- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
Existing affordance grounding (weakly supervised) methods typically focus on generalizing across different objects (e.g., shape and color), and bimanual models predict both hands' affordance. In this submission, the authors aim to associate the functional role to a specific hand, which is not explicitly modeled in existing methods.
It is discussed in the paper that localization alone cannot demonstrate if a model follows a specified execution, this seems to be a plausible statement. However, the rest of the paper is organized in a way that it is challenging for a reader to find evidence to support the proposed approach effectively addressing the problem (e.g., Table 1 contact localization). Fig. 2 is supposed to show that but it again just focuses on localization (affordance grounding).
As the authors address the affordance problem from a new angle, it is important to make sure the benchmark datasets used are suitable to validate the main hypothesis. In the paper, it is explained that GigaHands is filtered and repurposed to be used in the evaluation of this submission, and HOI4D (subset) is used as well to test capture conditions shift. Additional information is also provided in the App. A.1, but it'd be helpful to provide qualitative examples (images and labels) to show the data being used in the evaluation of the paper. And the subset seems to be relatively small compared to the original dataset. For example, HOI4D includes 1,506 recordings, only 154 recordings are used as stated in the App. A.1.
In terms of baseline comparisons, this is a major shortcoming of the submission, only two baselines are included in the comparison and several newer methods are not included, which are potentially applicable for the problem this submission aims to solve. That said, this part is another area that can be improved.
Critical strengths
The authors tackle affordance grounding from a new angle beyond localization alone. In my opinion, this is a meaningful step in the field. In daily life, we often complete a task using both hands, and each hand performs a different role. So, functional association with each hand might provide a fine-grained affordance analysis.
Critical weaknesses
The writing and readability could be improved. 1) Motivation is not clear enough, where the authors discussed existing methods largely ignored the functional association part, but did not provide the benefit of doing this. Adding this part would strengthen the motivation. 2) It is not easy to follow the paper to understand what the key differences between the proposed approach compared to the related methods are. 3) As briefly mentioned in the summary, the provided comparisons (quantitative and qualitative) do not focus on supporting the advantage of the proposed approach. The main table (Table 1) and qualitative results (Fig. 2) both focus on localization.
The experimental setup could be improved. 1) Benchmark datasets are important, especially when a paper tackles the problem from a new angle, in this case, no existing benchmark can be used or evaluation protocol could be directly used. In this case, it's important to establish that the benchmark datasets being used or the subsets selected are suitable to evaluate the proposed approach (the subset not too small). 2) Two baselines are included in the comparison, a number of recent affiance grounding methods are not included [r1 - r4]. Including these methods in the comparison would allow a reader to understand the performance of these recent methods (some are zero-shot) on the problem this submission focuses on. Note: Based on the ICLR's guidelines, papers officially published within the last two months are considered contemporaneous and the authors are not required to compare to those papers. The ECCV 2026 papers are published within two months of the ICLR paper submission, so it's not required to compare unless the authors would like to.
[r1] Weakly-Supervised Affordance Grounding Guided by Part-Level Semantic Priors, ICLR 2026
[r2] Affordance-r1: Reinforcement learning for generalizable affordance reasoning in multimodal large language models, AAAI 2026.
[r3] Token-Based Affordance Grounding with Large Vision-Language Models, ECCV 2026
[r4] A4-Agent: An Agentic Framework for Zero-Shot Affordance Reasoning, ECCV 2026
Questions for authors
Questions:
-
Clarify the motivation in terms of the benefit of providing functional association in affordance grounding.
-
Add the information regarding the benchmark datasets and the subset being used, as a reader, not enough information is provided in the initial submission.
-
Consider including more baselines to strengthen the comparison, which helps readers to understand whether the recent methods can address the problem this submission focuses on.
Suggestions for future work:
-
It's worth considering a dedicated benchmark to focus on the proposed problem. In this paper, as the focus is the proposed approach, not enough information is provided regarding the datasets being used, or whether they are suitable or providing statistical significance.
-
Improving the writing and readability can help readers understand how the proposed approach differentiates from the related methods.
-
Organize the results to support the key claim of the proposed approach, otherwise, it is not clear whether the proposed approach is effective in terms of the problem the paper focuses on addressing.