acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Associativity as Occam's Razor: Differentiable Measure of Algebraic Complexity

Abstract

Discovering discrete algebraic structures from data is a fundamental challenge in machine learning. However, standard deep learning models often struggle to learn generalizable algebraic rules, suggesting that their intrinsic inductive biases may be ill-suited for such tasks. Formalizing this intuition reveals a deeper theoretical issue: the literature currently lacks a precise, quantitative definition of algebraic simplicity. In this work, we resolve this gap by analyzing the global objective landscape of a canonical model for recovering discrete operation tables. We establish a lower bound for this objective and prove that attaining this bound entails a geometric alignment (collinearity) between the model's latent matrix representations. Furthermore, this lower bound implements an inverse penalty, which induces a full-rank unitarity bias—fundamentally opposing the standard low-rank bias in deep learning models. We establish that the objective over the feasible set is bounded below by an absolute floor determined solely by the target size. Attaining this absolute floor is structurally rigid, requiring the latent factorization to be perfectly unitary and collinear, which imposes a rigid algebraic homomorphism. Crucially, this homomorphism requirement transfers the associativity of matrix multiplication directly to the target operation. The global optimum exhibits a strict associativity gap, attaining the absolute minimum floor if and only if the target is a group isotope. Every global minimizer uniquely encodes the underlying group's left-regular representation (up to isotopy and unitary gauge). We empirically confirm that the minimum objective monotonically increases with the target's latent associativity violation ratio. These results formalize a novel differentiable inductive bias for deep learning—structural simplicity via latent associativity up to isotopy—offering a provably distinct alternative to low-dimensional representation. All foundational theorems are formalized in Lean 4.

Primary area:
learning theory
Keywords:
Grokking, Algebraic Completion, Global Landscape Analysis

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 15%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 3.00 over 3 reviews, above 85% of the others.
Reviewer_mGYgOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper analyzes the HyperCube objective for learning algebraic structures. It decomposes the objective into an inverse-scale term and a non-negative misalignment term. The paper proves that the minimum value is achieved if and only if the target is a group isotope, and characterizes the minimizers using the left-regular representation. The theoretical results are also formalized in Lean 4. The paper provides experiments on quasigroups of order 5-8 to study the relationship between the objective and associativity violations.

Critical strengths
  1. The main theoretical result is interesting. The matrix AM-GM inequality and its connection to associativity provide a good explanation for why the HyperCube objective favors group structures.

  2. The characterization of the global minimizers is useful. The paper also provides formal verification of the foundational results in Lean 4, which is a positive point.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The theoretical results are limited to exact reconstruction of fully observed operation tables. However, the main motivation is learning algebraic structures from partial observations. The paper does not provide results on sample complexity or generalization. It is unclear how much the theoretical analysis explains the empirical success of HyperCube in the actual learning setting.

  2. The experimental results are not entirely convincing. Figure 2 shows a correlation between the objective and associativity violations, but this does not establish a monotonic relationship. Also, the reported values are obtained using gradient descent and are not necessarily the global minima. The paper does not provide convergence guarantees for the optimizer.

  3. Theorem 9 claims a strict positive gap for non-group isotopes. However, the proof seems to show only that the lower bound cannot be attained. It is unclear whether a sequence of feasible solutions could approach the lower bound. This needs further clarification.

Questions for authors
  1. In Theorem 9, how do the authors establish that the infimum is strictly greater than 3|δ| for non-group isotopes? Is there a compactness or attainment argument?

  2. Which results are formally verified in Lean 4? Does the verification include the strict gap in Theorem 9?

  3. Can the authors provide experiments with partial observations to investigate whether the proposed associativity measure predicts generalization or sample efficiency?

2 comments

Thank you for highlighting the interest of our Matrix AM--GM inequality, global minimizer characterization, and Lean 4 formalization, as well as for your constructive questions on the infimum gap, verification scope, and learning implications.


W1: Theory is limited to exact reconstruction of full tables rather than partial observations / sample complexity.

A: Yes. Our theorems characterize full-observation structural selection, not partial-observation recovery rates. Please see Common Rebuttal (Joint Response, Point 3) for the exact-completion preference established here, the additional requirements for recovery, and the connection to our concurrent sample-complexity work. We address your requested partial-observation experiments separately below (Q3).


W2: Figure 2 does not establish strict monotonicity, GD values are not certified global minima, and optimizer convergence is not guaranteed.

A: We revised Section 5.1, Figure 2's caption, and Appendix D to distinguish training endpoints from certified global minima and describe the association as approximately monotonic. See Common Rebuttal (Joint Response, Point 2) for the theorem comparison and optimizer-convergence qualification.


W3 & Q1: How does Theorem 9 establish Hinf⁡(δ)>3∣δ∣\mathcal H_{\inf}(\delta) > 3|\delta| rather than just non-attainment—is there a compactness or attainment argument?

A: Thank you for catching this gap. Lemma 17 and Theorem 8 supply the missing near-floor compactness argument and establish the positive infimum gap. See Common Rebuttal (Joint Response, Point 1) and Appendix C.3.

Q2: Which results are formally verified in Lean 4, and does verification include the strict gap in Theorem 9?

