acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

MOST-OPSD: Dual-Level Speech-Prior Distillation for High-Performance Language BCIs

17 views

Abstract

Language brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) offer promising approaches to restoring communication, but accurate speech decoding remains challenging with limited neural recordings. Existing methods mainly improve neural decoding by using phoneme context and enhancing temporal modeling. However, decoding models struggle to learn a reasonable continuous speech structure from discrete phoneme label sequences with transcript supervision alone, thereby limiting decoding performance and generalization. Here, we propose the **MOST-OPSD** neural decoding framework, combining Mixture of Speech Teachers with privileged On-Policy Self-Distillation, which transfers transcript-generated speech priors to the decoding model at the representation and prediction levels. Specifically, the MOST module transfers structured speech representations across multiple neural stages via independent projections and length-aware Soft-DTW loss, while the OPSD module distills speech-conditioned phoneme distributions by querying speech features using current neural states and applying a shared phoneme head. On the *Brain-to-Text Benchmark '24*, the complete system of the MOST-OPSD neural decoding framework with the language model achieved state-of-the-art performance, achieving a word error rate (WER) of **3.63%** on the hidden test set. Supplementary experiments on the second dataset *Brain-to-Text '25* also show that our method significantly outperforms baselines. The results indicate that the proposed dual-level speech-prior distillation framework provides a promising technical path for high-performance language BCIs.

Primary area:
applications to neuroscience & cognitive science
Keywords:
Language brain-computer interfaces, Mixture of Speech Teachers, On-Policy Self-Distillation, speech priors

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 4%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 3.33 over 3 reviews, above 96% of the others.
Reviewer_QYXnOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper introduces MOST-OPSD for phoneme decoding from neural recordings. MOST aligns intermediate neural states with three frozen Wav2Vec2 representations of transcript-synthesized speech using length-aware Soft-DTW. OPSD uses a speech-conditioned privileged branch to supervise a neural-only CTC branch, which alone is retained at inference. On the public Brain-to-Text '24 benchmark, the paper reports improved validation PER and 3.63% hidden-test WER for its complete fusion system, with further experiments on Brain-to-Text '25.

Critical strengths
  1. The two transfer paths are technically concrete and substantially probed through component, teacher-view, shuffling, and data-fraction ablations. Inference remains neural-only, so training-time speech information does not create a direct test-time input dependency.

  2. The public benchmark validation is a meaningful strength. The supplied Brain-to-Text '24 submission artifact reproduces the reported 3.63% WER for the complete fusion system on the held-out competition benchmark.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The causal contribution of the proposed distillation design is not sufficiently isolated. The released implementation uses standard teacher-to-student forward KL between a trainable speech-conditioned privileged posterior and a neural-only posterior; it is neither on-policy in the usual autoregressive-distillation sense nor a reverse-KL objective. The paper does not compare this design with a matched ordinary-KD or reverse-KL baseline, and it does not isolate the gains from the privileged cross-attention, its additional CTC loss, and the posterior-KL term. Likewise, although TTS voices and speech encoders are varied, no direct text/phoneme teacher establishes that the frozen TTS-to-speech-encoder cascade is necessary.

  2. The headline system result is not yet fully auditable or attributable. The abstract and Table 1 report 3.63% hidden-test fusion WER, but the conclusion reports 3.91%. Moreover, 3.63% is a complete fusion-system score, whereas validation uncertainty is reported over five neural-model seeds only. The paper does not provide hidden-test system-level uncertainty or a controlled fusion ablation, making the margin difficult to attribute specifically to MOST-OPSD. These inconsistencies and missing system-level evidence reduce confidence in the central empirical claim.

Questions for authors
  1. Please distinguish the frozen speech-feature extractor, the trainable privileged branch, and the posterior teacher used for KL. Why is teacher-to-student forward KL preferred here, and how does it compare with a matched ordinary-KD and reverse-KL baseline?
  2. Can the authors isolate the contributions of privileged cross-attention, its parallel CTC loss, and the posterior-KL loss? Can a direct fixed text/phoneme teacher match the TTS-to-speech-encoder cascade?
  3. Which complete-fusion hidden-test WER is correct (3.63% or 3.91%)? Please identify the submitted artifact, state how many independently trained neural decoders contributed to the hidden-test results, and provide a controlled fusion ablation or uncertainty where evaluation access permits.

