acceptodds
Desk rejected at ICLR 2027

ProAR: Learning Prospective Reasoning with Autoregressive Video Models

Desk rejected at ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Autoregressive (AR) video models excel at causal generation, but their reliance on next-chunk prediction confines them to a short-sighted, reactive paradigm. This limitation is particularly consequential for reasoning-oriented generation, where achieving a target outcome through valid intermediate states matters more than local visual plausibility. To address this challenge, we propose Learning Prospective Reasoning with Autoregressive Video Models (ProAR), a novel framework that transforms autoregressive video generation into a goal-oriented reasoning process. ProAR introduces two key components: (1) To anchor generation to the long-range outcome, we integrate goal-frame prediction into the autoregressive loop via an asymmetric attention mask, enabling the predicted goal frame to guide the generation of intermediate states without being disrupted by them. (2) To guide short-range transitions, we introduce future representation self-alignment to encourage current hidden states to anticipate upcoming temporal dynamics. By leveraging teacher-forcing in AR training, we extract clean future representations in a single forward pass and align current representations with them using a lightweight, training-only predictor. Together, these two mechanisms seamlessly combine explicit, sparse target supervision with implicit, dense step-wise guidance, promoting coherent, goal-directed reasoning progress with modest computational cost. Experiments show that ProAR's complementary components consistently improve performance across diverse visual reasoning benchmarks. The framework proves highly training-efficient, surpassing fully trained standard AR baselines using only 25% of the training steps. This paradigm also demonstrates promising applicability to embodied reasoning tasks.

Primary area:
generative models
Keywords:
video reasoning, autoregressive video models

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 32%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.50 over 4 reviews, above 68% of the others.
Reviewer_2CAgOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

ProAR augments autoregressive video diffusion with jointly predicted goal frames and training-only alignment between current and clean next-chunk representations. Experiments on selected VBVR tasks, VideoRLVR, and WorldArena report improved reasoning scores and training-step efficiency, with the largest gains on VBVR and smaller improvements on the other benchmarks.

Critical strengths
  1. The framework coherently addresses both goal completion and the validity of intermediate states. Outcome provides terminal-goal guidance, while Transition supervises representations of the next state.
  2. The improvements on the selected VBVR tasks are substantial and exceed the reported bidirectional SFT baseline.
  3. The implementation reuses existing computation and is supported by several component and configuration ablations.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The advance over closely related future-aware autoregressive methods remains insufficiently established. Section 2 discusses future-representation distillation and hierarchical generation, but the experiments primarily compare against Standard AR and component variants.
  2. The current experiments do not clearly isolate the specific benefit of future supervision in Transition. The mechanism is closely related to future-representation alignment in Video-Mirai, with the main distinction being that ProAR obtains its targets from the same trainable backbone within a single forward pass. This offers a potentially useful efficiency advantage. However, the component ablation does not distinguish future anticipation from general representation regularization.
  3. Outcome provides clear benefits, but the independent value of repeatedly updating the predicted goal remains unclear. Outcome alone raises the VBVR score to 0.786, accounting for much of the overall improvement. However, the current experiments do not adequately distinguish the effects of auxiliary terminal-frame supervision, goal conditioning, and repeated goal estimation. Prior work such as FramePack already explores generated future endpoints as constraints on subsequent generation, making this distinction consequential. The asymmetric-attention ablation does not isolate repeated goal updating, and its average improvement is small.
  4. The controlled AR comparisons on the core reasoning tasks are limited, and the baseline’s identity requires clarification. Constructing Standard AR with the same backbone and task data is reasonable. Nevertheless, the main text describes teacher-forced causal adaptation of Wan2.2, whereas parts of the appendix refer to the baseline as Causal-Forcing. It is unclear whether these names denote the same implementation and which training stages were used.
Questions for authors
  1. Do Standard AR and the Causal-Forcing baseline mentioned in the appendix refer to the same model? Please clarify the implementation source, initialization, and training stages. If the discrepancy is only terminological, please state this explicitly.
  2. How does ProAR’s internal target construction compare with a Video-Mirai-style target under the same backbone, task data, and comparable training budget?
  3. How does repeatedly predicting the terminal goal compare with predicting it once and keeping it fixed throughout generation? A comparison controlling goal conditioning and computational budget would help distinguish the benefit of having a goal from the benefit of updating it.
  4. What evidence shows that Transition improves the backbone’s predictive representations, rather than primarily training an effective auxiliary predictor?
5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 2CAg [1/3]

We thank the reviewer for recognizing ProAR’s coherent design, substantial VBVR improvements, and efficient implementation with supporting ablations. We will address your concerns in the following response.

>>> W1 Comparison with Future-Aware Autoregressive Methods

>>> A1 Thanks for raising this practical concern! We fully agree that comparisons with closely related future-aware autoregressive methods should be established. Beyond the basic baselines in Table 1, we add two related methods, Video-Mirai and HDR, both designed for future-aware autoregressive video generation. Both methods are trained with the same backbone, data, and training steps as ProAR.

  • Video-Mirai: Video-Mirai is a future-representation alignment method closely related to our transition module. It uses a bidirectional foresight teacher to align causal hidden states with future representations. We fine-tune the bidirectional Wan2.2-TI2V-5B teacher on the same VBVR data, freeze it, and train the causal student with this alignment objective. The teacher and predictor are removed at inference.
  • HDR: HDR is a closely related video-reasoning approach, but it is currently not open-sourced. It performs hierarchical autoregressive video reasoning through coarse-to-fine denoising. We implement a three-level version on the same backbone and data, using 5, 10, and 20 denoising steps at the three levels.

