- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates the problem of unified adaptation in Source-Free Domain Adaptation (SFDA). While existing SFDA methods are typically designed for specific source-target category relationships—such as closed-set, open-set, partial-set, or generalized scenarios—this paper proposes ''Unified SFDA''. The goal is to handle diverse SFDA scenarios using a single unified approach, even in the absence of prior information about the target domain and without knowing the source-target category relationship beforehand. To this end, the authors propose CausalDA, which adopts a causality-inspired perspective to decompose latent invariant factors into two components: external and internal. External invariant factors are identified by leveraging a frozen vision-language model through prompt learning and objectives based on mutual information. Internal invariant factors are utilized to update the target model via unsupervised information maximization and pseudo-label guidance derived from the external factors. These two stages are optimized alternately. Experiments cover closed-set, generalized, open-set, and partial-set SFDA, as well as source-free OOD generalization. The results demonstrate that the proposed method achieves strong and relatively stable performance across these diverse settings.
Critical strengths
-
The problem addressed in the paper holds clear practical significance. Existing SFDA methods typically rely on predefined source-target category relationships and employ different approaches for different settings. This paper aims to reduce such setting-specific dependency, enabling a single method to maintain stable performance across various SFDA scenarios. I consider this research direction valuable, particularly for real-world deployment where the category composition of the target domain may not be accurately known in advance.
-
The method design is comprehensive, and the experimental results are highly convincing. The proposed ''external/internal invariant factor decomposition'' is realized through a concrete two-stage optimization process rather than remaining merely at a conceptual level. The experiments go beyond a single closed-set benchmark, systematically covering various SFDA settings and OOD generalization scenarios; the results demonstrate that CausalDA is highly competitive in these contexts. Furthermore, the paper presents thorough analyses, including ablation studies, pseudo-label analysis, invariance analysis, and prompt sensitivity tests. Overall, these results incline me to accept the paper.
Critical weaknesses
The core claim of ''Unified SFDA'' has not yet been established with sufficient clarity across the problem formulation, method description, and evaluation protocol. The paper characterizes ''Unified SFDA'' as adaptation performed without knowledge of the target domain or even the source-target category relationship. While this objective is compelling, it remains unclear to me just how ''unified'' the proposed method truly is in terms of practical deployment.
The algorithm incorporates an entropy- or K-Means-based rejection mechanism for unknown target classes. However, the paper fails to clarify whether this mechanism is consistently active across all settings or if prior knowledge regarding the presence of unknown classes is required. If the method relies on setting-specific activations, decision rules, or evaluation-specific processing, then the claim of operating ''without prior knowledge of the target setting or category relationship'' may be overstated.
Therefore, I believe the paper needs to make a clearer distinction between:
- a single framework performing well across multiple known SFDA settings, and
- a single deployment procedure operating without knowledge of the specific SFDA setting it faces.
While the paper provides ample evidence for the former, the definition and validation regarding the latter remain insufficiently direct. Given that ''Unified SFDA'' is a primary contribution of the work, this distinction is crucial to my scores.
Questions for authors
The manuscript also contains a clear quality-control issue in the Ethics Statement, which discusses ''malicious client detection in federated learning,'' a topic unrelated to this paper. It is maybe a simle typo copied from another manuscript. It was not corrected before submission, which raises some concern about the overall level of proofreading and manuscript preparation.
Q1. I believe the paper needs to make a clearer distinction between: a single framework performing well across multiple known SFDA settings, and a single deployment procedure operating without knowledge of the specific SFDA setting it faces.
R: Thank you for this helpful suggestion. In this paper, “unified” refers to the proposed method’s ability to perform well across multiple SFDA settings, consistent with the reviewer’s first interpretation. We have clarified this meaning in the revised manuscript.
Additionally, SFDA allows access to unlabeled target data. Thus, the problem setting is already specified by the training data used in each experiment. Our statement “without prior knowledge of the target setting or category relationship” was intended to indicate that our method does not require an explicit setting label or identifier. We have removed this statement to avoid ambiguity regarding the meaning of “unified.”
∗∗Q2.∗∗Themanuscriptalsocontainsaclearquality−controlissueintheEthicsStatement,whichdiscusses′′maliciousclientdetectioninfederatedlearning,′′atopicunrelatedtothispaper.Itismaybeasimletypocopiedfromanothermanuscript.Itwasnotcorrectedbeforesubmission,whichraisessomeconcernabouttheoveralllevelofproofreadingandmanuscriptpreparation.∗∗R∗∗:Thankyouverymuchforpointingoutthistypoandapologizeforthisoversight.Wehavefixedit.