- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes QuantForge, an LLM program search framework for training quantization algorithms after discovering MXFP4. This method maintains candidate programs and unresolved design hypotheses, distinguishes competitive interpretations through comparative experiments, and requires subsequent program modifications to implement experimental conclusions.
The author further proposes the HiRes quantization method discovered by QuantForge, which combines geometric transformation, discrete coding correction, and Attention/MLP error recovery.
Critical strengths
The author used paired random seeds and a unified evaluator budget in the search experiment, and analyzed the core components through program updates, replay, and checker ablation. Compared to only reporting the final optimal program, these experiments provide more specific mechanism evidence.
HiRes achieves lower quantization performance loss on multiple models. The paper also reports the results of stage ablation, different calibration seeds, and the computational cost of BF16 backed implementation.
Critical weaknesses
QuantForge combines existing mechanisms for program evolution, reflection, hypothesis testing, and execution checking. The paper refers to this process as Progressive Residual Factorization, but the current formal description mainly involves the management of unresolved hypotheses, discriminative control selection, and code modification.
Equation (2) can distinguish the prediction of registration interpretation, but cannot guarantee the recognition of the true error mechanism. The existing ablation has demonstrated the effectiveness of a complete search system, but the contributions of correct residual interpretation, program quality control, and invalid candidate filtering have not yet been fully separated.
The search experiment mainly compared Score only, TextMem, and ReflectMem, without directly covering more complete program search frameworks such as ReEvo and AlphaEvolve. All experiments used the same GPT-5.6 Sol proposer and were not validated across other algorithm discovery tasks.
In addition, although HiRes has good simulation quantification accuracy, its native MXFP4 deployment benefits have not been directly verified. Therefore, there are still limitations to the scope of application of the two contributions.
Questions for authors
How to determine the true error mechanism corresponding to an algorithmic residue and successfully solve it? Is there an independent mechanism for verifying the correctness of registration, apart from excluding competitive interpretations?
If traditional program search methods use the same execution checks, invalid candidate filtering, and code revision constraints, but do not use competitive interpretation and residual frontiers, does QuantForge still have significant advantages?
Does QuantForge's results rely on the reasoning ability of GPT-5.6 Sol? Will different proposer LLM or other program search tasks yield similar conclusions?
How to distinguish the numerical advantages of HiRes three-stage design itself from the independent contribution of QuantForge's discovery of this stage structure?
Action Required: Respond to Author Rebuttals Before the Discussion Period Ends
Dear Reviewers,
The authors have posted their rebuttals. As the author–reviewer discussion period is coming to a close soon, please read their responses and participate in the discussion.
All reviewers are expected to respond, at minimum with a brief acknowledgment confirming that the reviewers have read and considered the authors’ rebuttals. If your concerns have been addressed or remain unresolved, please briefly indicate this in your response.
Thank you for your time and effort.
Best,
Your AC