A: Yes—every numbered proposition, lemma, theorem, and corollary in the revised manuscript IS formally verified in Lean 4 (axiom-free modulo Lean's standard [propext, Classical.choice, Quot.sound]), including the strict positive infimum gap (Lemma 17, Theorem 8, & Theorem 10), with the sole exception of Corollary 23 (finite-group subtable realization via Malcev's residual-finiteness theorem in Appendix E.3; the concrete counterexamples in App. E.3–E.4 and the coding-theoretic description-length bound in App. F are also analytical paper arguments). Specifically, the Lean formalization covers Proposition 0, Lemmas 1–5, Theorems 6–11, Lemmas 12–17, Theorems 18–19, Corollary 20, and Theorems 21–22. Please see the full theorem-by-theorem mapping table at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/HyperCube_Lean-4664/README.md.


Q3: Can partial-observation experiments test whether the associativity measure predicts generalization or sample efficiency?

A: Prior empirical work in Huh (2025, Figure 6)—now cited in our Introduction—directly studied partial-observation generalization, reporting an approximately monotonic inverse association between numerical estimates of normalized exact-fit sensitivity H(Θ∞)/(3n2)\mathcal H(\Theta_\infty)/(3n^2) and partial-observation sample efficiency (area under the test-accuracy curve across observed fractions), across both quasigroups and non-quasigroup operations.

While two separate empirical correlations do not prove a transitive causal guarantee, our theoretical results clarify what low exact-fit sensitivity means algebraically in both regimes:

  1. Within quasigroups (Section 5): Our Figure 2 shows an empirical positive association between numerical normalized sensitivity H~(Θ∞)\tilde{\mathcal H}(\Theta_\infty) and latent associativity violation ν(δ)\nu(\delta), with exact floor attainment proved exclusively for group isotopes (ν(δ)=0\nu(\delta)=0). Directly testing partial-observation sample efficiency against ν(δ)\nu(\delta) across the loop population is a natural empirical check that we can include if helpful during discussion.
  2. Beyond quasigroups (new Section 6): At the sensitivity floor, duplicate rows and columns force shared full-rank unitary input slices (Theorems 11 and 18), as illustrated by (a2+b2) mod 6(a^2+b^2) \bmod 6 (Figure 1, Right). Thus, Hinf⁡(δ)\mathcal H_{\inf}(\delta) reflects functional compression more broadly (both latent homomorphism and consistent input merging at the floor), whereas ν(δ)\nu(\delta) specifically measures latent non-associativity within quasigroups.
Reviewer_N7nAOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper builds on the HyperCube model, a trilinear factorization for learning the operation table of a finite quasigroup, and trains it with a gradient-norm regularizer. The authors analyze the constrained global minimum of this regularizer over all exact factorizations of a target table δ\delta. The research area, understanding why continuous optimization can recover discrete algebraic structure, is interesting. In general, the paper provides a good overview of the domain, but lacks a concrete motivation for the HyperCube model exclusively, which is the focus of this work.

Critical strengths

The authors study the HyperCube gradient-norm regularizer, a purely continuous object, and asks why it should favor group structure. They then establish a lower bound of 3∣δ∣3|\delta| together with a complete characterization of the equality case. The key technical tool, the matrix AM--GM inequality (Lemma~5), is clean, non-obvious and, as far as I have verified, correct. The experiments serve as appropriate sanity checks of the theory. The accompanying Lean formalization is a nice addition, although I have not verified it.

Critical weaknesses

W1 I find it unclear why the HyperCube model deserves such a detailed analysis. Could the authors please clarify this? The paper provides no evidence that the identified mechanism transfers to the models that motivated the research (MLPs/transformers trained on modular arithmetic). While the main theorem establishing that unitary regular representations are the unique minimizers of the objective is elegant, it may simply reflect the design of the regularizer rather than reveal an inductive bias of deep learning or explain a deeper phenomenon.

W2 I have a concern about the proof of Theorem 9 and its consequences, and I would appreciate clarification from the authors.

As I understand it, Theorems 7 and 8 together establish the following: for every Θ in the feasible set F_δ, we have ℋ(Θ) ≥ 3|δ|, and equality ℋ(Θ) = 3|δ| is impossible when δ is not a group isotope. This is a pointwise statement:

ℋ(Θ) > 3|δ| for all Θ in F_δ.

The authors then pass from this to H_inf(δ) > 3|δ|, i.e., to a statement about the infimum. I do not see how this step is justified. A pointwise strict inequality does not imply a strict inequality for the infimum unless the infimum is attained, and I do not see why attainment should hold here, since F_δ does not appear to be compact.

If this step cannot be repaired, what remains established is only the weaker dichotomy that "group isotopes attain 3|δ|, whereas non-group isotopes do not attain it." This is compatible with H_inf(δ) = 3|δ| for every quasigroup of a given order.

In that case, H_inf would not separate groups from non-groups at all, the claimed "associativity gap" would be unsupported, and the central claim that H_inf measures algebraic complexity would not be established. In particular, nothing in the paper appears to exclude the possibility that H_inf(δ) = 3n² for all quasigroups of order n.

Questions for authors

See weaknesses. I am inclined to raise my score if the authors can answer those questions thoughtfully.

