acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Adaptation or Influence? Auditing Self-Updating Personalized Agents

Abstract

Self-updating personalized agents learn from feedback generated through their own interactions with users. Improved feedback may therefore arise from Adaptation, where the agent better learns a user’s existing preferences, or from Influence, where the agent’s previous actions change those preferences over time. Distinguishing Adaptation from Influence is difficult because both can produce better observed feedback. We study how to separate these effects in self-updating personalization loops. We introduce a controlled preference check that queries a preference dimension on a schedule fixed independently of the current personalized action. We further decompose action-caused preference change into a fixed-sequence effect along an already realized action sequence, a complete-loop effect when the adaptive interaction is rerun, and their difference, the additional-loop effect, which measures the additional change observed when subsequent feedback, profile updates, and actions are allowed to adapt. Across three simulated user-response mechanisms, two personalization systems, and five influence levels, ordinary feedback tracks hidden preference change poorly, with a macro Spearman correlation of . In contrast, the controlled check achieves a macro correlation of . However, simply using the preset influence strength also achieves , meaning that higher influence settings already tend to produce more hidden preference change. We therefore consider a harder comparison between the two systems at the same influence level. Here, the controlled check reaches balanced accuracy in identifying the system with less hidden preference change, compared with for always selecting the fixed-profile system. We also test whether self-updating creates additional Influence beyond the effects of the actions already taken. In the prespecified delayed-response setting, this additional change is only , below our threshold for practically meaningful amplification. These results show that, in our controlled simulation, scheduled preference queries can help distinguish Influence from Adaptation when ordinary feedback is ambiguous, while behavioral divergence does not necessarily imply substantial recursive amplification. Our findings establish a controlled synthetic benchmark and auditing framework, rather than a calibrated measure of real-user harm or welfare.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
personalized agents, self-updating, preference influence

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_1zPSOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies whether improved feedback in self-updating personalized agents reflects adaptation to existing preferences or influence that changes those preferences. It introduces a scheduled controlled preference check and decomposes influence into fixed-sequence, complete-loop, and additional-loop effects. Experiments using MovieLens-grounded simulated users show that the controlled check tracks hidden preference change more reliably than ordinary feedback, while the prespecified setting provides no evidence of practically meaningful additional-loop amplification.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper addresses a practically relevant evaluation problem, i.e., improved feedback does not necessarily indicate better adaptation when a personalized system can also change user preferences.

  2. The distinction between fixed-sequence and complete-loop effects provides a useful diagnostic perspective. In particular, the experiments show that divergent action trajectories need not imply substantial additional preference change.

  3. The empirical reporting is transparent. The authors include matched controls, a harder same-dose comparison, and sensitivity analyses, while explicitly acknowledging the limitations of perfect cross-dose correlations and unsuccessful system-selection results.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The controlled response is a nearly direct, low-noise proxy for latent preferences, while the hidden outcome also measures preference displacement. Since displacement alone already achieves perfect cross-dose ranking, the added value of the proposed score and its robustness under less favorable observations remain unclear.
  2. The fixed profile starts from the true initial preferences, leaving limited room for beneficial adaptation. Although the same-dose balanced accuracy is encouraging, accuracy and regret improvements over always choosing the fixed system remain inconclusive. Initial profile error and action-independent preference drift would provide stronger validation.
  3. Key simulation details remain underspecified, including the transition equations, endorsement rule, penalty function, matching procedure, and action-selection policy. The small additional-loop effect also warrants sensitivity analysis across reference trajectories and interaction horizons.
  4. The novelty relative to existing preference-shift auditing methods needs clarification. A held-out comparison with unweighted preference displacement would help separate the benefits of scheduled measurement from those of the proposed scoring design.
Questions for authors
  1. How does the full controlled-check score compare with unweighted response displacement in the held-out same-dose analysis, particularly in balanced accuracy and regret? The existing component analysis mainly establishes cross-dose ordering.
  2. Can the method distinguish action-caused influence from action-independent preference drift when the initial profile is inaccurate? This would directly test whether the audit separates influence from beneficial adaptation.
Reviewer_xRMSOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes to study and separate the effects of Adaptation and Influence in personalized, self-updating agents. Because ordinary feedback in recommender systems do not disentangle 1) the recommender system adapting to the user’s preferences (adaptation), and 2) the recommender system influencing the user’s preferences to like the recommended content more (influence), the authors propose a controlled preference check at a fixed schedule in order to directly measure the user’s preference shifts. The authors measure the efficacy of the aforementioned controlled preference check in settings with both varying and fixed influence levels. The paper then goes on to explore the question of whether updating user profiles and subsequent recommendations in a loop leads to a greater shift in user preferences as compared to a fixed recommendation sequence. Overall, the authors find that 1) the controlled preference check outperforms ordinary feedback at ranking hidden preference change, and 2) the additional effect on user preferences of allowing the recommendation systems to update user profiles and subsequent recommendations is insignificant.

