- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 1
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes LE-NODE, a hybrid weather forecasting framework that combines Eulerian grid-based Neural Ordinary Differential Equations (Neural ODEs) with sparse, adaptive Lagrangian particles. The proposed method leverages an Eulerian grid to represent the global atmospheric state, tracks local anomalies through continuous-time evolving Lagrangian particles, and dynamically updates the particle set at forecast segment boundaries to improve the prediction accuracy of localized extreme weather. The authors evaluate the approach on the ERA5 dataset, and experimental results demonstrate that LE-NODE achieves performance improvements in pointwise upper-tail metrics for Z500 and temperature, as well as lower-tail metrics for MSLP. Compared to a purely Eulerian model trained with the same objective, incorporating the particle branch yields a substantially greater reduction in tail prediction error than in full-field prediction error. Furthermore, through component ablation studies, evaluations across different forecast lead times, and typhoon case analyses, the authors further validate the effectiveness of the proposed method.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
None
Questions for authors
-
The paper demonstrates that introducing the Lagrangian particle branch significantly improves Tail-RMSE. However, adding the particle branch simultaneously increases both the number of model parameters and the computational cost. Consequently, it remains unclear whether the performance gains stem from the Lagrangian representation itself or from the additional model capacity. Could the authors compare their method against a stronger Eulerian-only model under a comparable parameter scale and computational budget?
-
The authors note that under a spatially varying velocity field, energy transfer across Fourier modes can occur even during an exact advection process. Could the authors further compare the predictions with the reference solution at the same time step—for example, by analyzing the full spectral error or global norm variations—to more directly validate the limitations of fixed-grid representations in transporting localized structures?
3 comments
Thank you for the detailed response. The additional results have addressed my concerns. I encourage the authors to incorporate these experiments and clarifications into the revised manuscript. I will maintain my original rating.
Follow-up on the revised manuscript
Thank you for following up. We appreciate your suggestions. The stationary local-branch comparison and the same-time reference errors helped make the results clearer.
Both experiments are now included in the revised manuscript, together with the parameter counts and measured computational costs. We have also clarified the scale parameterization and the interpretation of the spectral diagnostic. Thank you again for the careful reading.
Response to UnFh: local-capacity control and reference-relative errors
Thank you for your assessment. We answer the two questions separately.
Critical Weaknesses:
No separate weaknesses were listed. The two questions below identify important controls for interpreting the improvement.
Questions For Authors:
Q1. Does the improvement exceed that from extra parameters and computation?
The original same-loss comparison reduces Z500 upper-tail RMSE from 312 to 221 m, but also adds capacity. We added a stationary local-residual alternative retaining the local-state budget, latent width, feature access, decoder, boundary refresh, and objective while fixing positions within each integration segment.
The stationary/moving parameter counts differ by approximately 1.6%, but LE-NODE has higher measured training and inference costs. This is an approximate capacity control, not a strict equal-compute comparison. The moving branch retains a 63 m tail-error advantage, with a paired 95% time-block interval [41,85] m for the reduction. The stationary-versus-grid difference is descriptive; it does not establish that a fixed percentage of the original gain is causally due to capacity.
Q2. Can predictions be compared with the same-time reference through spectra or global norms?
Yes. Physical spectral transfer means that the initial Fourier coefficient need not remain constant. We therefore compare to the evolved reference:
These use 64 held-out initial fields and a pseudo-spectral reference at 512 squared resolution; the high band is kappa in [0.5,1.0]. They show lower prediction discrepancy for the moving implementation, without identifying the entire error as solver dissipation. We will state the characteristic argument as design motivation and avoid claiming that fixed grids necessarily fail or that particles remove all high-frequency error.