- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
ProAR augments autoregressive video diffusion with jointly predicted goal frames and training-only alignment between current and clean next-chunk representations. Experiments on selected VBVR tasks, VideoRLVR, and WorldArena report improved reasoning scores and training-step efficiency, with the largest gains on VBVR and smaller improvements on the other benchmarks.
Critical strengths
- The framework coherently addresses both goal completion and the validity of intermediate states. Outcome provides terminal-goal guidance, while Transition supervises representations of the next state.
- The improvements on the selected VBVR tasks are substantial and exceed the reported bidirectional SFT baseline.
- The implementation reuses existing computation and is supported by several component and configuration ablations.
Critical weaknesses
- The advance over closely related future-aware autoregressive methods remains insufficiently established. Section 2 discusses future-representation distillation and hierarchical generation, but the experiments primarily compare against Standard AR and component variants.
- The current experiments do not clearly isolate the specific benefit of future supervision in Transition. The mechanism is closely related to future-representation alignment in Video-Mirai, with the main distinction being that ProAR obtains its targets from the same trainable backbone within a single forward pass. This offers a potentially useful efficiency advantage. However, the component ablation does not distinguish future anticipation from general representation regularization.
- Outcome provides clear benefits, but the independent value of repeatedly updating the predicted goal remains unclear. Outcome alone raises the VBVR score to 0.786, accounting for much of the overall improvement. However, the current experiments do not adequately distinguish the effects of auxiliary terminal-frame supervision, goal conditioning, and repeated goal estimation. Prior work such as FramePack already explores generated future endpoints as constraints on subsequent generation, making this distinction consequential. The asymmetric-attention ablation does not isolate repeated goal updating, and its average improvement is small.
- The controlled AR comparisons on the core reasoning tasks are limited, and the baseline’s identity requires clarification. Constructing Standard AR with the same backbone and task data is reasonable. Nevertheless, the main text describes teacher-forced causal adaptation of Wan2.2, whereas parts of the appendix refer to the baseline as Causal-Forcing. It is unclear whether these names denote the same implementation and which training stages were used.
Questions for authors
- Do Standard AR and the Causal-Forcing baseline mentioned in the appendix refer to the same model? Please clarify the implementation source, initialization, and training stages. If the discrepancy is only terminological, please state this explicitly.
- How does ProAR’s internal target construction compare with a Video-Mirai-style target under the same backbone, task data, and comparable training budget?
- How does repeatedly predicting the terminal goal compare with predicting it once and keeping it fixed throughout generation? A comparison controlling goal conditioning and computational budget would help distinguish the benefit of having a goal from the benefit of updating it.
- What evidence shows that Transition improves the backbone’s predictive representations, rather than primarily training an effective auxiliary predictor?
5 comments
Response to Reviewer 2CAg [2/3]
>>> W3 Separating Goal Conditioning from Goal Updating
>>> A3 Thanks for this insightful concern! We agree that it is important to distinguish the benefit of repeatedly updating the goal from simply having a fixed goal. Following the reviewer’s helpful reference to FramePack [1], we add controlled comparisons on VBVR with three goal-conditioning strategies:
- Fixed predicted goal (first row):: Predicts the goal once from the first chunk, and reuses it for the rest of the video.
- Updated predicted goal (ProAR, second row):: Re-predicts the goal at every chunk to guide generation dynamically. Results are from the paper.
- Fixed ground-truth goal (third row): Use the actual final frame as a fixed goal throughout generation. (an upper bound, unavailable at test time)
| Model | Concentric Ring | Outline Match | Stable Sort | Star Match | Domino Chain | Ball Eater | Grid Shift | Pipe Puzzle | Slide Puzzle | Balancing Vessels | Mean |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed predicted goal | 0.758 | 0.865 | 0.763 | 0.850 | 0.794 | ||||||
| Updated predicted goal (ProAR) | 0.949 | 0.895 | 0.628 | 0.781 | 0.546 | 0.931 | |||||
| Fixed ground-truth goal | 0.931 | 0.868 | 0.875 | 0.889 | 0.774 | 0.736 | 0.824 | 0.792 | 0.890 | 0.867 | 0.845 |
Takeaways:
-
Dynamic updates beat a fixed prediction: Comparing Row 2 against Row 1, updating the goal at every chunk improves performance on 8 out of 10 tasks, raising the overall mean from 0.794 to 0.801 and bringing it closer to the oracle upper bound (0.845).
