- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper achieves efficient RGBA video generation under reference image and text conditioning, aiming to extend existing video diffusion models to support transparent video synthesis. The paper first constructs GameAlpha-2.4K, a dataset containing 2,395 game-style video samples, where alpha mattes are generated using existing alpha estimation models and further filtered through multimodal model-based quality assessment. Building upon the Wan architecture, the paper introduces an RGBA fusion module and a DoRA-based adaptation module to expand the original video generation model into the RGBA generation space. To reduce redundant DiT computation caused by transparent regions, the paper further designs a transparency prediction probe that identifies regions likely to become fully transparent and skips subsequent computation accordingly, achieving approximately 1.2× inference acceleration.
Critical strengths
The proposed transparency routing strategy is simple yet effective. By reducing the number of DiT tokens involved in the final denoising stages, it achieves a 1.2× inference speedup with minimal additional complexity.
Critical weaknesses
- The comparison in Figure 2 only focuses on the visual difference between post-generation matting and direct RGBA generation, but it does not evaluate how the proposed method compares with existing approaches that jointly generate RGB and alpha channels. The paper lacks direct visual comparisons demonstrating the quality of semi-transparent boundaries, where subtle artifacts are often difficult to capture through quantitative metrics alone. Therefore, the authors should include comparisons with existing RGB-alpha joint generation methods to better demonstrate the visual advantages of the proposed approach.
- The performance gain is relatively minor, and the overall contribution appears limited.
Questions for authors
Could the authors clarify how the proposed method compares with existing approaches that jointly generate RGB and alpha channels?
2 comments
Rebuttal to Reviewer Q4JB
References
[1] Wan-Alpha++: Animating a Single RGBA Asset into Controllable Transparent Video Effects, arXiv:2610.26189, 2026.
[2] TransPixeler: Advancing Text-to-Video Generation with Transparency, CVPR 2025.
Rebuttal to Reviewer Q4JB (W1/W2/Q1)
We sincerely thank the reviewer for their time and effort in reviewing our work, as well as for their constructive and valuable feedback.
W1/Q1
We thank the reviewer for pointing out the lack of a comparison with an independent direct RGBA generation method.
Based on our survey at the time of submission, we had not identified a reference-image-conditioned RGBA video generation method with both runnable inference code and model weights publicly available. Our original experiments therefore primarily compared against generate-then-matte pipelines. We would be happy to include comparisons with any publicly reproducible methods that we may have overlooked. We subsequently became aware of Wan-Alpha++, released on 2026-10-19 after our submission, and included its officially released model in our comparisons.
To further compare the two joint-generation systems on real-world human videos, we conduct experiments on VideoMatte240K. We use the official implementation, weights, and configuration of Wan-Alpha++, comparing it with our Dense and Routed variants. No additional fine-tuning or parameter selection is performed on this dataset.
Table 1: Quality comparison with Wan-Alpha++, an independent direct RGBA generation method, on VideoMatte240K.
As shown in the table, our Routed model achieves an FVD of 125.7, lower than Wan-Alpha++'s 155.2, while DINO-ID improves from 0.871 to 0.906. Aesthetic, Motion Smoothness, Flow Difference, and MAD scores are also better. Our system achieves competitive generation quality on VideoMatte240K while using fewer sampling steps than Wan-Alpha++.
Additionally, we provide visual comparisons of RGB and alpha outputs on VideoMatte240K via an anonymous link, showing results from our Dense and Routed variants and Wan-Alpha++. Corresponding detail regions are highlighted to facilitate visual comparison of subject appearance, hair and prop structures, and the completeness of the alpha mattes.
W2
Thank you for recognizing the simplicity and effectiveness of our method.
Our contributions include a dataset and a joint-generation approach for reference-conditioned RGBA video generation, as well as a routing method that uses predicted final visibility to reduce subsequent computation. We validate the effectiveness of these two aspects through comparisons with independent joint-generation methods and ablations with a fixed generator, respectively.
Complete generation system. We construct GameAlpha-2.4K and adopt a merged RGB–Alpha representation for reference-conditioned joint generation. TransPixeler[2] extends the generation sequence by adding Alpha tokens, and its supplementary material also discusses the resulting computational overhead; the merged representation we adopt avoids this additional sequence overhead. To evaluate the practical performance of the complete approach, we have added a comparison with the publicly released weights of Wan-Alpha++[1]. The full quantitative results and visual comparisons are provided in W1. These results provide direct evidence of our system's performance relative to existing joint-generation methods.
Additional gains from routing. Using the same generator, we further compare results with routing enabled and disabled. With the weights, inputs, and four-step sampling configuration held fixed, visibility routing reduces the mean end-to-end runtime from 125.9 seconds to 104.8 seconds, with FVD changing from 172.3 to 174.4 (Table 2 of the paper). Routing gains also vary with content. As shown in Table 2, under fixed routing parameters, the groups of samples with transparent-region proportions of 40%–60% and 80%–100% achieve end-to-end speedups of 1.12× and 1.26×, respectively, indicating that greater reductions in actual computation are possible when transparent regions occupy a larger proportion. Regarding the independent contribution of visibility as the selection criterion, the score-replacement experiment further shows (Table 2 in our response to YPyn) that, while keeping RAS's computational budget and execution mechanism unchanged, using predicted visibility scores alone substantially reduces output deviation relative to Dense; see the score-ablation table for details.
Table 2: End-to-end speedup across transparent-region proportions.