routes rather than equal compute. GKD and DistiLLM-2 improve on held-out GSM8K, despite their development regressions, and both splits are now shown.

Preservation and cost

FB-P fails 18.4% of previously solved tasks, versus 33.0% when the unchanged predecessor is resampled: 0.56 times that churn. Direct replacement has a lower ratio, 0.37. The reason to retain the predecessor is the deployment constraint, not a claim that its patch dominates replacement.

“Separate cost coordinates” means reporting successor calls, successor-generated tokens, own generated tokens and training tokens individually (Table 15). FB-S uses 1,311 successor calls, 403,658 successor tokens, 997,633 own tokens and 596,235 training tokens. FB-P uses no successor calls or tokens, but 2,070,054 own tokens and 513,967 training tokens. It exchanges successor access for additional self-generation.

Sections 1–2 now develop the motivation and metrics in this order. In this example, a deployment retaining its predecessor can recover 57.5% of the gap without successor supervision, with fewer negative flips than resampling.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Follow-up on the deployment setting

Thank you again for your time in reviewing our work. We hope our response has clarified why retaining the predecessor can be useful. We would like to connect that motivation more directly to the numerical comparison.

  1. First, we now state the deployment premise explicitly: an adapter update is feasible, while replacing the underlying model requires a different integration and validation process. The patch still needs validation. We therefore motivate CBack through this constraint, without claiming measured latency or licensing advantages.
  2. Within that setting, we measure how much of the successor's gain can be recovered while keeping the predecessor. The predecessor-only patch recovers 57.5% of the held-out GSM8K gap, compared with 24.1% for uniform sequence-level distillation. These are results under the evaluated configurations, not a comparison at equal total compute. This gives deployments that must retain the predecessor a concrete route to improvement: recovery without successor supervision, with negative flips at 0.56 times the unchanged predecessor's resampling churn.

We would welcome your thoughts on whether this makes the intended use case clearer.

Comments on the paper

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General response: clarified contribution and completed controls

Thank you for the reviews. We have revised the presentation and completed the controls needed to distinguish recovering a version gap from requiring successor supervision to recover it.

The result and the control behind it

On held-out GSM8K, the predecessor-only patch recovers 57.5% of the gap [51.6, 63.6], with negative flips at 0.56 times the predecessor's resampling churn. Positive-only SFT on exactly the same repairs, with matched training tokens and a development-selected learning rate, remains 23.2 accuracy points behind [20.2, 26.1]. Thus positive selection alone does not explain the pairwise training result in this setting.

The development-selected routes also recover on held-out MATH and Qwen MBPP. Phi-3 MBPP's gap does not replicate. Table 1 now shows the gate on both splits, including all three changed decisions.

Where to find the changes

The revised PDF accompanies these replies. Sections 1–3 define the protocol through a worked example. Section 5 and Appendices S–T contain the new comparisons. Section 6 corrects the positioning relative to Lin et al. and IRPO. The individual replies quote the concern being addressed and point to the revised passages and supporting tables.

Key passages discussed in our responses, along with selected captions, are now marked in deep blue for easier reference.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response Summary: Backporting and the Source of Recovery

Dear Reviewers,

We appreciate your recognition of the practical motivation for backporting and the care taken in evaluating recovery and preservation. Our original sealed GSM8K result already demonstrated that a deployed predecessor can recover 57.5% of the version gap without querying its successor. Your questions help distinguish what this result establishes, how it differs from prior work, and why the recovery occurs.

1. What does CBack contribute? — BeSi and Eqsg

CBack evaluates a specific deployment decision: how much of a measured version gain can be recovered inside the predecessor, at what cost to its existing successes, and whether the successor is needed. Unlike transferring an instruction-tuning weight delta into an older base model, CBack uses verified task-level repairs in an already post-trained predecessor. The worked example now makes these stages explicit. We also corrected the description of Lin et al.'s backporting work and situated the training objective within the existing preference-optimization family.