3 comments

Thank you for carefully checking our proofs—especially the Matrix AM--GM inequality—and for your constructive critique, which directly led to the new Positive Infimum Gap proof (Theorem 8) in the revised manuscript.


W1: Why analyze the HyperCube model specifically? No evidence mechanism transfers to MLPs/Transformers on modular arithmetic; result may reflect regularizer design rather than deep learning inductive bias.

A: This work is motivated by the parallel between matrix completion and algebraic completion as canonical testbeds for generalization theory. Deep linear networks—simplified linear counterparts of standard nonlinear networks—proved foundational in matrix completion for rigorously characterizing how gradient-based learning exploits low-rank linear dependencies among rows and columns (e.g., Gunasekar et al., 2017; Arora et al., 2019). For symbolic operations, however, entries are discrete symbols without numerical proximity, and an analogous characterization of a differentiable inductive bias for algebraic completion was missing. Our paper addresses this question in a canonical factorization model and characterizes a distinct structural bias—functional compression: representing an operation through shared algebraic composition and identity propagation among full-rank matrix embeddings, rather than low-rank linear interpolation.

  1. Why the theorem is not built into the regularizer by design:

    • Expressivity:

      As formalized in Proposition 0, the factorization model Tr(AaBbCc)\text{Tr}(A_a B_b C_c) can exactly fit every finite binary operation table δ\delta (associative or not, cancellative or not).

    • Generic sensitivity penalty:

      The regularizer H(Θ)=∑supp(δ)n∥∇ΘTabc(Θ)∥2\mathcal H(\Theta) = \sum_{\text{supp}(\delta)} n \|\nabla_\Theta T_{abc}(\Theta)\|^2 is simply the squared parameter-gradient norm of the model's predictions on supported entries (which for quasigroups is proportional to the trace of the reconstruction-loss Hessian on Fδ\mathcal F_\delta). It contains no commutators, no associator terms (a∘b)∘c−a∘(b∘c)(a\circ b)\circ c - a\circ(b\circ c), no orthogonality/unitarity constraints, and no group axioms.

    • Emergent algebraic structure at the floor:

      That attaining the universal sensitivity floor 3∣supp(δ)∣3|\text{supp}(\delta)| under exact fit forces full-rank unitary participating slices (κ=1\kappa = 1, in contrast to ℓ2\ell_2-induced rank reduction) and local collinearity—which for quasigroups (after loop isotopy and unitary gauge synchronization) forces an injective homomorphism

      ρ(a∘b)=ρ(a)ρ(b)\rho(a\circ b)=\rho(a)\rho(b)

      whose normalized trace identity Tr(ρ(g))=I{g=e}\text{Tr}(\rho(g)) = \mathbb I_{\{g=e\}} (the left-regular character) uniquely identifies the left-regular representation (Lemma 14 in Appendix B.2), and for arbitrary operations (new Section 6, Theorem 11 & Corollary 23) forces duplicate-row/column merging onto a reduced table that embeds into a finite-group multiplication table—is a nontrivial consequence of how parameter sensitivity interacts with operator composition. Appendix F quantifies the resulting lossless description-length advantage.

  2. Broader ML implication:

    The broader implication is that sensitivity minimization can favor functional generalization by selecting shared compositional mechanisms. We establish its exact-fit structural foundation; partial-observation generalization is left open here (Section 7) and studied in our concurrent work.

    Preliminary experiments in a separate study also suggest a predictive benefit of sensitivity regularization beyond factorization networks: in a quadratic MLP (QMLP), it improves prequential prediction over ℓ2\ell_2 regularization on structured algebraic completion tasks.

    Please see Common Rebuttal (Joint Response, Point 3) for the completion-selection implications.


W2: pointwise inequality does not imply a strict positive gap, since F_δ is not compact.

A: You are right. Lemma 17 and Theorem 8 supply the missing near-floor compactness argument and establish the positive infimum gap. See Common Rebuttal (Joint Response, Point 1) and Appendix C.3.

I thank the authors for their response and for the effort they put into revising the manuscript. The revisions address my main concern and substantially improve the paper. I am therefore inclined to raise my score.

However, the revision also introduces a new contribution and adds numerous pages to the main paper and the appendix, significantly expanding the content and altering the scope. In my view, these changes go beyond the scope of a typical revision.

Thank you for recognizing that the revisions address your main concern and substantially improve the paper.

Regarding your concern about scope, the positive-infimum-gap theorem directly addresses your W2. Section 6 is indeed an extension, broadening the analysis from quasigroups to the full class of finite binary operations. But it addresses the same structural-selection question and builds on the same mechanisms developed through Theorem 8. The original quasigroup results do not depend on this extension.