Results

ModelConcentric RingOutline MatchStable SortStar MatchDomino ChainBall EaterGrid ShiftPipe PuzzleSlide PuzzleBalancing VesselsMeanInference Time
Standard AR0.7940.753‾\underline{0.753}0.5650.6890.6580.7540.720‾\underline{0.720}0.4240.3880.8800.6631.0×
ProAR (ours)0.9490.7770.8950.8710.628‾\underline{0.628}0.7810.7700.546‾\underline{0.546}0.9310.8630.801~1.2×
Video-Mirai0.7930.7280.6260.6050.6210.778‾\underline{0.778}0.5650.4800.5470.8550.6601.0×
HDR0.911‾\underline{0.911}0.7380.890‾\underline{0.890}0.869‾\underline{0.869}0.5560.7650.6800.7260.858‾\underline{0.858}0.867‾\underline{0.867}0.786‾\underline{0.786}~1.5×

ProAR achieves the strongest overall performance, with a mean score of 0.801. HDR is competitive on several individual tasks but requires higher inference cost, while Video-Mirai has a mean score close to Standard AR. Overall, ProAR offers the most effective and efficient solution, achieving the strongest performance with only modest inference overhead.

>>> W2 Separating Future Anticipation from Representation Regularization

>>> A2 We truly appreciate this concern, and thank the reviewer for recognizing the efficiency benefit of constructing the targets within the same forward pass. To distinguish future anticipation from general representation regularization, we compare next-chunk and current-chunk clean-feature alignment using the same predictor and training budget.

  • Next-chunk alignment (ProAR, second line): aligns current noisy features with clean features from the next chunk. Since the target represents a future state, we use this setting to measure future anticipation.
  • Current-chunk alignment (third line): aligns current noisy features with clean features from the same chunk. Since this target only reinforces the current representation without future information, we use it as a control for representation regularization.
ModelConcentric RingOutline MatchStable SortStar MatchDomino ChainBall EaterGrid ShiftPipe PuzzleSlide PuzzleBalancing VesselsMean
Standard AR0.7940.7530.5650.6890.6580.7540.720‾\underline{0.720}0.4240.3880.8800.663
Future Alignment0.9490.7770.895‾\underline{0.895}0.8710.628‾\underline{0.628}0.7810.7700.546‾\underline{0.546}0.9310.863‾\underline{0.863}0.801
Current Alignment0.923‾\underline{0.923}0.776‾\underline{0.776}0.9220.867‾\underline{0.867}0.5880.779‾\underline{0.779}0.5580.5950.906‾\underline{0.906}0.8510.777‾\underline{0.777}

Next-chunk alignment achieves a mean score of 0.801, compared with 0.777 for current-chunk alignment, and performs better on 8 of 10 tasks. Since both settings use clean-feature alignment, this gap shows that future anticipation provides a stronger benefit than current-representation regularization alone.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 2CAg [2/3]

>>> W3 Separating Goal Conditioning from Goal Updating

>>> A3 Thanks for this insightful concern! We agree that it is important to distinguish the benefit of repeatedly updating the goal from simply having a fixed goal. Following the reviewer’s helpful reference to FramePack [1], we add controlled comparisons on VBVR with three goal-conditioning strategies:

  • Fixed predicted goal (first row):: Predicts the goal once from the first chunk, and reuses it for the rest of the video.
  • Updated predicted goal (ProAR, second row):: Re-predicts the goal at every chunk to guide generation dynamically. Results are from the paper.
  • Fixed ground-truth goal (third row): Use the actual final frame as a fixed goal throughout generation. (an upper bound, unavailable at test time)
ModelConcentric RingOutline MatchStable SortStar MatchDomino ChainBall EaterGrid ShiftPipe PuzzleSlide PuzzleBalancing VesselsMean
Fixed predicted goal0.943‾\underline{0.943}0.7580.890‾\underline{0.890}0.8650.639‾\underline{0.639}0.762‾\underline{0.762}0.7630.565‾\underline{0.565}0.901‾\underline{0.901}0.8500.794
Updated predicted goal (ProAR)0.9490.777‾\underline{0.777}0.8950.871‾\underline{0.871}0.6280.7810.770‾\underline{0.770}0.5460.9310.863‾\underline{0.863}0.801‾\underline{0.801}
Fixed ground-truth goal0.9310.8680.8750.8890.7740.7360.8240.7920.8900.8670.845

Takeaways:

  • Dynamic updates beat a fixed prediction: Comparing Row 2 against Row 1, updating the goal at every chunk improves performance on 8 out of 10 tasks, raising the overall mean from 0.794 to 0.801 and bringing it closer to the oracle upper bound (0.845).

  • Why updating matters: A single initial prediction relies solely on the starting frame, which often lacks enough context to foresee the exact final state. By updating the goal as the video unfolds, ProAR continuously corrects its target using newly generated visual evidence. Only on tasks where the final state is already obvious from the very first frame (e.g., Pipe Puzzle) does a fixed initial prediction suffice.

These results validate our default design of updating the goal. We will also cite and discuss FramePack [1] as a related endpoint-conditioning method that uses generated future endpoints to guide subsequent generation.

>>> W4 Clarifying the Standard AR Baseline

>>> A4 Thanks for pointing this out! "Standard AR" refers to our teacher-forced causal adaptation of Wan2.2 on the same backbone and task data. The term “Causal-Forcing” in the appendix refers to this same implementation. We sincerely apologize for the typos and will use "Standard AR" consistently. To broaden the AR comparisons on the reasoning tasks, we will also include the additional baselines from W1.

Questions

Q1: Do Standard AR and the Causal-Forcing baseline mentioned in the appendix refer to the same model?

