acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Topological Necessities: Mechanism-Invariant Strategic Subgoals for Cross-Embodiment Goal-Conditioned Control

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Long-horizon goal-conditioned reinforcement learning delegates control to a high-level module that proposes subgoals, but existing subgoals are implicit byproducts of value functions or latent actions, tied to the executor that produced them. We study a route-conditioned order of unavoidable stages that every successful executor must traverse, recoverable from offline trajectories and belonging to none of them. Its defining properties are topological: an unskippable stage is a separating set that every admissible path must cross, and a loop in free space forces a route choice. We read the two by homology in dimensions and over a transport-weighted carrier built from successful trajectories, yielding an enumerable gate set with shell-level certificates; the certified gates are what we call topological necessities. Certified gates enter the decision loop as a recursive topological gate hierarchy. Under a fixed, isomorphic free space, the object survives executor replacement: gates frozen on PointMaze data transfer without retraining to Ant and Humanoid, attaining the highest Humanoid aggregate under a unified interface (), with over a map-privileged reference on the multi-route task (); the planner saturates PointMaze () and matches or exceeds the strongest protocol-matched baselines on AntMaze (giant ), and exceeds HIQL on Kitchen (/).

Primary area:
reinforcement learning
Keywords:
goal-conditioned reinforcement learning, subgoal discovery, topology, hierarchical reinforcement learning, offline reinforcement learning, cross-embodiment transfer

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_D8xEOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes a topology-based subgoal discovery method for offline goal-conditioned RL. The authors construct a graph from successful trajectories, learn a geometric representation of the state space, and use persistent homology to identify bottleneck regions that successful trajectories must pass through. These necks are then organized into a hierarchical planning structure and converted into waypoints for low-level policies.

Critical strengths

The authors propose a complete pipeline for neck discovery, including graph construction, geometric representation learning, and topology-based bottleneck detection. The resulting necks can be used to generate a sequence of waypoints, which provides a natural way to decompose long-horizon goal-conditioned tasks into simpler subtasks.

Critical weaknesses
  • The proposed pipeline still relies heavily on human-designed task-specific choices. For example, the authors use different state representations and distance measures for AntMaze and Kitchen, with manually specified choices about which state dimensions are relevant. The entire pipeline is also quite complicated, making it difficult to imagine applying it automatically to arbitrary real-world goal-conditioned tasks without substantial human effort. I think this is a particularly important issue because waypoint discovery can always benefit from additional human priors. In the extreme case, since these benchmarks have fixed environments and relatively simple tasks, one could even manually specify a set of waypoints to guide the policy. It is therefore unclear how much of the performance comes from the proposed discovery method itself, rather than the task-specific design choices.

  • The theoretical analysis is extensive, but its connection to the actual method is not sufficiently clear. The paper devotes roughly 25 pages to theorems and proofs, yet I find it difficult to understand why all these theoretical results are necessary for the proposed approach. I would like the authors to explain more clearly what problem each theorem addresses, which claim in the main paper it supports, and what it tells us about the practical method.

  • The evaluation is limited to relatively simple and well-established benchmarks. AntMaze and FrankaKitchen have been widely used since D4RL (2020), and HIQL, one of the main baselines, was published in 2023. Although the paper also uses the more recent OGBench (2025), the evaluated tasks are still mostly maze navigation and simulated manipulation in fixed environments. Given the paper's broader claims about goal-conditioned control and cross-embodiment transfer, I would like to see evaluations on more challenging and realistic tasks, together with comparisons against stronger recent methods.

Questions for authors

Please see Weaknesses.

Reviewer_sEoKOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes a topology-based framework for discovering mechanism-invariant strategic subgoals from offline trajectories in long-horizon goal-conditioned reinforcement learning. By combining graph-based representations with persistent homology, the method identifies critical bottlenecks and constructs a hierarchical subgoal structure with theoretical guarantees under certain assumptions.

Critical strengths

The paper investigates an interesting perspective on hierarchical goal-conditioned reinforcement learning by separating task-level strategic subgoals from executor-specific policies. Defining subgoals through the underlying task topology provides a potentially useful direction for cross-embodiment transfer.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The motivation for automatically discovering subgoals is not sufficiently convincing. In many of the evaluated environments, particularly the maze navigation tasks, the critical bottlenecks and intermediate goals appear relatively obvious from the environment structure. It is unclear why such subgoals need to be learned through a relatively complex topological framework rather than identified using simpler geometric or graph-based planning methods.

  2. Although the paper provides extensive theoretical analysis, several guarantees appear to rely on strong assumptions or require further justification. In particular, the must-pass certificate in Theorem T3 relies on geometric regularity and route-conditioned connectivity assumptions, and it is unclear whether detecting a persistent valley alone is sufficient to establish a meaningful common bottleneck region. Moreover, the finite-step convergence argument in Theorem T5 does not explicitly account for the stochastic fluctuation term when specifying the required planning horizon. Finally, some asymptotic conditions, such as the neighborhood scaling required by Theorem T2, are not satisfied by the experimental configurations. These issues raise concerns about the extent to which the theoretical guarantees support the practical implementation.

Questions for authors
  1. In many of the evaluated maze environments, the critical bottlenecks and intermediate subgoals appear relatively straightforward to identify from the environment geometry. Could the authors clarify under what circumstances the proposed topological subgoal discovery is necessary, and what advantages it offers over simpler geometric or graph-based methods?

  2. The cross-embodiment experiments primarily consider different robots operating in the same maze geometry. How would the proposed method handle cases where different embodiments have different feasible configuration spaces due to their morphology, physical dimensions, or dynamic constraints? Would the identified topological gates remain valid in such settings?

Reviewer_EhkkOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies how to discover useful intermediate goals from offline trajectories and reuse them across different robots. The method identifies bottleneck regions along successful trajectories and uses them as subgoals to guide the robot toward its destination. It also distinguishes alternative trajectories around obstacles and adds more intermediate subgoals when needed. The paper evaluates the method on maze navigation and Kitchen tasks, and reports that subgoals discovered from PointMaze data can be reused on Ant and Humanoid.

Critical strengths
  • Learning subgoals that can be reused across different robots is an interesting and useful direction.

  • The transfer comparison uses the same controller and interface across methods, helping isolate the benefit of the discovered subgoals.

  • The paper includes extensive ablations on layouts, controllers, and recovery.

Critical weaknesses
  • The bottleneck states in Definition 1 are ambiguous. Do the bottlenecks depend on a specific distance metric? How do we define bottlenecks beyond navigation tasks?

  • Adding more subgoals improves performance, but the experiments do not establish whether identifying bottlenecks is better than learning a parametric hierarchical policy, e.g., HIQL, or simply performing open-loop planning such as MPC.

  • The evaluation is limited to navigation tasks, and it is not obvious how the proposed method performs on manipulation tasks.

Questions for authors
  • Do the bottlenecks depend on a specific distance metric? How do we define bottlenecks beyond navigation tasks?

  • How does the method perform when compared to methods that learn a parametric hierarchical policy or perform open-loop control?

  • How does the proposed method perform beyond navigation tasks?

  • Looking at the pseudocode in Algorithm 1, the method requires constructing a graph and running Dijkstra. Do these mechanisms introduce expensive computational overhead?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.