- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
During training, future observations can provide additional guidance for time series forecasting. The authors propose FoldOPSD, which consists of a teacher path and a student path that share the same forecasting model. The teacher path accesses the mean, standard deviation, and trend of the future segment, while the student path uses only past observations and a learned constant correction to predict future values. After training, only the student path is used for inference.
Critical strengths
-
Using information about the future segment of the training data to guide forecasting model updates through self-distillation is an interesting idea.
-
The constant correction in the student path can be absorbed into the existing output bias, providing a practical way to improve forecasting accuracy without changing the deployed architecture.
Critical weaknesses
-
The paper’s presentation needs improvement. The introduction does not clearly state the main contributions, abbreviations such as OPSD and EMA are not defined at first use, and the purpose of Figure 1(a) is insufficiently explained in the main text.
-
The teacher path introduces additional training costs. It remains unclear whether comparable improvements could be achieved by training the baseline longer under the same computational budget.
-
The method uses the mean, standard deviation, and slope computed over patches of fixed lengths. However, the contribution of each statistic and the rationale for selecting the patch lengths remain unclear.
-
The results in Table 6 raise questions about the robustness of FoldOPSD across different models.
Questions for authors
Please the author(s) answer my two questions: point 2 and point 3 in the 'Critical Weaknesses' section.
Thanks the authors for the rebuttal. The additional clarifications and experiments have addressed my concerns regarding W2 and W3. However, my concern regarding W4 remains, so I will keep my original score.