The extension’s structural message is simple: at the sensitivity floor, a local collision must reflect global redundancy. Any two columns that agree in one row must be identical throughout: i.e., (∃a: a∘b=a∘b′)  ⟹  (∀x: x∘b=x∘b′)(\exists a:\ a\circ b=a\circ b')\implies(\forall x:\ x\circ b=x\circ b'), since AaA_a is unitary,

\quad\Longrightarrow\quad B_b=B_{b'}.$$ Merging duplicate columns (and rows) yields a reduced table that embeds in a group-isotope table. This connects compression through input redundancy with the algebraic composition characterized in the original quasigroup setting. The revised manuscript remains within the permitted extended page limit; appendix material consists of detailed proofs, to which we also provide Lean formalization for verification support. Nevertheless, to improve readability, we would be happy to condense Section 6 to the above structural takeaway and an illustrative example, leaving the full characterization and proofs in the appendix so that the original quasigroup results remain the paper’s focus. We would also welcome the area chair’s guidance on the appropriate treatment of this extension within the revision.
Reviewer_JdjPOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
3
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The authors focus on the problem of discovering unknown discrete algebraic structures from data. In particular, they analyze in detail the HyperCube method to determine why it works well from a mathematical perspect. They derive various bounds on the optimization used in the HyperCube method under various properties of the quasigroup of interest. Finally, the authors include some numerical experiments to demonstrate their theoretical results.

Critical strengths

S1: The analysis of the HyperCube objective is thorough and derives some nice bounds.

S2: The development of the theory is easy to follow for the most part.

Critical weaknesses

W1: I had a hard time understanding the intuition behind the matrices X,Y, and Z. This in turn made my understanding of the later ideas suffer. I wonder if the authors have any intuitive way to think about these matrices.

W2: It is a little unclear to me what the numerical experiments show. Are they showing the results of Theorem 9? That would be great if so.

W2.1: The caption of Figure 2 has two sets of descriptions for each frame, it should just have one.

W2.2: This the left frame of Figure 2 shows trajectories, but it is impossible to tell where the trajectories end up. Or to even really distinguish different trajectories by color and what they mean. I guess the middle frame is where the trajectories end up?

W2.3: It looks like there are some points about 1.0 on the y-axis, can that be right?

W2.4: In the right frame, should the x-axis label be nu(delta)/|delta|? It would be nice in the caption to say that it is the associativity violation normalized by the target size |delta|.

Questions for authors

Q1: It might be helpful to say what delta is somewhere in the introduction before you use it in our contributions. You describe |delta| as the target size in line 75 and refer to it again in line 80. It makes sense to introduce the math and notation in section 3.1 as you do, but it leaves me a little confused in line 80 when you say "the absolute floor is attained if and only if delta is a group isotope".

Q2: Line 148 What is meant by "local algebraic constraints propagate globally"?

Q3: In figure 1 (Left), a,b, and c appear to point to a single component of A,B, and C respectively. However, I should think of A_a as an (n x n) slice of A (or equivalently, the whole face of the cube that it is pointing at), correct? Is there any way to make this more clear?

Q4: What is the insight that Theorem 6 shows? My understanding was that H(theta) = B(theta) + R(theta), which Lemma 1 shows that R(theta) is nonnegative. So clearly H(theta) >= B(theta). Then B(theta) >= H*(T(theta)) by Lemma 4 so clearly H(theta) >= H*(T(theta)). What am I missing? Is it somehow that Lemma 4 depends on being in the collinear set, and Theorem 6 you aren't in the collinear set?

Q5: I was temporarily confused when you mentioned feasible factorization on Line 336, it would probably be better to use the same term in Definition 1 (and maybe reference Defintion 1) so feasible set or feasible factorization in both places.

Q6: In line 433, how can an isotope be more or less associative? Isn't associativity dependent only on the binary operator that acts on the elements of Q? And isn't the isotope just a permutation of the elements of Q, aka a relabeling?

4 comments

Thank you for the constructive feedback and for highlighting the clarity and thoroughness of our theoretical bounds.


W1: Intuition behind matrices X,Y,ZX, Y, Z in Eq. (8)?

A: An intuitive way to view Eq. (8) (now Eq. (7) in the revised manuscript) is as a normalized balancedness across latent interfaces. We renamed Lemma 2 to Shared Balancedness and added brief intuition in Footnote 3.

In a deep linear network WLWL−1⋯W1W_L W_{L-1} \cdots W_1, standard balancedness between adjacent layers dictates Wl+1⊤Wl+1=WlWl⊤W_{l+1}^\top W_{l+1} = W_l W_l^\top, matching the singular directions and squared singular values entering and leaving each shared interface (e.g., Arora et al., 2018, Definition 1).

In our model, Tr(AaBbCc)\text{Tr}(A_a B_b C_c) forms a cyclic three-factor product. On the collinear set (with nonzero supported predictions), the local alignment identities force normalized balancedness between adjacent factors on each supported triple (a,b,c)(a,b,c): e.g.,

Z=Aa†Aa∥Aa∥2=BbBb†∥Bb∥2,Z = \frac{A_a^\dagger A_a}{\|A_a\|^2} = \frac{B_b B_b^\dagger}{\|B_b\|^2},

where the normalization is due to the sensitivity objective (rather than ℓ2\ell_2).

Because every input pair (a,b)(a,b) occurs in a binary operation table, ZZ is globally shared across all indices (and for quasigroup targets, XX and YY are also globally shared). Lemma 3 uses this shared ZZ to prove that all participating slices Aa,Bb,CcA_a, B_b, C_c have a common rank nκn\kappa; Lemma 4 then further establishes the global shared structure as the output-dependent lower bound within the collinear set, such as globally shared slice norms and scaled-unitarity.


W2: What do the numerical experiments show—Theorem 9?

