- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper focuses on the "Target-Intent Collapse" problem in cross-domain recommendation, where existing methods tend to synthesize overly similar target-domain sequences for users with similar source-domain preferences. To address this, the authors propose IntExpo, a three-stage framework. First, a Transferable Preference Profiler uses reinforcement learning guided by a domain discriminator to extract domain-agnostic preference profiles from source histories. Second, an Intent Generator clusters historical sessions and learns a conditional intent distribution using a collaborative loss to capture multiple plausible intents. Finally, a Behavior Generator fine-tunes an LLM to generate specific target-domain sequences based on the user's profile and the sampled intent trajectories.
Critical strengths
- The paper identifies a practical issue in generating synthetic data for cross-domain recommendations, which involves mapping a single source history to multiple plausible target intents. Highlighting this one-to-many relationship is a valid and useful perspective for improving data augmentation.
- The authors conduct extensive experiments across multiple cross-domain scenarios, including cold-start settings. The detailed ablation studies also help validate the contribution of individual components.
Critical weaknesses
-
The proposed framework is very heavy. It requires training a domain discriminator, running reinforcement learning, performing clustering, training an autoregressive transformer, and fine-tuning a large language model. The core motivation is simply to generate diverse target sequences. However, the paper does not compare IntExpo with a straightforward baseline, such as using a frozen large language model with an adjusted temperature or a prompt that explicitly asks the model to "generate 3 diverse intent sequences". Given the high training costs reported in Table 6, it is hard to justify this multi-stage pipeline without proving that simpler generative prompting strategies fail to achieve similar diversity.
-
In Section 3.1, the method uses a domain discriminator as a reward signal to penalize domain-specific information. The main risk here is that the language model might learn to bypass the discriminator by outputting generic, meaningless phrases (e.g., "the user likes good products"). If the profile loses fine-grained personalization just to become domain-agnostic, it harms the subsequent generation steps. The paper lacks qualitative or quantitative evidence to show that the profiles remain informative after this RL training.
Questions for authors
-
Could you provide a performance comparison against a simple baseline where a single frozen language model is explicitly prompted to generate diverse target sequences (e.g., via higher temperature or diversity-promoting prompts)? How do you justify the computational overhead of IntExpo compared to such simple approaches?
-
Can you provide qualitative examples of the user preference profiles before and after the reinforcement learning training? How do you ensure the profiles do not collapse into generic, low-information text?
-
How sensitive is the framework to the 120-day session threshold? Why did you choose such a long temporal heuristic to segment intents instead of relying on the semantic understanding capabilities of the language models?
3 comments
Q2: Profile Examples and Safeguards Against Collapse Before and After RL
Thank you for your questions. We respond in two parts, including Qualitative Examples and Safeguards Against Collapse before and after RL.
Qualitative Examples:
IntExpo aims to reduce domain-specific information while retaining users’ core interests and preferred attributes. The illustrative examples below show this transition: profiles before RL focus on source-domain items or content formats, while profiles after RL express interests and needs that can transfer across domains.
Table 2. Illustrative preference profiles before and after RL.
Transfer Scenario and Source History Before RL After RL Clothing → Sports : A lightweight waterproof hiking jacket, a thermal base layer, and durable quick-drying hiking trousers. Core interests: Functional clothing, including hiking jackets, outdoor trousers, and thermal underwear. Preferred attributes: Waterproof, quick-drying fabrics, lightweight and durable materials, warmth, and wearing comfort. Core interests: Hiking and outdoor activities in different weather conditions. Preferred attributes: Lightweight and durable options, protection from rain and cold, and comfort during sustained activity. Movie → Book : A film about an astronaut solving survival problems through science, a documentary on spaceflight technology, and a documentary explaining cosmic evolution. Core interests: Science-themed films and documentaries about spaceflight and the universe. Preferred attributes: Scientific detail, clear explanations, and logically structured problem-solving plots. Core interests: Space exploration, understanding the universe, and solving problems through science. Preferred attributes: Concrete scientific detail, clear explanations of underlying principles, and coherent analysis and reasoning.
These examples illustrate the abstraction of source-domain descriptions into transferable preferences. Preferences for waterproof fabrics and thermal clothing become outdoor protection needs that can guide sports-equipment generation. Preferences for science films and documentaries become interests in scientific exploration and clear reasoning that can guide book generation. These examples illustrate how IntExpo’s RL-based profiler can effectively extract transferable preferences while preserving the user-specific information needed for personalized generation.
