acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

PAGTPRP: Position-Aware Graph Transformer for Prerequisite Relationship Prediction

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Predicting prerequisite relationships is crucial in educational applications such as curriculum planning and intelligent tutoring. Although unified modeling of concept and document prerequisite prediction has been achieved, existing approaches still face limitations in integrating global structural context and edge-weight information when modeling heterogeneous prerequisite networks. We propose a Position-Aware Graph Transformer for Prerequisite Relationship Prediction (PAGTPRP). Specifically, PAGTPRP firstly generates embeddings for knowledge concepts and documents and constructs a global heterogeneous graph, which contains two types of nodes (documents and knowledge concepts) and three types of edges (“document-document”, “concept-concept”, and “document-concept”). In addition, we calculate the edge weights and use the graph Transformer to encode them as relational encodings, which are integrated into the multi-head self-attention mechanism. Finally, we employ a Siamese network to more accurately predict the prerequisite relationships. On LectureBank and UCD, we compare PAGTPRP with several baseline methods. The experimental results demonstrate that PAGTPRP achieves excellent performance in predicting prerequisite relationships. Our code is available at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/PAGTPRP-4E44.

Primary area:
learning on graphs and other geometries & topologies
Keywords:
Prerequisite Relationship Prediction, Graph Transformer, Heterogeneous Graph

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 9%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.50 over 4 reviews, above 9% of the others.
Reviewer_wvNqOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes PAGTPRP, a Graph Transformer-based framework for predicting prerequisite relationships among knowledge concepts and documents. The effectiveness of the proposed method is evaluated on two benchmark datasets, LectureBank and UCD, where it demonstrates competitive performance against existing approaches. However, despite its promising experimental results, the paper suffers from several limitations, including insufficiently justified research motivation, limited technical novelty, and a lack of interpretability and qualitative analysis. We believe that the authors need to better clarify the underlying research problem, highlight the methodological contributions beyond existing Graph Transformer-based approaches, and provide more intuitive evidence to explain the effectiveness of the proposed framework.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper provides a relatively comprehensive analysis of existing prerequisite relationship prediction methods, discussing their respective strengths and limitations.

  2. The experimental evaluation includes comparisons with ten existing baseline methods, providing empirical evidence of the effectiveness of the proposed approach.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Lack of clarity in the research motivation and problem formulation. The core research problem is not sufficiently well motivated. In particular, the authors raise the question of "how continuous association strengths should guide node interactions." However, several fundamental questions remain unanswered: Why is modeling node interactions necessary for prerequisite relationship prediction? What specific information is captured through these interactions? More importantly, how does such interaction information contribute to improving prerequisite relationship prediction? A clearer explanation of the underlying motivation and its connection to the target task is needed.

  2. Insufficient interpretability of the proposed framework. The paper does not adequately explain how the three key components—heterogeneous relations, edge-weight-aware attention, and the integration of broader structural context—contribute to prerequisite relationship prediction. Although these components are presented as the main advantages of the proposed framework, the underlying mechanisms through which they facilitate prerequisite discovery remain unclear. Further analysis is needed to establish a more explicit connection between these architectural designs and their benefits for the target task.

  3. Limited technical novelty. The technical novelty of the proposed approach appears limited. Graph Transformer-based architectures have been extensively explored for relation prediction, and the proposed method seems to primarily apply established techniques to an existing task rather than introduce fundamentally new methodological insights. Furthermore, techniques such as matrix factorization and rule-based classification according to edge weights are already well-established in related research. Therefore, incorporating these techniques does not, by itself, constitute a sufficiently substantial methodological contribution. The authors should more clearly distinguish their approach from existing Graph Transformer-based methods and clarify its unique technical contributions.

  4. Lack of qualitative analysis and illustrative case studies. The experimental evaluation lacks concrete case studies that could provide intuitive insights into the behavior of the proposed model. Although quantitative results demonstrate its effectiveness, they do not sufficiently explain how the model identifies prerequisite relationships in practice. In particular, the absence of qualitative examples makes it difficult to understand how heterogeneous graph structures, edge-weight information, and global structural context influence the final predictions. Including representative case studies and visualizations would help substantiate the claimed advantages of the proposed framework and provide a more interpretable understanding of its effectiveness.

Questions for authors

Please see the weaknesses.