A: Yes—Figure 2 is consistent with the group-isotope floor attainment and positive gap of Theorem 9 (now Theorem 10), and also reveals an empirical graded trend with ν(δ)\nu(\delta) beyond it. Please see Common Rebuttal (Joint Response, Point 2) above and revised Section 5.1 for details.

W2.1: Duplicate descriptions in Figure 2 caption.

A: Thank you for catching this editing artifact. It is fixed in the revised caption.

W2.2: Hard to see where trajectories end up or distinguish colors in Figure 2 (Left); is Middle the endpoint zoom?

A: Yes, your reading is exact:

  • Left panel: Shows full optimization trajectories Θt\Theta_t, starting from high alignment gap R~\tilde{\mathcal R} on the right and sweeping right-to-left toward decreasing H~δ\tilde{\mathcal H}_\delta (contour lines) (toward smaller R~\tilde{\mathcal R} and larger B~\tilde{\mathcal B}).
  • Middle panel: Provides a higher resolution view of the final points Θ∞\Theta_\infty where those trajectories terminate by zooming into a small box [0,0.85]×[0.75,1.05][0, 0.85] \times [0.75, 1.05].
  • Colors: Both trajectories and endpoints are colored by the target's normalized latent associativity violation ν(δ)\nu(\delta) (dark purple for group isotopes with ν(δ)=0\nu(\delta)=0, progressing to lighter colors (green and yellow) for larger violations).

We have clarified the relationship between the Left and Middle panels, the right-to-left sweep, and the colors in Section 5.1, Appendix D.3, and the Figure 2 caption (and updated the figure annotations with trajectory direction/endpoint cues for visual clarity).

W2.3: Are points near 1.0 on the y-axis right?

A: Yes: those points near (R~,B~)=(0,1)(\tilde{\mathcal R}, \tilde{\mathcal B}) = (0,1) are the floor-attaining group-isotope endpoints. We adjusted the axis limits in Figure 2 so these endpoints are clearly visible rather than clipped at the border.

W2.4: Should Figure 2 (Right) x-axis be ν(δ)/∣δ∣\nu(\delta)/|\delta|, and should the caption note normalization by ∣δ∣|\delta|?

A: Thank you for pointing out this notation mismatch. The Figure 2 (Right) plot already correctly used the latent normalized associativity violation counts, but the caption and x-label used the older notation: ν(δ)=nν(δ)/∣supp(δ)∣\nu(\delta)=n_\nu(\delta)/|\text{supp}(\delta)|, where nν(δ)n_\nu(\delta) denoted the raw unnormalized count. The updated text and figure now use the correct notation.

Q1: Define δ\delta before Section 1.2; "δ\delta is a group isotope" is confusing.

A: Agreed. In Section 1.2 (Our Contributions), we now explicitly introduce δ\delta on first use as a "target operation table δ\delta" and write ∣supp(δ)∣|\text{supp}(\delta)| for the target support size (n2n^2). We also replaced the shorthand "δ\delta is a group isotope" with the precise statement that "the target is isotopic to a group" (or "isotopic to a group operation table").

Q2: Meaning of "local algebraic constraints propagate globally" (Line 148)?

A: This refers to how the local algebraic identities in Eq. (6) (collinearity) propagate through supported triples via reused slices to enforce global shared structure—such as shared balancedness (Lemma 2), shared rank (Lemma 3), the equality conditions of Lemma 4 and Theorem 6 (shared norm and scaled-unitarity), and ultimately at the floor an injective homomorphism (for quasigroups, Lemma 13) or duplicate-row/column merging (beyond quasigroups, Theorem 18).

Q3: Does AaA_a denote an n×nn\times n slice in Figure 1 (Left), and can this be clearer?

A: Yes, fixing a∈Qa \in Q selects an entire matrix slice AaA_a. We replaced Figure 1 (Left) with a standard tensor-network diagram.

Q4: What does Theorem 6 add beyond H=B+R≥B\mathcal H = \mathcal B + \mathcal R \ge \mathcal B (Lemma 1) and B≥H∗\mathcal B \ge \mathcal H^* (Lemma 4)—that Lemma 4 requires the collinear set?

A: Yes! Lemma 4 (Bδ(Θ)≥Hδ∗(T(Θ))\mathcal B_\delta(\Theta) \ge \mathcal H^*_\delta(T(\Theta))) only holds on the collinear set Mδ\mathcal M_\delta (where Rδ(Θ)=0\mathcal R_\delta(\Theta) = 0), because its proof relies on the spectral projection identity κ≤1\kappa \le 1 (Lemma 3), which itself requires collinearity (Rδ=0\mathcal R_\delta = 0).

Outside Mδ\mathcal M_\delta, Bδ(Θ)\mathcal B_\delta(\Theta) can actually drop below Hδ∗(T(Θ))\mathcal H^*_\delta(T(\Theta)) (for instance, in Figure 2 Middle, non-collinear points with R~>0\tilde{\mathcal R} > 0 regularly have B~<1\tilde{\mathcal B} < 1), so chaining H≥Bδ\mathcal H \ge \mathcal B_\delta with Lemma 4 is invalid when Rδ>0\mathcal R_\delta > 0.

