acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Modeling Topological Impact on Node Attribute Distributions in Attributed Graphs

Abstract

We study how graph topology can condition a categorical distribution associated with node-indexed attributes. We introduce an algebraic–categorical framework based on the point of view of a node, represented by an under category that captures its node-centered structural perspective. Finite indexed projections of these viewpoints are aggregated into a graph-level monoidal object, separating the abstract topological representation from its concrete matrix realizations. We then introduce a distributional realization in which a supplied categorical distribution induces weighted graph matrices, yielding node-level and graph-level point-of-view (POV) distributions for both fixed distributions and sequences of distributions. For a connected graph and a strictly positive fixed distribution, we characterize the common limiting POV distribution by the normalized left Perron eigenvector of the induced weighted matrix. For complete graphs, we further prove recovery of the limiting supplied distribution for convergent distribution sequences, providing a sanity-check boundary when topology carries no distinguishing information. We complement the theoretical development with empirical studies that examine POV across several settings, including recovery behavior, distribution-conditioned graph propagation, topology conditioning of externally supplied node distributions, and representations of evolving policy distributions in reinforcement learning. Together, the framework provides a general mechanism for incorporating graph structure into supplied distributional information through node-centered viewpoints and path-based representations.

Primary area:
learning on graphs and other geometries & topologies
Keywords:
Categorical deep learning, Algebraic deep learning, Geometric deep learning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_eGTfOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The main research problem of this paper is "Given an attributed graph with a probability distribution over its nodes, how should the topology of the graph re-weigh that distribution?". The paper proposes to compute node POVs by first weighing the edges based on node probabilities and then counting the weight of paths of max length m between nodes. Then, the node POVs are normalized and aggregated into a graph POV. This method is supported by theory from a category perspective and culminates in two main results: 1) on a connected graph, node POVs converge to a single distribution as m grows; and 2) on a complete graph, the original distribution is recovered. Then, the method is evaluated on a set of complete graphs (theoretical guarantee) and also 7 node classification datasets (downstream application).

Critical strengths
  • The paper includes detailed and sound theory which provides mathematical guarantees (convergence on connected graphs and recovery on complete graphs) in support of the proposed method.
Critical weaknesses
  • The HPGNN experiment setup provides little validation for the paper. The graph datasets used do not come with prior probability distributions over its nodes, instead the authors provide synthetic distributions. The choice of these synthetic distributions should be justified and also ablated. Though, ideally, the authors can provide experiments on datasets that come with a meaningful prior probability distributions.

  • The comparative results are unconvincing. In Table 1, it is unclear if the uncertainty values and the tuning protocol are the same as the original HPGNN method. Hence, the results may not be comparable at all, even as a "descriptive" result. Furthermore, the paper only compares against personalized PageRank inside of HPGNN. Additional experiments that include other architectures and other baselines would greatly strengthen the paper.

Questions for authors
  1. While the related works section seem to provide some similar papers, there is no explicit description of existing work on the stated problem. Could the authors provide a detailed review on how prior works have tried to answer their research problem and why they're insufficient?
  2. How were the synthetic distributions chosen for the HPGNN experiments? Were there other choices and how much does the choice matter? Also, what is an example of a setting a probability distribution over nodes naturally arises?
  3. Can the authors provide additional context on how the category framework contribute to the results in Section 5? For example, how does the node POV definition in 5.2 relate to the node POV definition in 4.1?
Reviewer_msrgOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies how graph topology can reweight a categorical distribution over node-indexed attributes. It formalizes node-centered viewpoints using under categories and aggregates finite path representations into a monoidal object. The distributional realization assigns destination weights Pj/(1−Pj)P_j/(1-P_j) and normalizes the rows of (I+W)m−I(I+W)^m-I, or an ordered matrix product for a sequence of distributions. The main guarantees characterize convergence to a common left Perron distribution on connected undirected graphs and recovery of the limiting input distribution on complete graphs. Experiments examine complete-graph recovery, propagation within HPGNN, anomaly-score conditioning, and exploratory reinforcement-learning applications.

Critical strengths
  1. The distributional construction has a clear mathematical interpretation. The complete-graph recovery result gives a concrete consistency property, including for convergent sequences of input distributions. The fixed-distribution convergence argument correctly uses the primitivity of I+WI+W. Separating the abstract representation from its matrix realizations also makes the modeling choices explicit.