-
Why updating matters: A single initial prediction relies solely on the starting frame, which often lacks enough context to foresee the exact final state. By updating the goal as the video unfolds, ProAR continuously corrects its target using newly generated visual evidence. Only on tasks where the final state is already obvious from the very first frame (e.g., Pipe Puzzle) does a fixed initial prediction suffice.
These results validate our default design of updating the goal. We will also cite and discuss FramePack [1] as a related endpoint-conditioning method that uses generated future endpoints to guide subsequent generation.
>>> W4 Clarifying the Standard AR Baseline
>>> A4 Thanks for pointing this out! "Standard AR" refers to our teacher-forced causal adaptation of Wan2.2 on the same backbone and task data. The term “Causal-Forcing” in the appendix refers to this same implementation. We sincerely apologize for the typos and will use "Standard AR" consistently. To broaden the AR comparisons on the reasoning tasks, we will also include the additional baselines from W1.
Questions
Q1: Do Standard AR and the Causal-Forcing baseline mentioned in the appendix refer to the same model?
>>> A1 Thanks for the question. As clarified in W4, "Standard AR" and the “Causal-Forcing” baseline in the appendix refer to the same model: a teacher-forced autoregressive adaptation of Wan2.2, trained on the specific task data. The difference is purely terminological. We sincerely apologize for the typos and will correct the naming throughout the revised manuscript.
Q2: How does ProAR’s internal target construction compare with a Video-Mirai-style target under the same backbone, task data, and comparable training budget?
>>> A2 Thanks! Please see W1. We implemented a Video-Mirai-style future-representation alignment baseline using the same backbone, VBVR data, and training budget. ProAR achieves a substantially higher mean score (0.801 vs. 0.660) with only modest inference overhead.
Q3: How does repeatedly predicting the terminal goal compare with predicting it once and keeping it fixed throughout generation?
>>> A3 Thanks for the thoughtful question! Please see W3. Repeatedly updating the goal is more adaptive and broadly effective across tasks, while a fixed predicted goal suffices when the endpoint is easy to infer.
Response to Reviewer 2CAg [3/3]
Q4: What evidence shows that Transition improves the backbone’s predictive representations, rather than primarily training an effective auxiliary predictor?
>>> A4 Insightful question! To directly verify what the backbone itself learns, we drop the training predictor and train a lightweight MLP probe on its frozen features.
Experimental Setup. On the Stable Sort task from VBVR, we extract layer-15 hidden representations from the first autoregressive chunk of both Standard AR and ProAR. Using these frozen features, we train a probe to reconstruct future RGB frames at two horizons:
- H1: the final RGB frame of the next chunk;
- H2: the final RGB frame of the second next chunk.
| Method | H1 PSNR ↑ | H2 PSNR ↑ |
|---|---|---|
| Standard AR | 15.53 | 14.85 |
| ProAR | 16.41 | 15.70 |
(Higher PSNR indicates better reconstruction quality.)
With the predictor removed and the backbone frozen, ProAR still predicts better futures across both horizons. This confirms that transition module directly enriches the backbone's own representations with future information.
[1] Lvmin Zhang et al. "Frame Context Packing and Drift Prevention in Next-Frame-Prediction Video Diffusion Models." NeurIPS, 2025.
Response to Reviewer 2CAg [1/3]
We thank the reviewer for recognizing ProAR’s coherent design, substantial VBVR improvements, and efficient implementation with supporting ablations. We will address your concerns in the following response.
>>> W1Comparison with Future-Aware Autoregressive Methods>>> A1Thanks for raising this practical concern! We fully agree that comparisons with closely related future-aware autoregressive methods should be established. Beyond the basic baselines inTable 1, we add two related methods, Video-Mirai and HDR, both designed for future-aware autoregressive video generation. Both methods are trained with the same backbone, data, and training steps as ProAR.Results
ProAR achieves the strongest overall performance, with a mean score of 0.801. HDR is competitive on several individual tasks but requires higher inference cost, while Video-Mirai has a mean score close to Standard AR. Overall, ProAR offers the most effective and efficient solution, achieving the strongest performance with only modest inference overhead.
>>> W2Separating Future Anticipation from Representation Regularization>>> A2We truly appreciate this concern, and thank the reviewer for recognizing the efficiency benefit of constructing the targets within the same forward pass. To distinguish future anticipation from general representation regularization, we compare next-chunk and current-chunk clean-feature alignment using the same predictor and training budget.Next-chunk alignment achieves a mean score of 0.801, compared with 0.777 for current-chunk alignment, and performs better on 8 of 10 tasks. Since both settings use clean-feature alignment, this gap shows that future anticipation provides a stronger benefit than current-representation regularization alone.