Safeguards Against Collapse:
Thank you for highlighting this concern. Our prompt explicitly requires the profiler to retain each user’s core interests and preferred attributes. We also use KL regularization to constrain deviations from the reference policy during RL; its role in preventing degenerate solutions is discussed in Section 3.1 of the paper.
Our w/o DD ablation shown in Table 3 (Section 4.3 in our paper) provides supporting evidence. Removing discriminator-guided RL reduces recommendation performance across all transfer directions. This supports the usefulness of RL-optimized profiles for personalized transfer, beyond simply making their source domain harder to identify.
Table 3. Ablation of discriminator-guided RL.
Model Movie → Book (R@10 / N@10) Book → Movie (R@10 / N@10) Clothing → Sports (R@10 / N@10) Sports → Clothing (R@10 / N@10) w/o DD 0.0784 / 0.0454 0.1548 / 0.0897 0.1139 / 0.0660 0.0836 / 0.0462 IntExpo 0.0853 / 0.0534 0.1570 / 0.0915 0.1155 / 0.0685 0.0854 / 0.0476
Q3: Session Threshold Sensitivity and Why Not Use LLM Segmentation.
We thank the reviewer for this question. We respond in two parts: (i) How the session split threshold is chosen and how sensitive the framework is to it; (ii) Why we do not use an LLM for segmentation.
(i) Choice of the session split threshold and sensitivity analysis
Statistical Estimation. For each target domain, we take the 85th percentile of time gaps between consecutive interactions in the training sequences, rounded up to whole days, as that domain's threshold. Only the longest ~15% of gaps count as possible intent switches, so the threshold follows each domain's own rhythm. Across all four settings, this value lands near 120 days, so we use = 120 days as the shared default.
Sensitivity Analysis. We further evaluated days, with results shown in Table 4. Results show that performance peaks or is near-optimal around Δ = 120, and drops noticeably only when Δ is too small (sessions are over-fragmented) or too large (different intents are merged). We have added these results and analysis to Section 4.7.
Table 4. Sensitivity to the session threshold.
Dataset Metric 30 Days 60 Days 90 Days 120 Days 180 Days Movie->Book Recall@10 0.0756 0.0829 0.0842 0.0853 0.0816 Movie->Book NDCG@10 0.0499 0.0526 0.0529 0.0534 0.0521 Book->Movie Recall@10 0.1535 0.1557 0.1562 0.1570 0.1548 Book->Movie NDCG@10 0.0867 0.0867 0.0876 0.0915 0.0875 Clothing->Sports Recall@10 0.1108 0.1115 0.1134 0.1155 0.1150 Clothing->Sports NDCG@10 0.0621 0.0586 0.0575 0.0685 0.0621 Sports->Clothing Recall@10 0.0837 0.0842 0.0849 0.0854 0.0850 Sports->Clothing NDCG@10 0.0426 0.0446 0.0469 0.0476 0.0472
(ii) Why we do not use an LLM for segmentation.
We use a time-interval heuristic rather than LLM-based segmentation for three main reasons:
- Stable Supervision. Intent-trajectory learning uses overlapping users' real target-domain sessions as supervision (Eqs. (6)–(11)). Time intervals give a deterministic, reproducible, and user-consistent segmentation criterion. LLM-based segmentation would vary with prompts, model versions, and sampling randomness, making the training target itself unstable.
- Lower Computational Cost. Sessionization must be run offline over all overlapping users' sequences. Timestamp-based segmentation is an O(N) lightweight operation, whereas calling an LLM to decide each boundary incurs inference cost that grows linearly with data size.
- Intent Boundaries Are Not Necessarily Semantic-Similarity Boundaries. LLM-based segmentation tends to group semantically similar interactions into one session, but real intent switches can occur between semantically similar interactions. Time intervals serve as a coarse proxy for external context changes (season, scenario, need cycle) and provide a segmentation signal independent of item semantics, preventing segmentation from being driven entirely by semantic similarity.
Responses to Reviewer 6wYE
Thank you for your careful review and constructive feedback. We hope our responses below help resolve your concerns.