Critical strengths

The paper is relatively timely and well-motivated given the recent rise in personalized agent systems.

Critical weaknesses

Framing of contribution.

One of the papers stated contributions is presenting the distinction between Adaptation and Influence in personalized agents. The title, abstract, introduction, and first figure present these two as equally likely hypotheses for explaining shifts in user feedback. However, the rest of the paper devotes itself to studying Influence—how to audit for shifts in preferences, how to measure the additional influence of agents that update a user profile—and neglects Adaptation almost entirely. Indeed, Appendix I states that “the fixed profile equals the true initial simulated preference state”, which means that there is no need for the agent to adapt/update its user profile (updating/adapting the user profile may actually make recommender worse). The experiments in this paper don’t appear to directly study a setting where agents actually need to adapt to / learn unknown user preferences.

In contrast, prior work in this area (e.g., Carroll et al., 2022) does attempt to learn and update a model of user preferences. Broadly, this paper could do a better job at contextualizing its contributions within the space of prior work. For example, Carroll et al., 2022 also use counterfactuals to assess impacts of certain recommender systems, but instead compare against other recommender policies rather than a no-influence world (this paper). This and other distinctions with prior work in the area should be more explicitly spelled-out. It would perhaps also be valuable to compare the differences between the controlled preference check introduced by this paper and Carroll’s learned-preference estimator, specifically the assumptions made about the user in each setting.

It would also be helpful for the authors to define what they mean by “agent” (as this term is increasingly overloaded today) and compare the differences between personalized, self-updating recommender agents and non-agentic recommender systems.

Choices in formulation.

Certain choices the paper makes in terms of formulating/defining the metrics and measurements seem to lack justification. For example, when defining the influence as measured by the controlled preference check Δjanchor^\hat{\Delta_j^{anchor}}, it’s not clear to me why we are subtracting the pre-warmup measurement. Evaluating AtA_t after warmup makes sense (we’re giving the recommender a chance to update the user profile), but it’s less clear why we would want to subtract the preference change during the warmup phase. This may actually discard information: one system that changes a user’s preferences more during warmup and less afterward would be ranked lower in terms of Influence than a system that does the opposite, even when they both have the same amount of total user preference displacement. This design choice does not appear to be justified anywhere in the paper. It would perhaps be valuable to also compare against just using Δjanchor^=Aj,1post−Aj,0post\hat{\Delta_j^{anchor}} = A_{j, 1}^{post} - A_{j, 0}^{post} to justify this design decision.

The ‘ordinary feedback’ baseline in Section 5.2 and Figures 3 and 4 is a bit of a strawman. Both the controlled preference check and the hidden ground truth Δloop\Delta_{loop} primarily measure the absolute difference in user preferences, whereas the ordinary feedback baseline measures the signed difference in user ratings, which makes this an unfair comparison. The use of a signed difference seems to be the main factor responsible for the poor performance of ‘ordinary feedback’ in the ‘Satiation’ user response conditions where the ranking is reversed (Figure 3, bottom 2 rows; Figure 4, left panel). Conversely, I’d be interested to see how well absolute difference in user ratings tracks ground truth influence. I would be more convinced by the results if they demonstrated that the controlled preference check outperforms an absolute feedback change baseline rather than a signed difference one. A positive result would help disentangle whether the advantage of the controlled preference check comes from measuring preferences directly or just using an absolute value.

Questions for authors

“Under satiation, repeated exposure reduces preference for the exposed genre, so observed feedback can move in the opposite direction from underlying preference change.” If we instead assessed the absolute change in feedback and compared that with the underlying preference change, would that resolve this reversal issue?

The result about how the user response type amplifies or attenuates the self-updating effect (Appendix Figure 9) is quite interesting. Would this difference be clearer if the user profile was not initialized to be the same as the underlying user preferences? In general, I feel that exploring this nuanced effect would be interesting.

Reviewer_pppmOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies in self-updating personalized agents, how to distinguish whether the agent is learning the user’s existing preferences or that they are changing those preferences over time. The proposed solution is controlled preference checks.

Critical strengths

The paper studies a valuable problem of users being influenced by the interactions with the personalized agent.

Critical weaknesses

The paper appears entirely AI written. The abstract does not make sense and contains unnecessary statistical testing. The appendix contains file paths that exposes the username of the authors (wlyu) that breaks anonymity.

Regardless of the AI slop and bad presentation, the paper’s main result holds by construction. The “controlled preference check” (Eq. 11, App. C) reads the simulator’s hidden preference variable almost directly, with noise of standard deviation 0.0003, and the ground truth it is scored against (Eq. 13) is the change in that same variable, so the reported Spearman ρ = 1.0 (Table 1A) only shows that the variable correlates with itself. The influence dial set by the authors also reaches 1.0, and in the harder same-dose comparison the check is barely more accurate than always picking the fixed system (81.25% vs. 80.83%, Table 1B).

Questions for authors

None

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.