- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes FinRAIN, a reliability-aware news ingestion framework for LLM-based financial sentiment analysis and trading systems. FinRAIN assesses financial news along five dimensions: Market Relevance, Source Attribution, Information Novelty, Headline Exaggeration, and Stakeholder Bias. These assessments can be augmented with external knowledge through either pipeline-based or agentic retrieval. The paper evaluates FinRAIN from two perspectives. First, it examines whether reliability-weighted sentiment signals produced by five sentiment models achieve better alignment with subsequent stock returns. Second, it incorporates reliability annotations into single-stage and two-stage LLM-based trading frameworks and evaluates their trading performance. Experiments on financial news covering 20 U.S. stocks report improvements in sentiment-return correlation, directional hit rate, and risk-adjusted trading returns under several configurations.
Critical strengths
-
Practical motivation and modular design. The paper addresses a relevant problem in financial news processing: conventional sentiment-based pipelines may treat articles with different levels of relevance, credibility, and informational value equally. The proposed five-dimensional schema provides an interpretable interface for assessing these properties and can be integrated into different downstream systems without requiring modifications to their underlying models.
-
Evaluation across multiple models and downstream settings. The evaluation covers five sentiment analysis models, different external knowledge retrieval configurations, and two trading frameworks. The inclusion of dimension-level ablations, human agreement measurements, and computational cost analysis provides useful empirical insights into the proposed framework.
Critical weaknesses
-
The mechanism connecting reliability scores, sentiment improvement, and trading performance is insufficiently validated. Although FinRAIN claims that five-dimensional reliability scores improve sentiment signals, the paper does not clearly describe the mathematical formulation and weighting procedure used to aggregate these scores. Moreover, the paper mainly reports aggregate metrics (e.g., sentiment-return correlation and hit rate). Although Appendix H provides a single-day case study illustrating article-level label flips and decision changes, the paper lacks a systematic analysis of how reliability weighting alters individual article contributions, sentiment directions, or prediction corrections across the full evaluation. More importantly, the sentiment evaluation (Table 2) and trading evaluation (Table 3) follow two separate pipelines. The paper does not directly verify whether improved reliability-weighted sentiment signals lead to better trading decisions. An end-to-end evaluation comparing original sentiment signals and FinRAIN-enhanced sentiment signals in the same trading framework would better support the claimed benefits. In the trading setting, FinRAIN annotations appear to be consumed as additional prompt context by the decision LLM, rather than through an explicit, reproducible weighting operator; this further obscures how the five scores mechanistically affect BUY/SELL/HOLD decisions.
-
The robustness of LLM-based components is insufficiently evaluated. FinRAIN relies on LLM-based reliability scoring, retrieval, and trading decisions, but the paper does not provide repeated-run stability analysis. Although some experiments use deterministic decoding, the consistency of reliability scores, retrieval decisions, and BUY/SELL/HOLD predictions is not reported. Additionally, the paper does not provide variance estimates of trading metrics (e.g., Sharpe ratio and PnL) across repeated runs, making it difficult to assess whether the reported improvements are robust or sensitive to individual LLM generations.
Questions for authors
Q1: Could the authors clarify the exact formulation used to aggregate the five reliability dimensions into the final reliability weight, and explain how this weighting mechanism modifies the sentiment signals?
Q2: Could the authors separately clarify (i) how the five scores are converted into article-level weights in the intrinsic sentiment evaluation (Table 2), and (ii) how the same annotations are consumed in the trading frameworks (Table 3)—for example, via explicit weighting versus prompt-level injection? Beyond the single-day case study in Appendix H, a more systematic analysis of article-level contribution changes would help establish the mechanism.
Q3: Since FinRAIN relies on LLM-based decision-making components, could the authors evaluate whether the final trading decisions are stable across repeated runs with identical inputs?
Q4: Do BUY/SELL/HOLD decisions remain consistent across multiple executions, and what is the decision flip rate under repeated runs?
2 comments
The authors have clarified how the five reliability scores are aggregated into an article-level reliability weight and explained the different integration mechanisms used in Table 2 (explicit weighting) and Table 3 (prompt injection). In addition, they have conducted repeated-run experiments to assess the stability of trading decisions. However, several issues remain unresolved. The authors have not sufficiently explained how the computed reliability weights modify individual article-level sentiment scores and contribute to the final aggregated sentiment signal. Furthermore, the requested systematic analysis of article-level contribution changes is still missing. Regarding decision stability, although additional experiments have been conducted, the two-stage framework still exhibits a relatively high decision disagreement rate (30–32%), with no improvement over the baseline. Therefore, I maintain my original rating.
We thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback and for recognizing the practical motivation, modular design, and broad evaluation of FinRAIN. We appreciate the opportunity to clarify how the reliability annotations are incorporated into different downstream applications.
Q1 and Q2: Reliability weighting and integration with downstream trading frameworks
An important design principle of FinRAIN is to decouple reliability assessment from downstream consumption, allowing the same structured reliability information to be utilized by different models and decision frameworks without prescribing a specific integration mechanism.
In the intrinsic sentiment evaluation, the five reliability scores are normalized to [0, 1] and combined using their geometric mean to obtain an article-level reliability weight:
Ri=(∏j=1k5si,j)1/k,k=5. where si,j denotes the reliability score for article i and dimension j. This formulation gives each dimension equal importance while allowing lower scores to reduce an article's contribution. The geometric mean maintains a consistent weight scale and avoids completely excluding articles with lower reliability scores.
In contrast, the downstream trading evaluation does not consume the weighted sentiment signals from Table 2. Instead, the five reliability scores, together with their corresponding rubric definitions, are directly incorporated into the trading LLM prompts alongside the original news articles. The trading LLM interprets these annotations and makes directional decisions without relying on a predefined numerical weighting operator or intermediate sentiment aggregation.
The two evaluations are intentionally designed to assess complementary applications of FinRAIN, rather than sequential stages of a single pipeline. Table 2 examines whether explicit reliability weighting improves sentiment alignment, while Table 3 evaluates whether the reliability assessments themselves can provide useful information directly to downstream trading models.
Q3 and Q4: Trading Decision Stability
We thank the reviewer for raising the question of decision stability. To address this concern, we conducted three runs for each baseline and pipeline retrieval FinRAIN configuration using identical inputs. Decision disagreement and direct BUY/SELL reversal rates were calculated from all three pairwise comparisons between runs.
The results show that FinRAIN reduces decision disagreement in the single-stage framework (11% to 6%), while the two-stage framework exhibits comparable overall variability across configurations. Importantly, direct BUY↔SELL reversals remain rare across all settings (below 1% to 2%), suggesting that most decision variability does not involve a complete reversal of trading direction.
We appreciate the reviewer's suggestion, which provides a useful additional perspective on the reproducibility of downstream trading decisions.