- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces Skill2Env, a framework that synthesizes executable agent-training tasks and environments from skills using capability-oriented difficulty patterns and task blueprints. It further uses solver feedback to progressively harden the tasks. The pipeline produces 2,963 tasks, and fine-tuning Qwen3.6-35B-A3B on 1.5K high-scoring teacher trajectories collected from these environments improves performance across seven benchmarks.
Critical strengths
-
The framework provides a practical way to turn general skills into concrete training environments. It explicitly identifies 5 capability demands and designs 100 difficulty patterns.
-
Experimental results show that Skill2Env achieves substantial improvements over seven benchmarks. Improvements also hold across four Terminal-Bench harnesses.
Critical weaknesses
-
The contribution of each capability demand is unclear. You should include an ablation study showing whether training on tasks designed for a particular capability actually improves that capability and how each capability demand contributes to the overall gains. Do different benchmarks focus on different capabilities?
-
The five capability categories need clearer support. For example, you could explain which models struggle with each capability, on which tasks or benchmarks, and how many execution traces were analyzed. A chart summarizing this information would be helpful.
Questions for authors
- Was SFT performed in thinking mode or non-thinking mode? Specifically, did the training data include the teacher model’s reasoning traces?
4 comments
Response (Part 2/2): Capability-Conditioned Training Effects and SFT Setup (W1, Q1)
3. Capability challenges across benchmarks.
Agent tasks often require multiple capabilities, and different benchmarks emphasize different demands. We annotated 1,772 evaluation tasks across seven benchmarks, allowing multiple capability labels per task.
Table: Task-Level Distribution of Capability Challenges Across Seven Benchmarks.
| Benchmark | Tasks | E | P | S | L | R |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Terminal-Bench 2.1 | 89 | 76 | 61 | 1 | 26 | 13 |
| SWE-bench Multilingual | 300 | 212 | 26 | 0 | 3 | 264 |
| SkillsBench | 87 | 76 | 63 | 77 | 32 | 12 |
| ClawEval | 199 | 193 | 67 | 4 | 23 | 5 |
| τ³-Banking | 97 | 94 | 66 | 76 | 57 | 34 |
| AutomationBench | 600 | 582 | 425 | 309 | 414 | 0 |
| VitaBench | 400 | 272 | 355 | 0 | 232 | 1 |
| Total | 1,772 | 1,505 | 1,063 | 467 | 787 | 329 |
E: Environment Understanding; P: Planning; S: Skill Usage; L: Long-Horizon Consistency; R: Error Recovery.
For example, SkillsBench emphasizes Skill Usage (77/87 tasks), VitaBench and AutomationBench heavily involve Planning (355/400 and 425/600) and Long-Horizon Consistency (232/400 and 414/600), while SWE-bench Multilingual emphasizes Error Recovery (264/300).
4. Capability-stratified downstream evaluation.
We agree that it is important to examine whether capability-oriented training improves the corresponding agent abilities.
However, the five demands often co-occur within a task, making a simple leave-one-capability-out ablation difficult to interpret. Removing Planning-related tasks, for example, would also remove training signals for Environment Understanding and Long-Horizon Consistency. It would therefore not isolate Planning's contribution.
To provide more fine-grained evidence, we additionally analyze performance before and after SFT across the five capability demands on all seven benchmarks. Specifically, we group evaluation tasks by their capability demands and compare the number of success tasks before and after training.
Table: Capability-level performance before and after SFT across seven benchmarks.
| Capability Demand | Tasks | Success Rate Before SFT | Success Rate After SFT | Gain (pp) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Environment Understanding | 1,505 | 601/1,505 (39.93%) | 715/1,505 (47.51%) | +7.57 |
| Planning | 1,063 | 400/1,063 (37.63%) | 486/1,063 (45.72%) | +8.09 |
| Skill Usage | 467 | 75/467 (16.06%) | 113/467 (24.20%) | +8.14 |
| Long-Horizon Consistency | 787 | 243/787 (30.88%) | 309/787 (39.26%) | +8.39 |
| Error Recovery | 329 | 189/329 (57.45%) | 222/329 (67.48%) | +10.03 |
Note: A task is counted as successful if at least one evaluated rollout achieves full success; otherwise, it is counted as unsuccessful. Each task is counted only once, and partial credit does not count as success. Tasks may belong to multiple capability categories.
These results provide a capability-level view of training effectiveness. Aggregated across the seven benchmarks, task-level success rates improve for all five capability-demanding subsets.
5. Clarification on SFT training mode.
Finally, regarding the SFT setup, we conducted training in thinking mode, and the training data included the teacher model's reasoning traces.
We thank the reviewer again for the helpful suggestions.
Thank you for your response and additional experiments. All of my concerns have been addressed.
Thank You for Your Feedback
Thank you for your positive feedback and for confirming that your concerns have been addressed. We sincerely appreciate your thoughtful review and constructive suggestions.
Response (Part 1/2): Empirical Evidence for the Five Capability Demands (W2)
Thank you for recognizing the practical value of Skill2Env and its consistent improvements across benchmarks. We appreciate your suggestions on better supporting the five capability demands and clarifying their contributions to agent training. We address these concerns in two parts.
1. Motivation: From agent execution to shared capability demands.
Our framework adopts a capability-demand-oriented perspective. As described in Section 4.2, we identify five general capability demands based on the requirements of agent execution: environment understanding, planning, skill usage, long-horizon consistency, and error recovery. To operationalize these demands in task synthesis process, we introduce reusable difficulty patterns. Importantly, capability demands describe what agents need to be capable of, while difficulty patterns specify how these capabilities are challenged in executable tasks.
2. Empirical evidence from model execution failures. In our failure analysis process, we analyzed 500 failure trajectories from five agent models. We identified 848 failure reasons and categorized them into the five capability demands. A single trajectory may involve multiple failure reasons.
Table: Distribution of capability-related failure reasons across 500 trajectories.
E: Environment Understanding; P: Planning; S: Skill Usage; L: Long-Horizon Consistency; R: Error Recovery.
The analysis identifies failures associated with five capability demands across models. Representative execution traces further illustrate how these capability demands manifest in concrete failures. For example, in AutomationBench, Qwen3.6-35B-A3B misidentifies spreadsheet resources and uses unverified contacts (Environment Understanding). In VitaBench, Gemini-3.1 Pro incorrectly reschedules an unaffected Saturday dinner when modifying a separate appointment (Long-Horizon Consistency). In τ³-Banking, GPT-5.4 closes a credit-card account without first checking for pending disputes, skipping a required prerequisite (Planning). These cases illustrate distinct, observable failure mechanisms underlying the capability demands.