If the response addresses these concerns comprehensively and convincingly, I would be willing to raise my rating.

Reviewer_S1EcOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

MOST-OPSD investigates whether transcript-generated speech can improve attempted-speech decoding without requiring audio at deployment. MOST transfers intermediate representations from a frozen speech encoder through multi-stage Soft-DTW alignment, while OPSD constructs speech-conditioned phoneme distributions for distillation through a shared prediction head. Experiments on Brain-to-Text ’24 and ’25 report improvements in phoneme decoding and downstream transcription. The controlled backbone comparison and repeated training runs support the overall approach, although the contributions of individual mechanisms and the final fusion procedure require further clarification.

Critical strengths

The controlled backbone comparison provides persuasive evidence that speech-informed supervision improves neural decoding. Validation PER decreases from 14.90% with CTC-only training to 10.66% with MOST-OPSD, and both transfer components contribute to the combined result. The auxiliary speech modules are removed at inference, making this a useful training strategy without requiring additional modalities at deployment.

The empirical evidence extends beyond one aggregate benchmark score. Results cover two within-participant datasets, repeated training runs, single-model transcription, and several teacher and alignment controls. In particular, the speech-shuffling and temporal-alignment experiments support the importance of correctly associated speech structure, while the second dataset provides corroborating evidence for the approach.

Critical weaknesses

The experiments establish the usefulness of combined supervision more clearly than the specific advantages attributed to its mechanisms. The OPSD ablation removes privileged CTC and KL supervision together, while the teacher-view ablations change both teacher diversity and the neural stages receiving supervision. These gaps limit the mechanistic interpretation and make precise positioning against existing auxiliary-supervision and privileged-distillation methods important.

Several reporting ambiguities limit independent assessment of the downstream system results and reproducibility. These include conflicting descriptions of the GRU baseline, incomplete specification of fusion training and submission selection, and unspecified calibration details for the alignment objective. They should be resolved, although they do not negate the controlled phoneme-decoding improvement already demonstrated.

Questions for authors
  1. The CTC-only model achieves 14.90% PER in Figure 2(a), but its hidden-test WER is absent from Table 1. What WER does this matched backbone achieve through the same WFST and OPT pipeline? Please also clarify which GRU configuration produced the baseline results, since Appendix A.3 describes it as unidirectional and Appendix D.1 describes it as bidirectional.

  2. What is the neural-only PER when privileged CTC remains active with (\beta=0.25), but KL distillation is disabled with (\mu=0), using the same activation schedule? This comparison would distinguish posterior distillation from the direct auxiliary supervision that privileged CTC provides to the encoder and shared head.

  3. In Figure 2(b), is the total alignment weight preserved when teacher views are removed? Since removing views also removes supervision from corresponding neural stages, a comparison against one teacher layer repeated at G2/G4/G6, with matched projection capacity and total supervision weight, would more directly test teacher-layer complementarity.

  4. How is the fusion adapter trained, how are the ten input hypotheses constructed, and how are submitted configurations selected? Please specify the training data, submission count, and role of validation versus hidden-test feedback, and reconcile the 3.63% WER in Table 1 with 3.91% in Section 5.

  5. How does MOST relate to Better Representations, Better Speech BCIs: a Multitask Approach (2025), which combines phoneme CTC with auxiliary MFCC regression and semantic decoding for intracortical speech? Its targets differ from MOST’s frozen speech features, but a direct comparison of the supervision objectives and alignment requirements would clarify the methodological advance beyond auxiliary acoustic supervision.

  6. For the normalization in Equations (6) and (37), what calibration subset, encoder/projection state, and numerical constants were used? Please also explain whether calibration is repeated for each teacher configuration and ablation, since these choices determine the effective alignment strength.

  7. What specifically justifies the “on-policy” designation in Section 3.3? Appendix B.3 states that training uses no student-generated rollout, whereas the cited Self-Distilled Reasoner defines its objective over such trajectories; recomputing targets from current states therefore requires a qualified interpretation. Please also distinguish the proposed asynchronous conditioning and CTC formulation from earlier shared-weight privileged/student distillation, such as Fukuda and Thomas (Interspeech 2020), which combines hard-label supervision with posterior matching.