Reviewer_duRvOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
3
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper introduces a graph transformer-based approach to predict prerequisite relationship. The work primarily attempt to address two key limitations of the existing approaches: i) how continuous association strengths should guide node interactions, ii) how to incorporate context beyond individual candidate pairs. To this goal, the authors present a graph transformer-based approach that construct a weighted heterogeneous graph with concept and document nodes with document to document, concept to concept, and document to concept edges. The Transformer maps continuous edge weights into relational encodings and then ads this to self-attention layer. The authors present results on two datasets (UCD and Lecturebank). The results seem to suggest that the method outperforms some state of the art approaches on these two datasets.

Critical strengths

In my asessment, the most critical strength seems to be its reported perforamnce on two small datasets.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The contribution of the work is very incremental, and thus it has very little novelty.
  2. The results are presented on two very small datasets. I did not understand why he authors did not present results on other datasets.
  3. The problem statement does not satisfy the standard on ICLR, as the paper addresses an application oriented problem in a very narrow domain.
Questions for authors

Please see my comments in "critical wekanesses" section for my major concerns.

Reviewer_psKTOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies joint concept- and document-level prerequisite prediction, motivated by the need to combine global relational context with continuous association strengths. PAGTPRP constructs a heterogeneous graph from pretrained concept and document embeddings, enriching document features with an average of their associated concept representations. Document-document, concept-concept, and document-concept weights are derived from cosine similarity, a cosine-Jaccard combination, and TF-IDF, respectively. The central mechanism maps each scalar edge weight through a learnable ReLU transformation and adds the result to global self-attention logits. An ordered-pair MLP predicts directed prerequisite relations, and a joint binary cross-entropy objective combines the two tasks. Experiments on LectureBank and UCD report improvements in concept- and document-level prediction.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper addresses a useful educational prediction problem and recognizes that a candidate pair alone may omit relevant context. Combining document content with associated concept descriptions provides complementary semantic information. The shared graph and joint objective offer a coherent way for concept- and document-level supervision to influence a common representation, making the overall task formulation sensible.

  2. The graph weights have explicit interpretations as similarity or relevance, while Equation (16) uses ordered concatenation and signed differences to distinguish the two directions of a candidate pair. This is a sound design choice: symmetric contextual associations do not force symmetric prerequisite predictions. The division between feature construction, context aggregation, and pair classification also makes the pipeline straightforward to follow.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Equation (11) transforms each edge weight using only two scalar parameters per layer, shared across attention heads. When the ReLU is active throughout an attention row, the additive intercept cancels under softmax, leaving a learned rescaling of the supplied affinity values. The paper explicitly defines position awareness in terms of these weights, but does not establish a substantive representational principle beyond scalar association-biased attention. Section 2.2 already acknowledges prior joint heterogeneous modeling and global-context methods, so the claimed advance depends heavily on this lightweight transformation. The PE ablation shows that the association matrix is useful, but does not establish what the learned encoding contributes beyond directly injecting weighted affinities. A clearer account of the additional prerequisite-relevant structural information or modeling capability is needed.

  2. Equations (5)–(9) combine cosine similarity, cosine-Jaccard similarity, and TF-IDF relevance in one matrix, although these quantities have different meanings and numerical scales. Equation (11) then applies the same scalar transformation to all three relation types, with no stated type-specific calibration or relation-conditioned parameters. Equal numerical scores consequently receive identical relational biases even when they represent different evidence. Conversely, differences in score scale can influence the relative attention assigned to relation types without reflecting their relevance to prerequisite prediction. The distinct feature-generation paths retain some type information, but they do not explain the calibration of this separate bias channel. This weakens the justification for the proposed heterogeneous interaction mechanism and leaves its behavior dependent on insufficiently motivated score comparability.

Questions for authors

see Weaknesses

Reviewer_YBZ4OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

PAGTPRP addresses joint concept- and document-level prerequisite prediction in educational data. It combines text embeddings with a weighted heterogeneous graph whose association weights are mapped to additive biases in global self-attention. An ordered-pair prediction head produces directed prerequisite predictions, and the two tasks are trained with a joint objective. The paper reports concept- and document-level results on LectureBank and UCD, together with component ablations, experiments varying positive-to-negative ratios, and hyperparameter analyses. Its main proposed contribution is to combine cross-granularity information with relation-aware aggregation for prerequisite prediction.