Theorem 6 removes the collinearity assumption altogether, proving H(Θ)≥Hδ∗(T(Θ))\mathcal H(\Theta) \ge \mathcal H^*_\delta(T(\Theta)) for arbitrary parameters Θ\Theta via the noncommutative Matrix AM--GM inequality (Lemma 5):

any drop in Bδ\mathcal B_\delta below Hδ∗\mathcal H^*_\delta outside Mδ\mathcal M_\delta is more than compensated by the misalignment Rδ\mathcal R_\delta. We retitled Lemma 4 (Collinear Output-Dependent Bound) and Theorem 6 (Global Output-Dependent Bound) and added an explicit bridging paragraph at the start of Section 4 to highlight this exact distinction.

Q5: Unify "feasible set" / "feasible factorization" terminology across Definition 1 and Line 336.

A: Thank you—we updated Definition 1 (Feasible Set) to explicitly state "We call Θ∈Fδ\Theta \in \mathcal F_\delta a factorization of δ\delta," added Proposition 0 showing Fδ\mathcal F_\delta is always nonempty, and unified the terminology across Definition 1 and Theorem 7.

Q6: How can an isotope be more or less associative if isotopy is just a relabeling of QQ (Line 433)?

A: A single synchronized permutation ϕ\phi applied simultaneously to both inputs and the output (ϕ(a)∘′ϕ(b)=ϕ(a∘b)\phi(a) \circ' \phi(b) = \phi(a \circ b)) is an isomorphism, which indeed preserves associativity. By contrast, an isotopy (Definition 3) applies three independent permutations (ϕ,ψ,χ)∈Sn3(\phi, \psi, \chi) \in S_n^3 to the row inputs, column inputs, and output symbols: δabc∗=δϕ(a)ψ(b)χ(c)\delta^*_{abc} = \delta_{\phi(a)\psi(b)\chi(c)}.

Independent relabeling does not preserve associativity. For example, on Z3\mathbb Z_3, subtraction a∘b=(a−b) mod 3a \circ b = (a - b) \bmod 3 is isotopic to addition (a+b) mod 3(a + b) \bmod 3 (simply permute column labels via b↦−b mod 3b \mapsto -b \bmod 3), yet addition is associative while subtraction is not: (0−1)−1≡1≢0≡0−(1−1)(mod3)(0 - 1) - 1 \equiv 1 \not\equiv 0 \equiv 0 - (1 - 1) \pmod 3. Because our sensitivity objective H\mathcal H is invariant under all three permutations Sn3S_n^3, a target table δ\delta may fail associativity in its given labeling while still being isotopic to an associative group. Minimizing the violation count over all isotopic loop representatives L(δ)\mathfrak L(\delta) in Eq. (17) makes ν(δ)\nu(\delta) isotopy-invariant, so ν(δ)=0\nu(\delta)=0 if and only if δ\delta is isotopic to a group (see Appendix A.1 for a side-by-side comparison of isomorphism vs. isotopy).

Reviewer_JdjPOpenReview ↗

Response to Rebuttal

Thank you for clarifying many of my questions and concerns. I believe my original score of a 3 is fair, so I maintain it.

Thank you for revisiting our responses. Could you please clarify which soundness and presentation concerns remain unresolved after our revisions? In particular, are there claims or proof steps you still find insufficiently justified, or explanations that remain unclear?

Comments on the paper

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Common Rebuttal

Dear reviewers, Thank you for your thoughtful and constructive feedback.

To frame our responses, we first restate the paper’s central question and contribution.

Core Message and Motivation.

How can a continuous learning objective favor functional compression—representing discrete data through shared algebraic composition—rather than geometric compression via low-dimensional features and linear dependencies, as in low-rank matrix completion? In a canonical factorization model for algebraic operation recovery tasks, we show that parameter-sensitivity minimization under exact reconstruction induces precisely this bias, keeping symbol matrix embeddings full-rank while selecting exact algebraic structure. At the universal sensitivity floor, local alignment identities at individual table entries propagate globally through reused matrix representations to enforce consistent algebraic composition—without hardcoding group axioms or unitarity into the architecture or regularizer.


Your feedback guided the revisions summarized below.

Summary of Manuscript Revisions

We have made the following substantive and expository improvements and updates to our Lean 4 formalization:

  • Unified Notation & Definitions (Sections 1.2 & 2):

    Introduced δ\delta on first use with explicit support supp(δ)\text{supp}(\delta) (∣supp(δ)∣=n2|\text{supp}(\delta)| = n^2, replacing ∣δ∣|\delta|).

    Explicitly defined the sensitivity objective H(Θ)=∑(a,b,c)∈supp(δ)n∥∇ΘTabc(Θ)∥2\mathcal{H}(\Theta) = \sum_{(a,b,c)\in\text{supp}(\delta)} n \Vert \nabla_\Theta T_{abc}(\Theta) \Vert ^2.

    Restricted the unitary set Uδ\mathcal U_\delta to participating slices on the support (Definition 2).

    Unified "factorization of δ\delta" in Definition 1 (with Fδ≠∅\mathcal F_\delta \neq \emptyset formalized as Proposition 0).