Reviewer_EMnmOpenReview ↗
Rating
4(+2)
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

MOST-OPSD is motivated by the hypothesis that sequences of discrete linguistic units (e.g., phonemes), commonly used as targets in speech decoding tasks, may constitute a performance bottleneck due to the continuous nature of speech. To address this limitation, the authors propose incorporating additional supervisory signals obtained by generating synthetic audio with a TTS model. The generated audio is then embedded using an automatic speech recognition (ASR) encoder, and the resulting representations are aligned with intermediate representations of a neural decoder via soft-DTW. The approach is further complemented by an advanced distillation technique in which the teacher model has access to audio representations during training. The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art results on the Brain-to-Text ’24 Challenge.

Critical strengths

In my opinion, the main strengths of this work are twofold.

First, the performance results, measured in terms of word error rate (WER), are strong and establish a new SOTA on the Brain-to-Text ’24 benchmark. These results are valuable in their own right and provide a meaningful contribution to the field.

Second, I appreciate the underlying idea of encouraging the model to learn a better representation of continuous speech structure by leveraging synthetic audio, as well as the technical implementation of this idea. Effectively incorporating the proposed additional supervisory signals requires several non-trivial steps, including the temporal alignment of neural and audio representations. The authors have successfully implemented this pipeline and demonstrated its effectiveness.

Critical weaknesses

The main concern I have regarding this work is its novelty. The idea of aligning neural representations with audio representations is not new in this field. One example is MONA-LISA (Benster et al., 2024). Although this work does not generate synthetic audio (which I consider a valuable contribution of MOST-OPSD) it leverages audio recordings available for a subset of the trials used during model training. When broadening the scope to brain-to-voice tasks, the use of synthetic audio generation has also been explored, for example, in Brain2Voice 2.0 (Wairagkar et al., 2026). More generally, other approaches have explored aligning neural and audio representations implicitly. For instance, BrainWhisperer (Boccato et al., 2026), which received an honorable mention in the Brain-to-Text ’25 Challenge, uses a fine-tuned Whisper decoder. While I appreciate the specific contribution of synthetic audio generation in MOST-OPSD, the paper would benefit from a more thorough discussion of how the proposed approach differs from these existing methods and what aspects of the methodology are genuinely novel.

A second concern is the clarity and strength of some of the claims. For example, line 14 states that "decoding models struggle to learn reasonable continuous speech structures from discrete phoneme label sequences". While I agree that this is a relevant limitation worth investigating, the statement should be more carefully qualified, given that existing models already achieve very strong performance on the benchmarks considered in this work. Finally, the notation is unnecessarily cumbersome in several places, with numerous subscripts and superscripts, as well as variables that are either left undefined or not clearly explained. For example, HineuH_i^{neu} is introduced in line 151 without an apparent definition. Similarly, the definition of ZideepZ_i^{deep} in line 206 is unclear to me. Improving the consistency of the notation and explicitly defining all variables would make the paper easier to follow.

Questions for authors
  1. Could the authors expand the related work section to discuss the differences between MOST-OPSD and the approaches mentioned above? A clearer discussion would help establish the novelty of the proposed method and clarify its contribution relative to existing approaches.

  2. Could the authors improve the presentation of the mathematical formulation, particularly by explicitly defining all variables? More generally, could they ensure that the claims made in the paper are appropriately calibrated to the proposed methodology and the empirical evidence provided?

  3. I noticed that Figure 3b appears to show non-zero values only along the diagonal of the matrices. Does this indicate that the model never confuses the phonemes shown in the figure?

  4. The authors rely on a specific TTS model to generate synthetic audio and, presumably, on a particular voice configuration. How robust are the results to the choice of TTS model and to variations in the generated voice characteristics? More specifically, could the observed performance gains be partly attributable to a favorable match between the acoustic features of the generated audio and the neural responses of the recorded subjects, rather than to the proposed method itself? An ablation study using different TTS models and voices would help clarify the generalizability of the approach and establish whether the reported improvements are robust to these choices.

Comments on the paper

2 comments

Dear Reviewer,

Thank you very much for your time and thoughtful review. As the discussion deadline approaches, could you please take a look at the authors' rebuttal and share your thoughts in the discussion?

Many thanks for your continued help!

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Global Response

We thank the Area Chair and Reviewers for their constructive feedback. During rebuttal, we added supervision and TTS controls and clarified the method and fusion protocol.


