- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes RS-RDA, a region-to-decision white-box multimodal adversarial attack method for remote sensing vision-language models (RS-VLMs). It first combines region reliability, vision-language relevance, and semantic complementarity to localize decision-relevant regions and applies bounded perturbations within them. Then, by comparing clean and adversarial answer distributions along with regional gradients, it identifies score shifts, dominant incorrect competitors, and decision-changing regions, thereby generating and selecting semantics-preserving adversarial prompts to adapt the attack to the evolving decision boundary.
Critical strengths
see summary
Critical weaknesses
The following concerns need to be addressed by the authors one by one.
1)The paper employs SAM to segment remote sensing images. Is the segmentation quality consistently satisfactory for every image in the attack dataset?
2)The text font in the framework figure is too small and does not conform to standard formatting conventions.
3)In the equations, some variables are typeset in bold. What is the purpose of this emphasis? Are these variables intended to be highlighted as particularly important?
4)The authors should explicitly clarify whether the baselines are also permitted an equivalent strength of prompt search.
5)Why is the ASR of the baseline methods in Table 1 substantially lower than that of the proposed method? Is there a reasonable explanation for this discrepancy?
Questions for authors
see weakness