  • Reframed High-Level Exposition (Abstract, Section 1, & Section 7):

    Rewrote the Abstract, Introduction/Contributions (Section 1.1–1.2), and Conclusion to foreground the broader conceptual takeaways: how sensitivity minimization favors functional compression via shared algebraic composition, how local identities propagate globally through reused representations, and how this contrasts with geometric compression in low-rank matrix completion.

  • Clarified Selection Mechanism & Theorem Roles (Sections 1–4):

    Clarified how local alignment propagates into shared balancedness, rank, and scaled-unitarity, and how Matrix AM--GM extends the bound beyond the collinear set.

  • Clarified End-to-End Proof Logic & Structural Selectivity (Sections 4–6):

    Clarified the proof chain from universal realizability and the sensitivity floor to structural characterization and the positive infimum gap.

  • Calibrated Empirical Analysis & Figure 2 (Section 5.1 & Appendix D):

    Updated Figure 2 and its caption to reconcile ν(δ)\nu(\delta) (Eq. (17)), clarified the trajectories and zoom region for the training endpoints Θ∞\Theta_\infty, and highlighted the red H~δ=1\tilde{\mathcal{H}}_\delta = 1 contour (the proved global lower bound of Theorem 6) alongside the empirical cyan dotted reference (suggesting a stronger alignment-dependent lower bound left open for future analysis).

Quick Numbering Guide (Submitted →\to Revised):

  • Eq. (8) →\to Eq. (7) (Shared Balancedness); Lemmas 1–5 and Theorems 6–7 unchanged.
  • Proposition 0 (new, Appendix B): Exact Factorization Exists (Fδ≠∅\mathcal F_\delta \neq \emptyset).
  • Theorem 8 (new, Section 4 & Appendix C.3.2): Positive Infimum Gap (supported by new Lemma 17, Spectral No-Escape, in Appendix C.3.1).
  • Theorem 8 →\to Theorem 9: Unitary Collinearity   ⟺  \iff Group Isotope (with supporting Lemmas 12–15 in Appendix B.2).
  • Theorem 9 →\to Theorem 10: Global Optimality for Quasigroups.
  • Theorem 11 (new, Section 6): Exact Reduced Unitary Factorization (with Theorems 18–22 & Corollary 23 in Appendix E, and description length in Appendix F).

New Results

The revised manuscript includes the following new results.

  • Rigorous Positive Infimum Gap (Theorem 8 & Lemma 17, Section 4 & Appendices C.3; Theorem 10):

    Repaired the pointwise-to-infimum step identified by Reviewers N7nA and mGYg. Without assuming global compactness of Fδ\mathcal F_\delta, we prove that any feasible sequence approaching the floor 3∣supp(δ)∣3|\text{supp}(\delta)| remains bounded after zeroing unused output slices, yielding a floor-attaining limit and establishing a uniform positive gap Hinf⁡(δ)≥3∣supp(δ)∣+εn\mathcal H_{\inf}(\delta) \ge 3|\text{supp}(\delta)| + \varepsilon_n across all non-floor-attaining operations of order nn—and hence across all non-group-isotope quasigroups of order nn (Theorem 10).

  • Extension Beyond Quasigroups & Description Length (Section 6, Theorem 11, Appendices E & F):

    Characterized floor attainment for arbitrary binary operations (including non-cancellative ones) via collision rigidity, reduced unitary factorizations, and finite-group subtable embeddings (Theorems 18–22 and Corollary 23 in Appendix E; illustrated in Figure 1 Right by the floor-attaining, reducible non-quasigroup table (a2+b2) mod 6(a^2+b^2) \bmod 6), and proved an O(nlog⁡n)\mathcal O(n\log n) vs. Θ(n2log⁡n)\Theta(n^2\log n) lossless description-length separation between group-isotope and generic quasigroup tables (Appendix F).

  • Newly Added Appendix Sections:

    Added Appendix C.3 on the positive infimum gap, Appendix E on arbitrary binary operations, and Appendix F on description length.


Joint Response on Key Shared Points.

  1. Positive Infimum Gap Without Global Compactness (Reviewers N7nA W2; mGYg W3 & Q1):

    Reviewers N7nA and mGYg rightly noted that pointwise strictness (H(Θ)>3n2\mathcal{H}(\Theta) > 3n^2 on Fδ\mathcal F_\delta) does not by itself exclude an unbounded sequence Θk∈Fδ\Theta_k \in \mathcal F_\delta with H(Θk)→3n2\mathcal{H}(\Theta_k) \to 3n^2 in the non-compact feasible set.