1. Methodological contribution (EMnm, S1Ec, QYXn)

To clarify our contribution relative to prior work and the scope of "on-policy," we revised the related work and method. Our contribution is this dual-level transfer across asynchronous neural and speech sequencesy: MOST module uses length-aware Soft-DTW to align representations from multiple layers of a frozen speech encoder with intermediate neural stages; OPSD module uses cross-attention from current neural states to construct speech-conditioned targets on the neural time grid. The trainable, CTC-supervised branch uses a shared phoneme head and supplies a detached posterior for forward KL. "On-policy" refers to current-state conditioning in CTC training. Inference uses neural input alone. We clarified that discrete labels may provide limited explicit guidance on continuous speech dynamics and graded phoneme similarities.

2. Supervision and teacher controls (S1Ec, QYXn)

To test what posterior KL adds to privileged CTC and how teacher choice affects PER, we added loss and teacher controls. MOST accounts for the larger observed gain, reducing validation PER from 14.90% (CTC-only) to 11.46%. With MOST and the CTC-supervised cross-attention branch retained, PER is 11.12% with KL off, 10.91% with reverse KL, and 10.66% with forward KL (paired t-tests, p = 0.025 vs. KL off and p = 0.009 vs. reverse KL, n=5). From the perspective of our design, the forward KL may retain a correction for teacher-supported phonemes that the student underestimates. Additionally, MOST + frozen KD yields 12.72% PER, and phoneme embedding and BERT teachers yield 15.52% and 16.37%, supporting the value of speech-derived phonetic and temporal structure.

To address whether stage coverage explains the benefit of distinct views, we repeated W8 across G2/G4/G6 with three projections and the nominal stage weights. This gives 12.74% PER versus 10.66% with distinct views, favoring the selected pairing under the reported settings, including configuration-specific calibration.

3. Hidden-test gains and fusion provenance (S1Ec, QYXn)

To quantify gains before fusion and reconcile the reported WERs, we added a CTC-only hidden-test comparison and documented fusion. On Brain-to-Text Benchmark '24, the same WFST + OPT pipeline yields hidden-test WERs of 7.62 ± 0.33% for CTC-only and 6.25 ± 0.14% for MOST-OPSD (mean ± SD over 5 seeds). QYXn verified that the submitted artifact reproduces 3.63% WER from ten independently trained decoders. TMT (Feghhietal.,2026) reports 5.68% WER with the same ensemble size.

The revised conclusion reports the ten-decoder fusion result. We trained the Llama-3.1-8B-Instruct fusion adapter with TMT's public code and data. Selection across 22 submissions relied exclusively on validation. Variation across independent ensembles remains open.

4. Robustness and reproducibility (EMnm, S1Ec)

To test whether gains depend on the choice of TTS system or voice, we added Kokoro-82M (Hexgrad, 2025) and compared it with Piper in original choice. Piper and Kokoro yield 10.66 ± 0.10% and 10.84 ± 0.16% validation PER (p=0.065), respectively. Appendix C.3 already reported that the two Piper voices differ by 0.04 percentage points (p=0.645). However, Kokoro's higher validation CTC loss (0.535 vs. 0.457) indicates remaining sensitivity.

Brain-to-Text '25 corroborates our within-participant results. Cross-participant transfer and streaming remain future direction. We clarified that the GRU is bidirectional, documented calibration on 240 training sentences with fixed scales per configuration, and explained why small off-diagonal errors appear faint in Fig. 3(b).

Reviewer assessments and feedback

  • EMnm highlighted the strong benchmark WER and the technical value of aligning neural representations with synthetic speech. After rebuttal, EMnm found the responses solid and said the rating could rise to 3 or 4.
  • QYXn highlighted the concrete transfer mechanisms, extensive ablations, and reproducible benchmark results. QYXn found the revised paper substantially improved and stated an intention to raise the rating to 3.
  • S1Ec highlighted the controlled backbone gains, neural-only deployment, and corroborating results on a second dataset. S1Ec stated that the revisions and experiments substantially addressed the concerns and maintained 3 (Weak Acceptance), citing convincing gains and recognizing the contribution of the dual-level speech distillation.

We thank the Area Chair and Reviewers again. The revised manuscript clarifies the contribution and teacher roles (Sections 2–3), reports the pre-fusion WER and KL-off results (Section 4.3), and documents the controls, calibration, and fusion protocol (Appendices B and C).

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.