>>> A1 Thanks for the question. As clarified in W4, "Standard AR" and the “Causal-Forcing” baseline in the appendix refer to the same model: a teacher-forced autoregressive adaptation of Wan2.2, trained on the specific task data. The difference is purely terminological. We sincerely apologize for the typos and will correct the naming throughout the revised manuscript.

Q2: How does ProAR’s internal target construction compare with a Video-Mirai-style target under the same backbone, task data, and comparable training budget?

>>> A2 Thanks! Please see W1. We implemented a Video-Mirai-style future-representation alignment baseline using the same backbone, VBVR data, and training budget. ProAR achieves a substantially higher mean score (0.801 vs. 0.660) with only modest inference overhead.

Q3: How does repeatedly predicting the terminal goal compare with predicting it once and keeping it fixed throughout generation?

>>> A3 Thanks for the thoughtful question! Please see W3. Repeatedly updating the goal is more adaptive and broadly effective across tasks, while a fixed predicted goal suffices when the endpoint is easy to infer.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 2CAg [3/3]

Q4: What evidence shows that Transition improves the backbone’s predictive representations, rather than primarily training an effective auxiliary predictor?

>>> A4 Insightful question! To directly verify what the backbone itself learns, we drop the training predictor and train a lightweight MLP probe on its frozen features.

Experimental Setup. On the Stable Sort task from VBVR, we extract layer-15 hidden representations from the first autoregressive chunk of both Standard AR and ProAR. Using these frozen features, we train a probe to reconstruct future RGB frames at two horizons:

  • H1: the final RGB frame of the next chunk;
  • H2: the final RGB frame of the second next chunk.
MethodH1 PSNR ↑H2 PSNR ↑
Standard AR15.5314.85
ProAR16.4115.70

(Higher PSNR indicates better reconstruction quality.)

With the predictor removed and the backbone frozen, ProAR still predicts better futures across both horizons. This confirms that transition module directly enriches the backbone's own representations with future information.

[1] Lvmin Zhang et al. "Frame Context Packing and Drift Prevention in Next-Frame-Prediction Video Diffusion Models." NeurIPS, 2025.

Reviewer_1jekOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper addresses short-sighted generation in autoregressive video models: locally plausible chunks do not necessarily lead to the correct outcome or valid intermediate states. ProAR introduces two training mechanisms. Outcome jointly predicts the current chunk and a final goal frame, using asymmetric attention to let the goal guide current generation. Transition trains current hidden representations to predict those of the next clean chunk, reusing future information available during teacher-forcing; its predictor is removed at inference. Experiments compare Standard AR, component variants, and ProAR using the same Wan2.2 5B backbone on VBVR, VideoRLVR, and WorldArena. The reported gains include an increase from 0.663 to 0.801 on the ten selected VBVR tasks, a VideoRLVR success-rate increase from 50.97% to 52.97%, and smaller aggregate improvements on WorldArena. The authors attribute these gains to combining outcome guidance with local future supervision.

Critical strengths
  1. The VBVR gain from 0.663 to 0.801 with the same backbone is substantial and spans multiple tasks (Table 1). This is more convincing than a comparison only against an unadapted pretrained model, and is the strongest part of the paper.

  2. The two modules have clear roles in guiding outcomes and transitions. Transition reuses representations from the existing training forward pass, and its predictor is removed at inference. The appendix also reports the overall overhead, making the practical cost easier to assess.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Most of the gain appears to come from the goal branch: Outcome alone reaches 0.786 versus 0.801 for the full model (Table 1). This supports the overall recipe, but does not isolate the value of the future temporal target. If aligning to the clean current representation gives similar gains, the mechanism claim would need to be narrower.

  2. Complementarity is uneven. Transition alone reaches 49.60% on Sokoban, compared with 46.00% for the full model (Table 3). This does not negate the VBVR gains, but shows that combining the modules is not consistently better. Without repeated training or uncertainty estimates, the smaller increments are difficult to assess.

  3. Controlled comparisons are mostly against Standard AR and internal variants. Related future-prediction or representation-alignment approaches are not compared under the same setup, leaving the added value over existing ideas unclear. This contributes to my current weak-reject recommendation.

Questions for authors
  1. What happens when alignment targets the clean current representation instead of the future one?
  2. Do repeated training runs preserve Transition's gains and the Sokoban regression?
  3. Could you compare against one related future-prediction method with the same backbone and budget?
5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 1jek [1/2]

We thank the reviewer for recognizing ProAR’s strong VBVR gains, clear module design, and efficient training. We will address your concerns in the following response.

>>> W1 Isolating the Value of Future Temporal Targets

>>> A1 Thanks for raising this rigorous concern! We agree that the outcome branch accounts for most of the overall improvement, while transition provides a smaller but meaningful additional gain. Following the suggestion, we add a controlled experiment on next-chunk and current-chunk clean-feature alignment.

  • Next-chunk alignment (ProAR, second line): aligns current noisy features with clean features from the next chunk. Results are from the paper.
  • Current-chunk alignment (third line): aligns current noisy features with clean features from the same chunk. We retrain the model with this alternative objective as a control experiment.
ModelConcentric RingOutline MatchStable SortStar MatchDomino ChainBall EaterGrid ShiftPipe PuzzleSlide PuzzleBalancing VesselsMean
Standard AR0.7940.7530.5650.6890.6580.7540.720‾\underline{0.720}0.4240.3880.8800.663
Future Alignment0.9490.7770.895‾\underline{0.895}0.8710.628‾\underline{0.628}0.7810.7700.546‾\underline{0.546}0.9310.863‾\underline{0.863}0.801
Current Alignment0.923‾\underline{0.923}0.776‾\underline{0.776}0.9220.867‾\underline{0.867}0.5880.779‾\underline{0.779}0.5580.5950.906‾\underline{0.906}0.8510.777‾\underline{0.777}

Next-chunk alignment reaches 0.801, compared with 0.777 for current-chunk alignment, and performs better on 8 of 10 tasks. This shows that transition benefits from the prospective future target, rather than simply from aligning with clean features.