    We completely repaired this gap via Lemma 17 (Spectral No-Escape, App. C.3.1) and Theorem 8 (Positive Infimum Gap, Section 4 & proof in App. C.3.2). Without assuming global compactness or non-group infimum attainment, we prove near-floor compactness: if H(Θk)→3n2\mathcal{H}(\Theta_k) \to 3n^2 on Fδ\mathcal F_\delta, every supported triple's 3n×3n3n\times 3n block-cyclic matrix MkM_k satisfies Tr(Mk3)=1\text{Tr}(M_k^3)=1 and ∥Mk2∥2→1\Vert M_k^2 \Vert ^2 \to 1,

    which confines its Schur eigenvalues near cube roots of unity (where no two sum to zero) and bounds all off-diagonal entries inductively (sup⁡k∥Mk∥<∞\sup_k \Vert M_k \Vert < \infty). Zeroing unused output slices preserves feasibility and H\mathcal{H}, yielding a convergent subsequence whose limit attains H(Θ∗)=3n2\mathcal{H}(\Theta_*)=3n^2. Thus Hinf⁡(δ)=3n2\mathcal{H}_{\inf}(\delta)=3n^2 if and only if the floor is attained; taking the minimum gap over the finitely many non-attaining operations of order nn yields a uniform gap Hinf⁡(δ)≥3∣supp(δ)∣+ϵn\mathcal{H}_{\inf}(\delta) \ge 3|\text{supp}(\delta)| + \epsilon_n (ϵn>0\epsilon_n > 0) across all non-floor-attaining operations—and hence across all non-group-isotope quasigroups of order nn (Theorem 10).

  2. What Figure 2 Shows & Empirical Calibration (Reviewers JdjP W2; mGYg W2):

    Figure 2 shows optimization trajectories and training endpoints, with sensitivity normalized by Hδ∗(T(Θ))\mathcal{H}^*_\delta(T(\Theta)). We compare these observations with the predictions of Theorem 10 (old Theorem 9):

    • Floor attainment vs. positive gap:

      Training endpoints Θ∞\Theta_\infty approach the theoretical floor (R~,B~)=(0,1)(\tilde{\mathcal R}, \tilde{\mathcal B})=(0,1) (H~δ=1\tilde{\mathcal{H}}_\delta = 1) exclusively for group isotopes (ν(δ)=0\nu(\delta)=0), while all non-group-isotope targets (ν(δ)>0\nu(\delta)>0) remain separated above H~δ=1\tilde{\mathcal{H}}_\delta = 1 with R~>0\tilde{\mathcal R} > 0.

      This is consistent with Theorem 10 without requiring optimizer convergence guarantees: for group isotopes, approaching the universal lower bound 3n23n^2 numerically upper-bounds Hinf⁡(δ)\mathcal{H}_{\inf}(\delta) near the floor, while for non-group isotopes the positive infimum gap ≥3n2+ϵn\ge 3n^2+\epsilon_n is proved analytically (Theorem 8), not inferred from uncertified GD endpoints.

    • Graded empirical trend:

      Beyond the theorem's zero-versus-positive gap characterization, Figure 2 (Right) shows an approximately monotonic positive association between normalized complexity H~δ(Θ∞)\tilde{\mathcal{H}}_\delta(\Theta_\infty) and latent associativity violation ν(δ)\nu(\delta).

We revised Section 5.1 and Appendix D to refer to "training endpoints Θ∞\Theta_\infty" and "approximately monotonic" association throughout.

  1. Generalization and Partial-Observation Implications (Reviewer mGYg W1 & Q3; related concern in N7nA W1):

    Our results characterize full-observation structural selection, not sample-complexity or partial-observation recovery bounds (Introduction and Conclusion). They nevertheless identify a structural preference among candidate completions.

    Completion selection: Given observations Ω⊂Q×Q\Omega \subset Q \times Q, the partial-observation exact-fit problem optimizes parameters directly:

    \mathcal{H}_{\Omega}(\Theta).$$ Here $T_{\Omega}$ restricts predictions to observed input pairs, and $\mathcal{H}_{\Omega}$ sums sensitivity over their observed supported triples. By contrast, every consistent full table $\bar{\delta}$ is exactly realizable (Proposition 0), and its full-table complexity defines an idealized completion-selection criterion: $$\min_{\bar{\delta}:\, \bar{\delta}_{\Omega} = \delta_{\Omega}} \mathcal{H}_{\inf}(\bar{\delta}) \quad = \min_{\bar{\delta}:\, \bar{\delta}_{\Omega} = \delta_{\Omega}} \inf_{\Theta \in \mathcal{F}_{\bar{\delta}}} \mathcal{H}_{\bar{\delta}}(\Theta).$$ where $\mathcal{H}_{\bar{\delta}}$ sums sensitivity over the completion's full support. The second criterion compares exact full-table completions; it is not equivalent to the first problem, where unobserved predictions need not be one-hot and the sensitivity objective uses only observed support. Among quasigroup completions, the floor $3n^2$ is attained exactly by group isotopes; all others satisfy $\mathcal{H}_{\inf}(\bar{\delta}) \ge 3n^2 + \epsilon_n$ (Theorems 8 and 10). For arbitrary operations, Theorem 11 characterizes floor attainment via reduced unitary factorizations, with the same gap separating all non-attaining completions (Theorem 8). **Recovery foundation:** Recovery requires sampling conditions that rule out competing low-sensitivity completions and a link between partial-support regularization and full-table complexity. Matrix AM--GM and equality rigidity (Lemma 5), gauge synchronization (Lemma 12), and left-regular character uniqueness (Lemma 14) supply the analytical tools. Our concurrent sample-complexity work builds on these tools to study how functional compression enables generalization through shared algebraic composition. Local rigidity identities follow from saturation of the sensitivity bound at observed entries, without requiring full-table observations. The concurrent analysis studies conditions under which these identities propagate through shared representations and uniquely determine unobserved outputs.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.