- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This manuscript proposes DASTrack, a single‑object tracker that introduces the pre‑trained DINOv3 vision Transformer into single‑object tracking. The authors present Dense LoRA (DLoRA) as the backbone adaptation strategy, which spatially concatenates template and search images and aggregates multi‑layer intermediate features from the backbone. Built upon DLoRA, the paper develops template‑adaptive modulation (TAM), trajectory‑guided modulation (TGM), and a spatial refinement head (SRH) for iterative localization. The model is evaluated on seven tracking benchmarks with promising results, accompanied by abundant experimental analyses.
Critical strengths
This work specifically adapts DINOv3 for single‑object tracking. The proposed Dense LoRA (DLoRA) provides a practical backbone adaptation recipe: spatially concatenating template‑search inputs and aggregating multi‑layer intermediate features of the network. This design aligns with the intrinsic property of DINOv3. This exploration offers valuable references for future tracking research built upon DINO‑family foundation models.
Critical weaknesses
1.The validation of module effectiveness heavily relies on the paper’s multi‑stage training strategy, where previously trained modules are frozen when training new components. There is no end‑to‑end joint‑training baseline. It is therefore difficult to distinguish whether the observed performance gains come from the intrinsic capability of each module, or from residual compensation of later modules for features produced by frozen earlier components. 2.The discussion in the related‑work section is insufficient. The substantial novelty of this paper concentrates on the Dense LoRA (DLoRA) backbone adaptation for DINOv3, while TAM, TGM and SRH are incremental engineering improvements built upon well‑established paradigms. However, the manuscript fails to clearly draw the boundary between these customized modules and existing prior approaches.
Questions for authors
1.Some existing works adopt gaussian response maps. Why does the TGM module not directly use them as the Value in attention? 2.In Table 3, the multi-layer feature fusion (MLF) module of DLoRA shows counterintuitive results and the given explanation is flawed. Since the GOT-10k training set enjoys rich category diversity, intermediate-layer features are expected to be beneficial. Why does multi-layer fusion hurt performance?
my last evaluation
Thank you for the authors' response. Unfortunately, most of my concerns remain unresolved. Therefore, I will maintain my original score.