>>> W2 Stability of Component Complementarity

>>> A2 Thanks for the concern! We recognize that the two components do not strictly reinforce each other on every individual metric. Given our computational budget, we retrain the Transition-only and full ProAR models with an additional seed and report the mean ± std below:

ModelMaze Prec.Maze SRFlowFree Prec.FlowFree SRSokoban Prec.Sokoban SR
w/ Transition89.59 ± 0.4280.70 ± 0.2856.45 ± 0.9227.10 ± 0.5745.56 ± 0.2149.20 ± 0.57
ProAR (ours)93.08 ± 0.3583.05 ± 0.4960.97 ± 0.5729.90 ± 0.4247.42 ± 0.2846.45 ± 0.64

The results are consistent with the original findings. ProAR improves precision on all three VideoRLVR tasks and improves success rate on two of three tasks, while Transition retains an advantage on Sokoban success rate. The relatively small changes across runs also indicate that these observing patterns are stable.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 1jek [2/2]

>>> W3 Matched Comparisons with Related Methods

>>> A3 Thanks for this practical suggestion! We totally agree that comparing against related future-prediction & representation-alignment methods is crucial for clarifying ProAR’s value. Following the suggestion, we evaluate two most related baselines, Video-Mirai and HDR, both designed for autoregressive video generation.

We implement them using the same backbone, VBVR data, and training budget as ProAR, and report both performance and inference cost.

  • Video-Mirai [1]: Video-Mirai is a future-representation alignment method closely related to our transition module. It uses a bidirectional foresight teacher to provide future-representation targets for a causal video generator. We first fine-tune the bidirectional Wan2.2-TI2V-5B teacher on the same VBVR training data, freeze it, and train the causal student with future-representation alignment. The teacher and predictor are removed at inference, so the model keeps the standard AR inference cost.
  • HDR [2]: HDR is a closely related video-reasoning approach, but it is currently not open-sourced. It performs hierarchical autoregressive video reasoning through coarse-to-fine denoising. We implement a three-level version on the same backbone and data, using 5, 10, and 20 denoising steps at the three levels.
ModelConcentric RingOutline MatchStable SortStar MatchDomino ChainBall EaterGrid ShiftPipe PuzzleSlide PuzzleBalancing VesselsMeanInference Time
Standard AR0.7940.753‾\underline{0.753}0.5650.6890.6580.7540.720‾\underline{0.720}0.4240.3880.8800.6631.0×
ProAR (ours)0.9490.7770.8950.8710.628‾\underline{0.628}0.7810.7700.546‾\underline{0.546}0.9310.8630.801~1.2×
Video-Mirai0.7930.7280.6260.6050.6210.778‾\underline{0.778}0.5650.4800.5470.8550.6601.0×
HDR0.911‾\underline{0.911}0.7380.890‾\underline{0.890}0.869‾\underline{0.869}0.5560.7650.6800.7260.858‾\underline{0.858}0.867‾\underline{0.867}0.786‾\underline{0.786}~1.5×

ProAR achieves the best mean score at 0.801 and outperforms Video-Mirai and HDR on 8 of 10 tasks. HDR is competitive on several individual tasks, but requires higher inference cost. Video-Mirai has the same inference cost as Standard AR, but its mean score is 0.660, showing limited ability on video reasoning tasks.

Overall, ProAR achieves the best performance among all compared methods while maintaining low inference overhead, making it both effective and efficient.

Questions

Q1: What happens when alignment targets the clean current representation instead of the future one?

>>> A1 Thanks! Please refer to W1. In our controlled comparison, aligning with current features (score 0.777) provides smaller gains than aligning with future features (score 0.801, default design), highlighting the value of future-aware supervision.

Q2: Do repeated training runs preserve Transition's gains and the Sokoban regression?

>>> A2 Thanks! Please see W2. The additional runs preserve both patterns: ProAR achieves notably stronger overall performance, while transition only remains slightly better on Sokoban success rate.

Q3: Could you compare against one related future-prediction method with the same backbone and budget?

>>> A3 Thanks for the constructive question! Please see W3. We compare ProAR with two related future-prediction method, Video-Mirai and HDR. ProAR achieves the strongest performance while maintaining modest inference overhead.


References

[1] Yu, Yonghao, et al. “Video-Mirai: Autoregressive Video Diffusion Models Need Foresight.” NeurIPS, 2026.

[2] Qian, Zezhong, et al. “Hierarchical Denoising for Multi-Step Visual Reasoning.” NeurIPS, 2026.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Kind Follow-up Regarding Remaining Concerns

Dear Reviewer 1jek,

Thank you for reviewing our paper and rebuttal. We sincerely appreciate your valuable feedback.

Could you kindly let us know whether our response has addressed your concerns? If any concerns remain, we would greatly appreciate your further guidance. We would also be grateful for any suggestions on revising the paper.

Best regards,

The authors

Reviewer_ENxPOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

ProAR augments autoregressive video diffusion with two forms of future supervision: a jointly denoised goal frame that guides current generation through asymmetric attention, and a training-only predictor that aligns current noisy features with clean next-chunk features. The latter reuses representations from the teacher-forced forward pass. Using a Wan2.2-5B backbone, the paper reports a substantial improvement on ten selected VBVR tasks, smaller gains on VideoRLVR and WorldArena, and faster convergence than its standard AR baseline.