2. Is recovery attributable to successor knowledge? — Hnv9

The successor-free control was part of the original study precisely to test this question. Its recovery demonstrates that a version gap need not represent knowledge available only from the successor. We subsequently evaluated the registered MATH and MBPP test splits and audited the gap gate on held-out data. Reporting the development and held-out decisions together makes clear which gaps are supported on each split.

3. Does the failure comparison itself matter? — Hnv9

To isolate this mechanism on GSM8K, we held the verified positive answers fixed, matched training tokens, and selected the SFT learning rate on development data. FB-P retains a 23.2-percentage-point held-out accuracy advantage [20.2, 26.1] over positive-only SFT under this protocol. This directly supports a role for failure-aware contrast beyond the choice of positive examples.

We hope this brings the answers to the main questions together. We would be glad to discuss any point that still needs further evidence or explanation.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Summary of Major Contributions, Strengths, and Responses to Concerns

Dear AC, SAC, and PCs,

We sincerely appreciate your time and effort in managing the review process. We also appreciate the reviewers’ careful reading and their recognition of the practical motivation for backporting and the controls used to evaluate recovery and preservation. As the discussion concludes, we provide a concise summary of the paper’s contributions, the strengths identified by the reviewers, and the completed comparisons addressing their main questions. We hope this makes the evidence easier to assess together.

1. Core Contributions

  • A protocol for recovering version gains in a deployed predecessor. CBack first checks that a measurable version gap exists, then evaluates verified repairs through gap recovery, preservation relative to resampling churn, and separately reported costs. This makes the upgrade question testable for a predecessor that must remain in service.

  • Evidence separating recovery from successor dependence. On sealed GSM8K, predecessor-only repairs recover 57.5% of the version gap, with a 95% interval of 51.6–63.6%, without querying the successor. The rate of losing previously correct answers is 0.56 times the predecessor’s own resampling churn. Thus, recovering a newer release’s measured gain does not by itself establish that its answers were needed.

  • Efficient acquisition when successor repairs are used. In the original GSM8K experiment, querying the successor on predecessor failures yields 3.2 times as many admissible repairs per successor token as uniform querying. The protocol reports this benefit alongside the costs of successor-free alternatives.

2. Strengths Recognized by Reviewers

  • A practically motivated problem. BeSi highlighted constraints on adopting newer model releases, and Hnv9 recognized the formulation of localized upgrades with explicit attention to preserving existing successes. Eqsg also found structured backporting interesting.

  • Informative controls and evaluation. BeSi highlighted the successor-free findings. Hnv9 recognized the measurable-gap gate, the resampling baseline for preservation, and the sealed evaluation protocol.

3. Responses to Key Concerns

We have made the distinction from prior work explicit and completed the comparisons needed to test alternative explanations for recovery.

ReviewerConcernEvidence in the final manuscript
BeSi, Hnv9How does CBack differ from weight transfer and established preference training?Lin et al. transfer a whole fine-tuning weight update into an older base model. CBack evaluates individually verified repairs in an already post-trained predecessor, measuring recovery, preservation and cost together. Successor-free controls test whether successor access is needed.
EqsgWhat does backporting offer relative to distillation?On sealed GSM8K, predecessor-only repairs recover 57.5% of the gap, compared with 24.1% for uniform sequence distillation. Each route’s generation and training costs are reported separately.
Hnv9Could positive answers alone explain the GSM8K result?With the same 879 repairs, 98% of the pairwise arm’s training tokens and a development-selected learning rate, positive-only SFT still trails pairwise training by 23.2 held-out accuracy points [20.2, 26.1] (Appendix T).
Hnv9Do the findings extend beyond the original sealed GSM8K evaluation?Completed held-out evaluations confirm successor-free recovery on MATH and Qwen MBPP. Table 1 reports development and held-out gate decisions together, separating whether a gap exists from whether a selected route recovers it.

4. Concluding Remarks

CBack establishes how to measure and recover a version gain without assuming that recovery requires successor supervision. The original recovery and preservation results, matched-positive control, and held-out evaluations support this distinction. We hope this summary assists your final assessment, and we appreciate the time devoted to considering our work.

The authors of CBack

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.