- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes ReLoF, which estimates sample-level reliability through entropy-based confidence and leave-one-out view consistency, and uses the reliability as the exponent of LogOP for multi-view fusion. In addition, a MaxLog regularization is introduced to alleviate the soft veto induced by erroneously high-confidence views. Experiments cover both normal and conflict scenarios on seven datasets.
Critical strengths
- The method is concise and interpretable, connecting view reliability, fusion geometry, and confidence control in an easy-to-implement framework.
- The AOP–LogOP comparison is carefully designed, with results reported on seven datasets over ten random seeds.
Critical weaknesses
- The protocol may leaks test information: without a validation set, the model is evaluated on the test set every 10 epochs with the best test accuracy retained, and normalization precedes the data split; given gains as small as 0.07–0.30 percentage points, this may alter the main conclusions.
- The core reliability estimator lacks ablations against uniform-weighting, entropy-only, and consistency-only variants.
- Only one view is replaced while most views remain clean, matching its prior assumption, so robustness under general conflicts is unproven.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors use an independent validation set for model selection, normalize using training-set statistics only, and re-report all results?
- Could comparisons with uniform-weighting, confidence-only, consistency-only, and other confidence regularization methods be added?
- How do ReLoF's performance and reliability weights change as the number of conflicting views grows from one to a majority?