Critical strengths

The VBVR improvement is substantial under the controlled AR comparison: the mean score rises from 0.663 to 0.801, with improvements on eight of ten tasks (Table 1). ProAR also exceeds the fine-tuned bidirectional baseline at 0.736. This provides useful evidence that explicit future supervision can improve task-oriented video generation.

The method makes efficient use of teacher forcing. Clean future features are reused within the same backbone pass, and the alignment predictor is removed at inference. Appendix A.1 reports 12–14% additional training cost and approximately 12% inference overhead for four-frame chunks. This accuracy–cost tradeoff is practically appealing.

Critical weaknesses

The experiments do not establish the advantage over the closest existing approaches. Section 2 identifies Video-Mirai as closely related future-representation supervision and HDR as closely related autoregressive visual reasoning, but neither is evaluated. The standard-AR comparison establishes usefulness relative to that baseline, while leaving the contribution relative to existing future-aware methods unclear. A matched-backbone, matched-data comparison with a relevant approach, reporting both performance and cost, would materially strengthen the case.

The evidence for the specific prospective-reasoning mechanisms is incomplete. Outcome alone reaches 0.786 on VBVR versus 0.801 for the full model, while removing the asymmetric mask gives 0.799 (Tables 1 and 5). There is no same-chunk clean-feature alignment control to distinguish future prediction from general representation regularization. Figure 6 visualizes the trained predictor’s output rather than independently testing what the backbone retains after that predictor is removed. Uncertainty estimates are also absent, which matters for the smaller gains on VideoRLVR and WorldArena. Finally, the 2,500-step efficiency result precedes activation of Transition at step 7,500, so it principally supports Outcome guidance.

Questions for authors

How does ProAR compare with a closely related future-aware method, such as HDR or an adaptation of Video-Mirai, under matched backbone, data, and compute accounting?

Does next-chunk alignment outperform same-chunk clean-feature alignment with the same predictor and training budget? Can a matched probe of the frozen backbone establish improved future prediction without using the training predictor?

How stable are the incremental improvements over Outcome alone and the unmasked variant? Please report paired test-set uncertainty and, where feasible, repeated runs. Was configuration selection performed on a separate validation set?

5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer ENxP [1/3]

We thank the reviewer for recognizing ProAR’s substantial VBVR improvements, effective use of teacher forcing, and favorable accuracy–cost tradeoff. We will address your concerns in the following response.

>>> W1 Additional Future-Aware Baselines

>>> A1 Thanks for the valuable suggestion! We completely agree that comparisons with the closest existing approaches are important for clarifying ProAR’s contribution. As suggested, we implement two baselines, Video-Mirai and HDR, using matched backbones and matched data, and report both performance and inference cost.

Setting

  • Video-Mirai: Video-Mirai is a future-representation alignment method closely related to our transition module. Since it requires a bidirectional foresight teacher, we first fine-tune a bidirectional Wan2.2-TI2V-5B model on the same VBVR training set. We then freeze this teacher and train the causal student with future-representation alignment. The teacher and predictor are removed at inference, so the deployed model keeps the Standard AR inference cost.
  • HDR: HDR is a closely related video-reasoning approach, but it is currently not open-sourced. We implement a three-level hierarchical version on the same Wan2.2-TI2V-5B backbone and VBVR training data, using coarse-to-fine denoising with 5, 10, and 20 steps at the three levels.

Both methods are trained with the same backbone, data, and training steps as ProAR.

Results

ModelConcentric RingOutline MatchStable SortStar MatchDomino ChainBall EaterGrid ShiftPipe PuzzleSlide PuzzleBalancing VesselsMeanInference Time
Standard AR0.7940.753‾\underline{0.753}0.5650.6890.6580.7540.720‾\underline{0.720}0.4240.3880.8800.6631.0×
ProAR (ours)0.9490.7770.8950.8710.628‾\underline{0.628}0.7810.7700.546‾\underline{0.546}0.9310.8630.801~1.2×
Video-Mirai0.7930.7280.6260.6050.6210.778‾\underline{0.778}0.5650.4800.5470.8550.6601.0×
HDR0.911‾\underline{0.911}0.7380.890‾\underline{0.890}0.869‾\underline{0.869}0.5560.7650.6800.7260.858‾\underline{0.858}0.867‾\underline{0.867}0.786‾\underline{0.786}~1.5×

ProAR achieves the best overall performance, outperforming Video-Mirai and HDR on 8 of 10 tasks. HDR remains competitive on several individual tasks, especially Pipe Puzzle, but requires approximately 1.5× the inference cost. Video-Mirai has same inference cost to Standard AR, but its mean score is 0.660, showing limited ability on these reasoning tasks.

Overall, these comparisons show that ProAR provides the most effective and efficient solution among the evaluated methods, achieving the strongest reasoning performance with only a modest inference overhead.

>>> W2 More Evidence for the Prospective Reasoning Mechanisms

>>> A2 Thanks for pointing out where the evidence could be clearer! In our submission, we provided ablations of Outcome and Transition (Tables 1 and 3), asymmetric attention (Table 5), and the alignment layer and projector (Tables 6 and 7 in Appendix A.2), along with alignment visualizations in Figure 6. We will address your points in turn below, with additional experiments where needed.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer ENxP [2/3]

>>> W2.1 Stability of the Component Ablations

>>> A2.1 Thanks for this practical concern. To assess stability, we repeat both the outcome-only vs. ProAR and w/o asymmetric mask vs. ProAR comparisons across three random seeds, and report the mean ± std below:

  • Outcome-only vs. ProAR
ModelMean ± Std
Outcome alone0.787±0.0017
Full model (ProAR)0.801±0.0010

We also conduct a paired test across all 500 samples on the original evaluation: ProAR outperforms the outcome-only baseline on 398 out of 500 samples, with a 95% confidence interval of [+1.43, +1.91].

