- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces LensDreamer, a world-model-assisted optimization framework for optical lens design. By learning the multi-step changes in optical response during lens parameter editing, the method predicts in latent space the endpoints that different design action sequences may reach, and uses a Basin-Map planning strategy to allocate a limited budget for high-fidelity physical evaluations across different candidate design regions. The paper also constructs the LensDreamer-Traj trajectory dataset, which is used to train and evaluate the model's ability to predict lens parameter changes and optical responses.
Critical strengths
-
The paper tackles a practically meaningful system design problem and backs it with fairly thorough experiments. It treats optical lens design as a complex non-convex optimization task and combines multi-step optical response prediction, exploration of candidate design regions, and allocation of physical optimization budget into a complete framework. Its effectiveness is demonstrated not only by final optimization results but also by multi-step prediction, dynamics-component ablations, and candidate action selection from a shared pool. These results suggest that the proposed model improves prediction and action selection under the tested settings, rather than only achieving strong final system-level metrics. This supports acceptance, since the method is empirically justified at multiple levels and addresses a problem with clear practical value.
-
The dataset and physical optimization evaluation framework also have research value. The authors construct the LensDreamer-Traj trajectory dataset and the LensDreamer-2K benchmark, and combine predictive evaluation with final physical optimization evaluation. Under controlled comparisons with matched physical evaluation budgets, LensDreamer outperforms Optiland multi-start, with paired confidence intervals in the supplementary material supporting this improvement. The paper also reports final design error and attempts to assess coverage of different stable optimization endpoints, offering a complementary view of search behavior in non-convex optical design spaces. This supports acceptance because the dataset, evaluation pipeline, and physical optimization experiments have potential research value beyond the specific model architecture.
Critical weaknesses
-
The lens parameter updates are deterministic and known (Eq. 3), making exact parameter updates combined with a nonlinear optical response surrogate a natural baseline. Such a model could also evaluate multi-step action sequences. Without this comparison, it is difficult to assess the added value of recurrent world-model dynamics. Moreover, the comparison between greedy one-step planning and the full Basin-Map planner changes both the planning horizon and basin allocation strategy, making their individual contributions difficult to isolate.
-
The reported basin coverage depends on how locally optimized endpoints are grouped, but the numerical tolerances used to identify distinct basins are not specified. The DLS stopping criteria and sensitivity to these tolerances are also unclear. Since discovering distinct basins is a central claim of the paper, these details are important for reproducing the results and assessing the robustness of the reported improvements.
Questions for authors
-
Have the authors considered a baseline that uses exact parameter updates with a nonlinear optical response surrogate? How would it compare with the proposed world model under the same training data and planning budget?
-
What numerical tolerances are used to determine whether two DLS-optimized endpoints belong to the same basin, and what are the DLS stopping criteria? How sensitive are the reported basin coverage results to these settings?
8 comments
Kind Request to Review Our Rebuttal and Updated Manuscript
Dear Reviewer k4En,
Thank you for your time and thoughtful feedback. We have posted our point-by-point responses, including additional experiments and clarifications, and uploaded the revised manuscript and supplementary material. We would greatly appreciate it if you could review these updates when you have a chance. If any questions or concerns remain, we would be happy to provide further explanations or discuss them with you. Thank you again for your time and consideration.
Best regards, Author of submission 1572
Thank you for the author's reply. I'll keep my score.
Thank you for the author's reply. I'll keep my score.
Response to Reviewer k4En (R4)
Thank you for your comments. We respond point by point below and have revised the manuscript and supplementary material. Please download the latest main-paper and supplementary PDFs to view the revisions.
W1/Q1: Added value of learned dynamics and multi-step planning.
We trained a Direct Optical Surrogate combining exact prescription updates with nonlinear response prediction:
pk+1=A(pk,ak),Y^k+1=fθ(pk+1,S).
Direct Optical Surrogate: A shared three-layer Transformer block repeated four times predicts responses from exact action-updated prescriptions and specifications using bidirectional attention.
Action-Conditioned World Model: Transformer–RSSM uses causal action-history attention, recurrent stochastic rollouts, and a shared three-layer block repeated four times per latent step.
Both share training data/schedule, 2,000 tasks, Basin-Map Planner (H=8), ≤180 online Optiland calls, and local refinement. Selection uses a shared exact-prescription/predicted-response representation, excluding private latent features and uncertainty scoring. LensDreamer (Ours) retains its original planner configuration.
Under the common planner, the world model reduces SpecGAPFA by 8.8% and RMS by 6.8%, and improves SR by 1.75 percentage points, with gains on all metrics. The full LensDreamer system reaches 43.60% OOD SR versus 39.20% for the surrogate (+4.40 percentage points; 11.2% relative), supporting success on unseen specifications.
We ran H=1, 2, 4, and 8 with the same full Basin-Map Planner, checkpoint, candidate population, verification slots, other settings, DLS, tasks, and seeds, with ≤180 Optiland calls per task. H=1 retains basin-aware selection, unlike the original greedy baseline.
From H=1 to H=8, SpecGAPFA decreases by 21.9% and SR increases by 9.50 percentage points, while stable basins rise from 1.27 to 1.63. All horizons retain basin-aware selection and execute only the first action before replanning.
Thank you for these suggestions. Section 3.4, Tables 4–5, and Appendix F.2 now isolate the contributions of dynamics and planning.
W2/Q2: Endpoint grouping, DLS stopping, and tolerance sensitivity.
We already described endpoint grouping in Section 2.4/Appendix F, coverage metrics in Appendix G, and tolerance-based grouping in Appendix H, Figure 2.
Following your suggestion, we have added numerical criteria in Appendix F.1 and sensitivity results in Appendix H.1. Certification is a separate post-hoc audit, outside the online 180-call budget, allowing ≤1,024 residual evaluations per audit refinement plus certification calls. Escape uses all 2,000 tasks. Grouping uses a complete-link rule with structural checks and tolerance-normalized prescription/response distances. Prescription tolerance is 10−3. Online and audit TRF use separately specified stopping rules. Certification additionally requires physical validity and projected-gradient infinity norm ≤10−4, passing checks at both 10−6 and 10−7 difference steps; a budget stop alone does not certify convergence.
We scale grouping tolerances on fixed audited endpoints. Mean basin counts are:
The ranking remains unchanged across the full range, also for anchor escape. With matched endpoint counts, Full-minus-CEM remains positive (0.16–0.25). Thank you for this suggestion. Appendices F.1/G give the protocol and statistics; Appendix H.1, Tables 10–11, adds sensitivity results for reproducible coverage analysis.