- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies the theoretical properties of the existing Spikelet representation for time series. It introduces a linear-time algorithm to complete signal-induced support intervals, proves several properties of the resulting structure, and establishes connections with persistent homology. The paper also compares extremal-structure preservation with Gaussian smoothing and Fourier reconstruction.
Critical strengths
- The paper is well organized, with clear definitions and detailed mathematical proofs.
- The analysis of support completion and the noncrossing property provides a useful characterization of the Spikelet representation.
Critical weaknesses
-
The paper builds on the existing Spikelet representation. While the support completion algorithm and theoretical analysis are new, it is not clear how much they add to the original method. In particular, the practical benefit of using completed supports is not demonstrated.
-
Some theoretical results are rather straightforward. For example, Theorem 1 follows from using linear interpolation between retained extrema and does not depend on the specific Spikelet construction. It is difficult to see these results as major contributions.
-
The comparison with persistent homology could be more informative. The paper explains how the support intervals differ, but it remains unclear what useful information the proposed representation provides beyond existing persistence-based representations.
-
Most experiments check the theoretical properties, while the real-data analysis is limited to three recordings. A comparison between the original and completed Spikelet supports on a simple task, such as motif matching or event localization, would help show why the new results matter.
Questions for authors
- What practical benefit does exact support completion provide over the original Spikelet representation?
- What information does the proposed support hierarchy retain that cannot be obtained from existing persistence-based representations?
- Can the authors provide some examples where the completed supports improve the results of a downstream task?
3 comments
Response to Author's Rebuttal
Thank you for the response. The revisions clarify the main theoretical contribution and its distinction from persistence-based methods. The new examples also help illustrate the role of support completion.
My main concern remains whether these results offer meaningful advantages over existing methods. The new examples demonstrate the proposed representation's capabilities, but do not provide comparative evidence of its benefits. I will therefore keep my rating unchanged.
Thank you for reconsidering our revision and for acknowledging that the main theoretical contribution and its distinction from persistence-based methods are now clearer.
We understand the remaining concern. Our examples demonstrate concrete capabilities, but do not establish comparative downstream advantages. Our principal contribution is the mathematical guarantee for the collective extremum-centered support family (Theorem 2), together with a precise characterization of what the original Spikelet scan computes (Proposition 2). Beyond the new examples, the paper provides structural comparisons: positive smoothing changes global extremal values (Proposition 3); fixed-resolution reconstruction can introduce false extrema (Proposition 4; Corollaries 2–3); fixed-rank linear reconstruction cannot universally preserve independently varying apex values (Proposition 6); and certain compactly supported wavelets admit crossing supports (Proposition 8). Table 9 further shows large support-length variation within persistence-lifetime bins.
We agree that controlled downstream comparisons are needed to establish whether and when these properties translate into measurable advantages, and we identify this as future work (Section 8). We therefore position the paper as a contribution to the mathematical foundations of time-series event representation, with downstream benchmarking as the next step.
Thank you for the careful review. Our separate General Response summarizes the overall revisions and their locations. Because the geometric distinctions are easier to see than to describe, we particularly invite the reviewer to examine Figs. 13–15 and Table 10 (Appendices I–K).
W1 / Q1 (What the results add to the original Spikelet). First, the theory characterizes what was already exact in the original method: the one-pass scan computes exact magnitudes and left endpoints (Proposition 2), while Theorem 1 guarantees preservation of retained apex values under magnitude-only pruning. Second, completion recovers each event's full signal-induced extent: the one-pass interval may stop at an early local low or high, whereas completion reaches the deepest trough or highest rebound within the full excursion. Fig. 14 (Appendix J) illustrates both cases on S&P 500 prices: a decline event's right endpoint moves from September 16 to October 12 (18 additional trading sessions), and a rebound event gains 19 sessions. Completion changes right endpoints for 20.8%–25.6% of selected events in three real recordings (Table 8). Contribution 1 now identifies Theorem 2's collective noncrossing and inclusion hierarchy as our main result.
W2 (Theoretical contributions). We agree that Theorem 1 is elementary and uses the Spikelet construction only through the retained apex set; the revision states this after Theorem 1. Its role is to establish a preservation baseline for Section 6. Proposition 6 (Appendix F) shows that a fixed rank-q linear reconstruction cannot universally preserve q+1 independently varying apex values; in contrast, Theorem 1 guarantees exact values at the apexes retained by adaptive pruning. Our main result is Theorem 2, while Proposition 4 and Corollaries 2–3 (Appendix F) give the most technically involved analysis, establishing conditions under which fixed-resolution reconstruction introduces false extrema.
W3 / Q2 (Information beyond persistent homology). The difference is the geometric object: Biswas et al. associate one window with each persistence pair of a maximum and minimum, whereas Spikelet assigns a two-sided support to each individual maximum or minimum (Fig. 13: two pair windows versus four supports; Table 10, Appendix I). Although absolute Spikelet magnitude equals 0D persistence lifetime for two-sided interior events (Proposition 1), it is only the smaller of the two apex-to-endpoint amplitude drops, aL and aR. Spikelet's event-centered representation additionally provides: (i) each event's temporal support—within lifetime bins, the support-length Q90/Q10 ratio reaches 235.22 (Table 9); (ii) access to both side drops aL and aR from the original samples, capturing asymmetry; and (iii) same-polarity support containment, organized into noncrossing inclusion forests by Theorem 2. These properties motivate the time-series structural queries in W4/Q3.
W4 / Q3 (Downstream impact). As a concrete event-localization illustration, Table 8 and Fig. 14 compare the original one-pass and exact completed supports: 20.8%–25.6% of selected events have provisional right endpoints, which completion corrects according to Definition 1. Beyond localization, we introduce time-series structural queries, retrieving variable-length events without prescribing a window length by combining shape, magnitude, duration, and asymmetry with relationships among internal Spikelets. Fig. 15 (Appendix K; Section 7) retrieves plateau-like, nested, sharp, and asymmetric events from a measured supersonic-jet acoustic record (2 million samples) for physical analysis. Together with the three original recordings and S&P 500 data, these illustrations span five records across physiology, animal behavior, human motion, finance, and acoustics. We do not claim improvements in downstream accuracy without controlled comparisons; benchmarking against existing query methods remains future work (Section 8). The present results establish two concrete capabilities: exact recovery of signal-induced event supports and structural retrieval of variable-length waveform events, including internal substructures, from measured data without prescribing fixed windows.
We would be glad to discuss any point further.