These results show a clear and stable improvement over outcome alone across all seeds and samples.

  • Without Asymmetric Mask vs. ProAR
ModelMean ± Std
w/o Asym. Mask0.797±0.0012
Full model (ProAR)0.801±0.0010

Similarly, in the paired test across the 500 original samples, ProAR beats the unrestricted variant on 310 out of 500 samples, with a 95% confidence interval of [+0.01, +0.03].

We recognize that the gain from asymmetric masking is relatively small, but remains consistent across seeds. Furthermore, since the asymmetric mask provides a reliable improvement while maintaining a sparser attention pattern, we retain this design in ProAR.

>>> W2.2 Distinguish future prediction from general representation regularization

>>> A2.2 Insightful suggestion! As suggested, we conduct a controlled experiment to validate the future-alignment design of our transition module. We compare next-chunk and same-chunk clean-feature alignment using the same predictor.

  • Next-chunk alignment (ProAR, second line): aligns current noisy features with clean features from the next chunk. This result is from the paper.
  • Same-chunk alignment (third line): aligns current noisy features with clean features from the same chunk. We retrain the model with alternative objective as a control experiment.
ModelConcentric RingOutline MatchStable SortStar MatchDomino ChainBall EaterGrid ShiftPipe PuzzleSlide PuzzleBalancing VesselsMean
Standard AR0.7940.7530.5650.6890.6580.7540.720‾\underline{0.720}0.4240.3880.8800.663
Future Alignment0.9490.7770.895‾\underline{0.895}0.8710.628‾\underline{0.628}0.7810.7700.546‾\underline{0.546}0.9310.863‾\underline{0.863}0.801
Current Alignment0.923‾\underline{0.923}0.776‾\underline{0.776}0.9220.867‾\underline{0.867}0.5880.779‾\underline{0.779}0.5580.5950.906‾\underline{0.906}0.8510.777‾\underline{0.777}

Next-chunk alignment improves the mean score from 0.777 to 0.801 and performs better on 8 of 10 tasks. Because both variants use clean-feature teachers and the same predictor, this comparison directly distinguishes future prediction from general representation regularization. The results show that supervising future dynamics is more effective than aligning with clean current chunk alone, highlighting the importance of prospective reasoning.

>>> W2.3 Future Prediction in the Frozen Backbone

>>> A2.3 Nice suggestion! To test what the backbone retains after removing the training predictor, we train a lightweight probe on frozen Standard AR and ProAR representations.

Setting. We use the Stable Sort task from VBVR. From the first autoregressive chunk, we extract the layer-15 hidden representations and train an MLP probe to predict:

  • H1: the last RGB frame of the next chunk;
  • H2: the last RGB frame of the second next chunk.

We evaluate future-frame reconstruction using PSNR, where higher values indicate better prediction.

MethodH1 PSNRH2 PSNR
Standard AR15.5314.85
ProAR16.4115.70

(Higher PSNR indicates better reconstruction quality.)

ProAR achieves higher PSNR for both H1 and H2, showing that its frozen backbone retains more predictive information about future states even after the training predictor is removed.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer ENxP [3/3]

>>> W2.4 Uncertainty estimation

>>> A2.4 Thanks! As suggested, to estimate the uncertainty, we re-evaluate VideoRLVR with three random seeds and report the mean ± std below.

ModelMaze Prec.Maze SRFlowFree Prec.FlowFree SRSokoban Prec.Sokoban SR
Standard AR89.33 ± 0.3579.59 ± 0.4955.18 ± 0.8629.45 ± 0.4840.12 ± 0.3743.87 ± 0.51
ProAR (ours)93.27 ± 0.4182.75 ± 0.6360.68 ± 0.6430.14 ± 0.5247.71 ± 0.5446.17 ± 0.76

As shown in the table, results are consistent across random seeds with minimal variance. On VideoRLVR, ProAR reliably improves Precision on every task (from 61.54 to 67.22) and drives steady gains in success rate.

>>> W2.5 Attributing Efficiency Gains Across Training Stages

>>> A2.5 Thanks for raising this point! We agree that the 2,500-step result primarily reflects outcome guidance, since we activate transition at step 7,500. However, Figure 4 shows a clear improvement between steps 7,500 and 10,000 after the transition module is introduced. This indicates that transition also brings meaningful gains beyond outcome, with zero inference overhead.

Questions

Q1: How does ProAR compare with a closely related future-aware method, such as HDR or an adaptation of Video-Mirai, under matched backbone, data, and compute accounting?

>>> A1 Thanks for the question! Please see W1. We compare ProAR with both HDR and Video-Mirai using matched backbones, data, and training budgets. We show that ProAR achieves the best overall performance with only modest computational overhead.

Q2: Does next-chunk alignment outperform same-chunk clean-feature alignment with the same predictor and training budget?

>>> A2 Yes. Next-chunk alignment (our default design, score 0.801) clearly outperforms same-chunk alignment (score 0.777). Please refer to W2.2.

Q3: Can a matched probe of the frozen backbone establish improved future prediction without using the training predictor?

>>> A3 Yes. Please see W2.3. We added a matched probe that reconstructs better future frames from ProAR's frozen representations. This directly confirms that the backbone itself retains stronger future-predictive information.

Q4: How stable are the incremental improvements over Outcome alone and the unmasked variant? Please report paired test-set uncertainty and, where feasible, repeated runs. Was configuration selection performed on a separate validation set?