Critical strengths
  1. Well-motivated joint prediction. Concept- and document-level prerequisite relations provide complementary views of educational structure. The proposed joint formulation is relevant, and Sections 4.2–4.4 clearly distinguish association signals used for representation learning from directional prediction through ordered-pair features.
  2. Inspectable design and materials. The manuscript defines the graph weights, attention-bias mapping and task objectives explicitly, and Table 4 separately considers background embeddings, positional encoding and document prerequisite information. The submitted supplementary code includes the main implementation, ablation scripts and data splits, enabling detailed inspection of the proposed design and evaluation procedure.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Invalid held-out evaluation. The submitted supplementary code uses concept-test labels to alter predictions: after scaling, it adds 0.22/0.15 to positive-labeled scores for LectureBank/UCD and clips to [0,1] before metric computation. Independently, preprocessing reads full prerequisite files, including held-out positives, to construct concept descriptions, hierarchy information and graph weights; document relations enter graph construction before splitting. These distinct routes expose target answers, invalidating held-out evaluation in the submitted implementation. Disabling score adjustment alone cannot repair contaminated inputs. Both routes require correction and a valid reassessment of the empirical claims.
  2. Algorithm and split discrepancies. The submitted supplementary code computes graph representations under no_grad before the prediction heads, blocking supervised encoder training through this path. Its 1→16→1 sigmoid/tanh bias differs from Eq. (11)'s two-scalar ReLU. Training uses all nodes and adjacency despite Section 5.1's test-node exclusion; document splits default to 70/15/15 rather than 80/10/10. The supplied LectureBank/UCD splits also share 16/19 identical labeled negative concept pairs between training and test sets. These discrepancies undermine the correspondence between the stated algorithm, evaluation protocol and submitted implementation.
  3. Unresolved mechanism contribution. GKROM already learns multiple concept/document relations, while MTN combines resource, relation and textual evidence. PAGTPRP's continuous-weight attention bias is a plausible contribution, and the paper reports rerunning baselines on the same splits. However, Table 4's w/o PE control removes the attention-bias pathway for these association weights. It does not distinguish the value of Jaccard/TF-IDF/cosine inputs from their placement in attention, nor establish the incremental benefit of the proposed aggregation with input representations, supervision and the ordered-pair head held fixed.
  4. Direction versus relatedness. Prerequisite prediction requires distinguishing direction from semantic relatedness. The ordered-pair head in Eq. (16) enables directional predictions, and Section 5.1 includes both reversed positives and randomly sampled negatives. However, aggregate scores do not show whether relational aggregation improves ordering closely related concepts or mainly distinguishes unrelated ones. This distinction matters because the symmetric association signals directly encode relatedness rather than prerequisite order. A breakdown by negative type would connect the observed gains to the task's directional difficulty and clarify the contribution beyond the supervised prediction head.
  5. Unresolved cross-granularity transfer. Concept-background features and the joint objective in Eq. (20) provide plausible cross-granularity coupling. Table 4 separately ablates background embeddings and document prerequisite information, supporting their contribution to concept prediction. However, it does not show whether concept supervision benefits document prediction or whether encoder sharing benefits either task beyond separately trained predictors using the same inputs and task labels. Such a comparison would clarify whether joint optimization enables reciprocal transfer or mainly provides document-to-concept assistance, and identify where parameter sharing is advantageous.
Questions for authors
  1. Corrected evaluation. Identify which reported results, if any, used label-dependent prediction adjustment or held-out relation inputs. Provide corrected preprocessing and evaluation, retraining affected models; report ACC/AUC/F1 with test labels used only to compute metrics.
  2. Implementation and splits. Reconcile the encoder-gradient, attention-bias and split discrepancies. Correct overlapping labeled pairs across splits, explain test-node representation construction and the assignment of opposite pair orientations, and reassess affected results.
  3. Matched mechanism control. Compare attention-bias aggregation with supplying the same relational information directly to the ordered-pair predictor, keeping text features and supervision matched.
  4. Directional discrimination. For the full model and w/o PE, report performance separately on reversed-positive and randomly sampled negatives under the same evaluation protocol.
  5. Benefit of joint optimization. With inputs and supervision budgets matched, compare joint optimization with separately trained concept and document predictors. Report the effect on each task to establish where cross-task sharing provides an advantage.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.