- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The authors builds a system for a quadruped with an arm to follow and grab a target initialized by a text prompt, using RGB, thermal, and 4D radar. Radar and thermal are projected onto the RGB image so each pixel carries depth, Doppler velocity, and heat in addition to color. On top of this they run an open-vocabulary detector and a video segmentation tracker, and they check each tracking update against a constant-velocity prediction using position, Doppler, and thermal residuals. When the check fails, they re-detect the target and prefer candidates near the predicted position. A confidence threshold decides when the robot keeps approaching and when it attempts the grasp. All experiments are on the real robot with four toy targets, indoor/outdoor and day/night. The authors report 91.3% capture success against 76.7% for the best baseline, and better recovery after occlusion.
Critical strengths
This work addresses a practical problem: following and grabbing a specific object with a legged robot when the camera image is poor, e.g. at night, outdoors, or under heavy occlusion. The authors test the whole pipeline on a real robot, from sensing to grasping, and do not stop at perception benchmarks.
Critical weaknesses
- My major concern is the reliability of the results. The baseline numbers in Table 7 look implausible, and the main claims rest on them. Each cell has only 30 trials, yet across all 16 cells, every gap from KineMan-RL to BirdieRL and from BirdieRL to DQ-Net is exactly +1 or +2. That is 32 gaps with no ties and no reversals. In outdoor night, every gap is +2. Some columns are also repeated across conditions. For example, indoor-night Mouse and outdoor-night Rabbit are both 14/16/18/26. The supplement does not run the baselines, and its per-trial table cannot be matched to Table 7. It is also unclear how DQ-Net, which was evaluated only in simulation on a B1 + Z1, was deployed on a real Go2 + PiPER.
- The method has limited novelty. Radar and thermal projection onto the image, TSDF mapping, constant-velocity gating with Doppler, and re-detection near the predicted position are all standard, mostly from radar-based tracking in autonomous driving.
Questions for authors
- The results from table 7 look implausible. Please provide raw per-episode logs for all methods in Table 7, with episode ID, target, condition, layout, timestamp, and outcome. How do you explain why every gap between neighboring baselines is exactly +1 or +2, and why some columns repeat across conditions?
- How was each baseline adapted to the Go2 + PiPER? Please give the inputs used, whether it was retrained and how, and how sim-to-real was handled. DQ-Net was only evaluated in simulation on a different robot.
- The supplementary videos show a tabletop block-sorting arm, a red ball, and a robot walking in a corridor. It seems not relevant to robot tracking or chasing a target.
If authors can address point 1 and 2, I would consider raising my rating.