- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes READ-ECG, which models paper ECG printout digitisation as a structured visual sequence regression task. Using lead-time queries and an attention-based decoder, the method directly reconstructs multi-lead continuous waveforms from an entire ECG page, and these reconstructed signals can be processed by existing downstream ECG analysis models without retraining.
Core Claim: By exploiting the lead and temporal structure of ECGs, high-fidelity, reusable digital waveforms can be directly reconstructed from full-page images, bypassing traditional segmentation-based digitisation pipelines.
Critical strengths
-
Unified full-page multi-lead decoding: Unlike pipelines that segment individual leads separately, READ-ECG encodes lead identity and temporal position into target queries to reconstruct multi-lead signals in a unified framework. This is a reasonable use of ECG layout structure and offers a clean implementation for full-page sequence regression.
-
Verification of downstream signal reusability: The authors evaluate parameter-invariant downstream models on both original visible waveforms and reconstructed waveforms, showing that prediction performance barely drops. This is more meaningful than reporting reconstruction error alone, as it confirms that the digitisation preserves information utilized by existing analysis tools.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited conceptual novelty relative to prior work: Directly regressing waveform points from ECG images has been explored (e.g., SLPM), and the Image Signal Analysis pipeline is established. READ-ECG’s main addition is combining lead-time queries with full-page joint decoding. However, the paper does not show what new modeling principles this brings beyond existing image-to-sequence formulations. The method feels more like an effective engineering assembly of known techniques than a conceptual breakthrough.
-
Lack of ablation isolating the core structured queries: Current ablations primarily examine patch size and QKNorm, without isolating the specific impact of the lead-time queries against standard sequence decoders. Thus, it is unclear whether the strong performance comes specifically from the ECG-informed query design or simply from general full-page joint regression and model capacity. In addition, evaluating different digitisation baselines under differing clean-image rendering protocols limits fair algorithmic attribution.
Questions for authors
- Compared to a standard image-to-sequence decoder using the same vision backbone and training data, what specific and irreplaceable advantage do the lead-time structured queries provide?
- Which ECG-specific structural priors are strictly necessary for the method’s performance? Can you provide evidence separating the contribution of structured query modeling from general joint sequence regression?
2 comments
Good luck!
Thank you for the additional experiments. The ablation shows that structured queries improve reconstruction quality with fewer parameters. The comparisons using the same images also address my concern about the fairness of the evaluation. My remaining concern is about novelty, as the paper still does not clearly show what is new beyond existing methods. However, I think the new results are sufficient, and I will raise my rating from 2 to 3. Please include these experiments in the revised paper. Good luck!
Response to rLTv
Thank you for highlighting full-page decoding and the test of waveform reuse.
W1. Contribution relative to prior work
SLPM already regresses waveform points from individual lead crops and identifies joint full-page reconstruction as future work. Our contribution is to decode all visible leads jointly from the full printout. Each query represents a particular lead and time interval. Cross-attention lets it read the trace from the image, while self-attention lets it draw on other intervals and leads. The decoder returns a waveform and a sample-by-sample uncertainty estimate for each visible lead. SLPM
A 2024 PhysioNet Challenge entry already used digitised waveforms for classification. We ask how much performance an existing signal analyser retains when the original waveform is replaced by a reconstruction. Across three PTB-XL task families, the same residual 1D CNN scored 0.9269 mean AUROC on original visible waveforms and 0.9270 on READ-ECG outputs. It could therefore be reused on these printouts without retraining. 2024 Challenge entry
W2a, Q1–Q2. What the lead and time priors contribute
A sequence of amplitudes is usable as a multilead ECG only if each value has a lead, a time, and a voltage scale. Here, the known layout, visible lead durations, paper speed, and gain supply that mapping. Both decoders use it, so the ablation isolates how the queries represent those positions. Whether the decoder could learn the mapping from the image is a separate question.
Once each output has a lead and time, independently learned queries also reconstruct well. Factorising the queries lets the decoder reuse a lead embedding across times and a time embedding across leads. With the backbone, decoder, and training protocol held fixed, that sharing improved page SNR by 0.41 dB with 0.48M fewer trainable query parameters. The gain over frozen random queries was 1.41 dB.
We also checked how quickly the two designs learned. In one full-data fit per design, structured queries had lower normalised validation MAE (×100) than independently learned queries at epoch one (10.02 vs 18.05) and epoch ten (2.54 vs 2.77). The ordering briefly reversed at epoch two. This suggests a possible benefit with shorter training and motivates testing whether it also holds with fewer training ECGs or across different print layouts.
W2b. Same-image baselines
We agree that comparing results across renderers leaves the effect of the input style unresolved. We therefore ran released Krones M3 and Ahus Open-ECG-Digitizer on the same 2,194 clean PTB-XL pages used for READ-ECG. On 891 held-out Kaggle captures, we gave all three systems the same automatically perspective-corrected images. Ahus then applied its own preprocessing. READ-ECG used its Kaggle-adapted checkpoint, and M3 and Ahus used their released weights. Krones et al. · Ahus
READ-ECG leads on both sets of identical images, whether we score the waveforms as predicted (strict SNR) or allow a time shift of up to 0.2 s in either direction and a constant voltage offset per lead (aligned SNR). On Kaggle, alignment raises READ-ECG’s score by just 0.06 dB, compared with 5.97 dB for M3 and 3.73 dB for Ahus. We will distinguish these matched comparisons from Demolder’s and SLPM’s results on their own renderings.