>>> A4 Thanks! The improvement over outcome alone is clear and stable across seeds. The gain over the unmasked variant is smaller but consistent. Please see W2.1 for the detailed results.

Regarding configuration selection, we use the controlled ablations in the Appendix to determine a single shared configuration, including the feature block, predictor DiT depth, loss weights, and other architectural choices. We fixed this configuration across all benchmarks and methods, so the comparison does not rely on task-specific tuning and reflects the effectiveness of our design under a consistent setup.

Reviewer_9kKJOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
1
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents ProAR, a framework for improving goal-directed reasoning in autoregressive video diffusion models. It introduces two components: Outcome Guidance, which jointly predicts the current video chunk and a final goal frame using asymmetric attention, and Transition Guidance, which aligns current noisy representations with clean next-chunk representations obtained from the same teacher-forced forward pass. Experiments demonstrate substantial improvements on the selected VBVR tasks, smaller gains on VideoRLVR and WorldArena, and faster convergence than a standard autoregressive baseline.

Critical strengths

1,Clear motivation and coherent design. The paper addresses an important challenge in video-native reasoning: generating valid intermediate states while reaching the intended outcome. Its two components provide complementary forms of supervision at different temporal scales.

2,Efficient use of internal representations. Transition Guidance reuses features already computed during teacher-forced training, avoiding an external teacher or an additional backbone forward pass. The predictor is removed at inference.

3,Strong results on the selected VBVR tasks. ProAR improves the mean score from approximately 0.664 to 0.801 and outperforms the standard AR baseline on eight of ten tasks. The controlled comparison using the same backbone provides useful evidence of effectiveness.

4,Useful ablations and efficiency analysis. The paper examines component contributions, attention masking, alignment layers, predictor depth, and training schedules. It also reports computational overhead and demonstrates faster convergence.

Critical weaknesses

1, The experiments do not sufficiently isolate prospective reasoning from auxiliary supervision. Aligning current noisy features with future clean features combines temporal prediction with denoising representation learning. A same-chunk clean-feature alignment baseline would help establish whether anticipating the future is essential. Similarly, retaining goal prediction while blocking current-to-goal attention would distinguish auxiliary supervision from explicit goal conditioning.

2, Evidence for the asymmetric attention mechanism is limited. Table 5 shows only a small improvement from 0.799 to 0.801 over unrestricted current–goal interaction. Without uncertainty estimates or repeated runs, this does not convincingly establish the importance of the proposed directional information flow.

3, Component complementarity is inconsistent, and abstract reasoning gains are modest. Average VideoRLVR success improves by only two percentage points. On Sokoban, the full model achieves 46.0% success, below the 49.6% achieved by Transition Guidance alone. These results qualify the claim that the components consistently reinforce each other.

4, Broader planning and embodied reasoning claims exceed the demonstrated evidence. The paper does not systematically evaluate generalization to longer horizons or greater task difficulty. WorldArena shows a modest EWMScore improvement from 60.43 to 60.95 and evaluates generated videos rather than closed-loop execution, providing limited evidence for improved embodied task completion.

Questions for authors

Does future-feature alignment outperform alignment with the current chunk’s clean features?

Does goal prediction still help when current tokens cannot attend to goal tokens?

Are the small gains from asymmetric masking and on VideoRLVR statistically reliable?

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 9kKJ [1/2]

We thank the reviewer for recognizing ProAR’s clear motivation, efficient use of internal representations, strong results, and thorough ablations. We will address your concerns in the following response.

>>> W1 Isolating Prospective Reasoning from Auxiliary Supervision

>>> A1 Thanks for this thoughtful suggestion! We agree that isolating prospective reasoning from auxiliary supervision is crucial. This concern directly relates to the design of our two core modules, transition and outcome. To validate both design choices, we add two controlled ablations below.

1. Transition: Future Anticipation vs. Representation Regularization

To validate the design of the transition module, we compare future-feature alignment against a same-chunk alignment control:

  • Next-chunk alignment (ProAR, second line): aligns current noisy features with clean features from the next chunk. Results are from the paper.
  • Same-chunk alignment (third line): aligns current noisy features with clean features from the same chunk. We retrain the model with this alternative objective while keeping all other settings identical.
ModelConcentric RingOutline MatchStable SortStar MatchDomino ChainBall EaterGrid ShiftPipe PuzzleSlide PuzzleBalancing VesselsMean
Standard AR0.7940.7530.5650.6890.6580.7540.720‾\underline{0.720}0.4240.3880.8800.663
Future Alignment0.9490.7770.895‾\underline{0.895}0.8710.628‾\underline{0.628}0.7810.7700.546‾\underline{0.546}0.9310.863‾\underline{0.863}0.801
Current Alignment0.923‾\underline{0.923}0.776‾\underline{0.776}0.9220.867‾\underline{0.867}0.5880.779‾\underline{0.779}0.5580.5950.906‾\underline{0.906}0.8510.777‾\underline{0.777}

Next-chunk alignment outperforms same-chunk alignment, improving the mean score from 0.777 to 0.801 and performing better on 8 of 10 tasks. Since both variants use clean-feature teachers, this result shows that the gain comes from supervising future dynamics, rather than from clean-feature alignment alone.