  2. The empirical reporting is clear. The paper identifies the HPGNN comparison as descriptive, includes a topology-only control for anomaly detection and simple history baselines for RL, and reports negative as well as positive results. The computational appendix and paired analyses are useful. This makes the evidence considerably easier to assess.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The significance of the categorical formulation remains unclear. From Definition 5.1 onward, the implemented construction can be described directly through weighted matrix products and row normalization. Theorem 5.3 then follows from Perron–Frobenius theory. I could not identify a property of the implemented representation that requires the under-category construction, rather than the direct matrix formulation. Recovering the graph from the abstract category does not establish the expressiveness of the finite POV matrices used downstream. The odds weighting also has a direct characterization: for a strictly positive PP on a complete graph, (PW)j=(1−Pj)wj(P W)_j=(1-P_j)w_j, so requiring PP to be a left eigenvector forces wj∝Pj/(1−Pj)w_j\propto P_j/(1-P_j). This is a useful justification, but the recovery experiment primarily checks the chosen boundary condition; it is not independent evidence that the weighting is useful on general graphs. The rationale for privileging complete graphs also deserves clarification, since symmetry of node positions alone applies to other vertex-transitive graphs. These points weaken the case for a substantial conceptual advance, rather than indicating that the stated convergence theorems are false.

  2. The downstream experiments do not isolate the contribution of POV. The original HPGNN is not rerun under the same protocol, while the POV variant receives validation-based selection over 15 view pairs and other hyperparameters. The alternative destination-weight experiments concern complete-graph recovery, not node classification. Consequently, the reported accuracies do not distinguish the benefit of odds weighting from simpler destination reweighting, propagation depth, or the model-selection budget. The finite-depth behavior also needs measurement: when the weights are small, (I+W)m−I(I+W)^m-I may be close to mWmW, making the normalized views similar across depths. This is a possibility to test, not an established explanation of the results. The appendix's mixed anomaly-detection and RL findings are informative, but do not replace a controlled comparison in the main learning task.

Questions for authors
  1. Which result or useful modeling property depends on the categorical formulation and cannot be obtained by defining the weighted matrix product directly? Why is complete-graph recovery the appropriate boundary requirement, beyond the fact that complete graphs are symmetric?

  2. Can the authors rerun HPGNN with the same splits and tuning budget, and compare POV against uniform conditioning, row-normalized adjacency, and row-normalized Adiag⁡(P)A\operatorname{diag}(P) using the same depth and view-selection protocol?

  3. For the selected distributions, how different are the m=2,3m=2,3 views from m=1m=1? Please report a direct row-distribution distance, such as max⁡i∥pov⁡(vi,P,m)−pov⁡(vi,P,1)∥1\max_i\|\operatorname{pov}(v_i,P,m)-\operatorname{pov}(v_i,P,1)\|_1, together with a scale diagnostic for WW. This would clarify whether path aggregation contributes materially before the common-limit behavior in Theorem 5.3 takes over.

Reviewer_TZ5AOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The authors study combining categorical distributions for node-indexed attributes with the graph structure and propose an algebraic-categorical framework that defines each point of view (POV) of a node as an under category of the graph category (Cat(G)). This is built from the algebraic machinery of Grothendieck Graph Neural Networks, and finite indexed projections of POVs are aggregated into a graph-level monoidal object. A supplied categorical distribution induces an odds-weighted adjacency matrix that produces node-level and graph-level POV distributions. The authors provide some additional theoretical guarantees. Specifically, for a connected graph and a strictly positive fixed distribution, node-level POVs converge to the normalized left Perron eigenvector of the weighted matrix. For complete graphs, the construction recovers the limit of any convergent sequence of distributions. Experiments showcase how POVs behave under multiple settings and use them as propagation matrices inside HPGNN for node classification across seven benchmarks.

Critical strengths

The presented theoretical analysis defines node POVs independently of the matrix such that several weightings can be applied. Additionally, the limit is defined as a Perron eigenvector, making complete graph recovery, providing a sanity check when topology carries no distinguishing information. This design can be applied without changes to the architecture or the training pipeline, since POVs are built from simple distributions. Sequences of distributions are also enabled, making the framework applicable to evolving cases.

Critical weaknesses

Experiments do not strongly validate the theory, since a small m is used for directed graphs, while guarantees refer to infinite, undirected ones. POV beats HPGNN on 4/7 tested datasets, with small gains for small datasets and large stds. Additionally, HPGNN is not reproduced, but the results are taken directly from the paper. It is unclear how the proposed theoretical contributions differ from those of Langari et al. 2026.

Questions for authors

Based on the weaknesses:

  • The authors should reproduce HPGNN and provide an ablation against simpler reweighted adjacency matrices.
  • The authors should provide a roadmap that is easy to follow for their theoretical contributions, clarifying any existing overlap with related work (Langari et al., 2026).
  • Applications shown in the appendix should be strengthened with baseline comparisons to show the methods’ significance in real use-cases.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.