2. Outcome: Explicit Goal Conditioning vs. Auxiliary Supervision

To validate the design of the outcome module, we compare explicit asymmetric goal conditioning against a non-interacting attention control:

  • Asymmetric mask (ProAR, explicit goal conditioning, second line): current can attend to goal, while goal cannot attend to current. Results are from the paper.
  • Bidirectional mask (auxiliary supervision, third line): current and goal cannot attend to each other. We retrain the model with this attention mask while keeping all other settings identical.
ModelConcentric RingOutline MatchStable SortStar MatchDomino ChainBall EaterGrid ShiftPipe PuzzleSlide PuzzleBalancing VesselsMean
Standard AR0.7940.7530.5650.6890.6580.7540.720‾\underline{0.720}0.4240.3880.8800.663
Asymmetric mask0.9490.7770.8950.8710.6280.7810.7700.5460.9310.863‾\underline{0.863}0.801
Bidirectional mask0.833‾\underline{0.833}0.754‾\underline{0.754}0.705‾\underline{0.705}0.793‾\underline{0.793}0.646‾\underline{0.646}0.769‾\underline{0.769}0.6820.456‾\underline{0.456}0.431‾\underline{0.431}0.8360.691‾\underline{0.691}

Observation: The bidirectional-mask model still improves over Standard AR (from 0.663 to 0.691), showing that goal prediction offers useful auxiliary supervision even without direct token interaction. However, the asymmetric mask boosts the mean score much further from 0.691 to 0.801, proving that explicit goal conditioning provides a substantial gain beyond auxiliary supervision alone.

Together, these controls directly support the specific designs of both modules: transition benefits from anticipating the future, while outcome benefits from explicit goal conditioning.

>>> W2 Robustness of the Asymmetric Attention Design

>>> A2 Thanks for raising this concern. To further validate the directional information flow, we repeat the comparison with three random seeds and report the mean ± standard deviation:

ModelMean ± Std
w/o Asym. Mask0.797 ± 0.0012
ProAR (ours)0.801 ± 0.0015

Across repeated runs, the asymmetric mask maintains a consistent improvement over the unrestricted variant. Moreover, it also keeps the goal representation clean from noisy current tokens, producing a sparser attention pattern. Since the gain is reliable and the attention pattern is sparse, we adopt this asymmetric attention design.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 9kKJ [2/2]

>>> W3 Consistent Component Gains

>>> A3 We appreciate this constructive comment. To verify the statistical reliability of our findings, we re-evaluated Table 5 across three random seeds and report the mean ± std below:

ModelMaze Prec.Maze SRFlowFree Prec.FlowFree SRSokoban Prec.Sokoban SR
Standard AR89.33 ± 0.3579.59 ± 0.4955.18 ± 0.8629.45±0.48‾\underline{29.45 \pm 0.48}40.12 ± 0.3743.87 ± 0.51
w/ Outcome92.99±0.39‾\underline{92.99 \pm 0.39}82.24±0.39‾\underline{82.24 \pm 0.39}57.90±0.63‾\underline{57.90 \pm 0.63}23.29 ± 0.7743.68 ± 0.4044.26 ± 0.49
w/ Transition89.38 ± 0.4780.96 ± 0.4956.38 ± 0.6626.76 ± 0.3445.32±0.45‾\underline{45.32 \pm 0.45}49.45 ± 0.59
ProAR (ours)93.27 ± 0.4182.75 ± 0.6360.68 ± 0.6430.14 ± 0.5247.71 ± 0.5446.17±0.76‾\underline{46.17 \pm 0.76}

As shown in the table, our results are stable across seeds, and combining both components yields substantial, consistent gains in Precision across every single task (lifting Mean Precision from 61.54 to 67.22). While the two components do not strictly reinforce each other on every individual metric, ProAR still consistently achieves the strongest overall balance across the benchmark.

>>> W4 Embodied Evaluation

>>> A4 We truly appreciate this concern. We would like to clarify that our main focus in this work is video generation and video reasoning. From this perspective, we agree that the WorldArena result is best viewed as an initial transfer test, rather than a full evaluation of long-horizon, closed-loop embodied control. Within this setting, ProAR improves 13 out of 16 metrics in the AR comparison, providing encouraging evidence for transfer to embodied video simulation. We will present this result more carefully within this scope, and we believe that extending prospective video reasoning to embodied control is a very promising direction for future work.

Questions

Q1. Does future-feature alignment outperform alignment with the current chunk’s clean features?

>>> A1 Yes. Future-feature alignment outperforms current-feature alignment. We validate this through a controlled same-chunk alignment baseline. Please see the transition analysis in W1.

Q2. Does goal prediction still help when current tokens cannot attend to goal tokens?

>>> A2 Yes. Goal prediction still helps when current and goal tokens cannot attend to each other. However, it delivers a much larger gain through explicit goal conditioning when current can attend goal (as default). Please see the outcome analysis in W1.

Q3: Are the small gains from asymmetric masking and on VideoRLVR statistically reliable?

>>> A3 Thanks! Please see W2 and W3. To prove this, we evaluate both the asymmetric-masking (W2) and VideoRLVR (W3) across multiple random seeds. The results show that the gains are consistent across runs.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Kind Follow-up Regarding Remaining Concerns

Dear Reviewer 9kKJ,

Thank you for reviewing our paper and rebuttal. We sincerely appreciate your valuable feedback.

Could you kindly let us know whether our response has addressed your concerns? If any concerns remain, we would greatly appreciate your further guidance. We would also be grateful for any suggestions on revising the paper.

Best regards,

The authors

Dear Reviewer 9kKJ,

Thank you for your valuable feedback and efforts during the review process!

As the discussion period is approaching its end (less than 6 hours), we kindly ask whether you have any remaining concerns. We would be happy to address them and further clarify our work before the discussion closes.

We would also be grateful if you could take a look at our revised manuscript, where we have marked the changes in blue.

We sincerely appreciate your time and the opportunity to discuss our work.

Best,

The authors

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.