acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

RolloutFaith: Auditing Persistent Internal Interventions in Visual World Model

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Interpretability methods such as probes, activation patches and learned editors are designed to reveal or modify a model's current computation. World models pose a harder requirement: because their predictions become inputs to later predictions, a useful internal correction must survive after editing stops. We therefore propose **RolloutFaith**, a framework that measures semantic improvement both in the prediction produced at intervention time and over later autonomous predictions under fixed events, actions, noise, and information budgets. We evaluate ten fitted editors on three world models across Crafter, Cartpole, and CoinRun. We also use Reference Activation Patching, which replaces a model activation with the paired activation computed from the real observation, to measure the correction available at the chosen interface. This reference intervention improves later predictions in all nine model and task combinations and outperforms the best fitted editor in eight, yet its sustained gain decreases with horizon in five of nine combinations. Current fitted editors recover only limited and inconsistent long term effects. By restoring individual state components to their untouched values, we find that persistent effects travel through the newest generated frame in DIAMOND, recurrent memory in DreamerV3, and both in STORM. These findings suggest that training should reward future consequences. To test this hypothesis, we propose *Delayed LoReFT*, which optimizes the same low rank intervention through four frozen future transitions and improves sustained intervention effects to some extent.

Primary area:
interpretability and explainable AI
Keywords:
Interpretability, World Model

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_9vWVOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper seeks to provide an explainability method for world models. As typical explainability methods probe model parameters to examine the output, and world models use their predictions as input for further computation, this problem is not trivial. It is proposed to evaluate the model at the current step and future steps, which is tested on multiple editors and 3 models on 3 benchmarks. This analysis shows that the models should be rewarded more for future consequences, resulting in the proposition of the temporal supervision method delayed loreft, which shows improvement in some tasks.

Critical strengths
  • Explainability is an important problem, and extending it to world models is both important and relevant, specifically due to the difficulties in trivially transferring traditional explainability methods.
  • The experiments appear extensive and thorough
Critical weaknesses
  • The related work is very short, I would expect at least some minor discussion on world models, or at least a more detailed analysis of previous world model interpretability work. The limitations of the prior work are not defined in a way that shows the need for this method.
  • The figures for this paper are unfocused and unclear. There is no figure for either RolloutFaith or Delayed Loreft, and instead there is an unclear teaser figure and a figure for the dataset composition, which appears to be composed from existing datasets. The captions can also be significantly improved with direct explanations instead of requiring the reader to find where it is mentioned in the text.
  • Overall it seems that the paper can be framed better, starting with a more structured background on world models, an analysis of existing interpretability metrics with clear examples of failure cases, and finally explaining the framework and results.
  • The proposed improvements do now show improvement over all tasks
Questions for authors
  • Can you provide some clear examples of where previous interpretability methods fail, and RolloutFaith succeeds.
  • Can you provide a framework/method diagram for both RolloutFaith and Loreft
Reviewer_jLRSOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies whether a one-time intervention in a world model’s internal representations can improve its subsequent predictions after editing stops. The authors introduce RolloutFaith to evaluate both immediate and sustained gains across three world models and three tasks. They compare reference activation patching with learned editors and use component restoration to examine how intervention effects propagate through the models. They also propose Delayed LoReFT, which trains an editor using losses on future predictions. The results show that improving the current prediction does not necessarily lead to lasting benefits, and that future-step supervision helps in some settings but remains inconsistent across tasks.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper addresses a meaningful evaluation problem. Separating immediate semantic gain from sustained gain helps assess whether an intervention remains useful after editing stops. This distinction is particularly relevant to world models, where generated states influence subsequent predictions.

  2. The evaluation protocol is carefully controlled. The experiments cover three world models and three tasks, with edited and unedited rollouts sharing events, actions, and prediction noise. Source-level aggregation and bootstrap confidence intervals also account for the dependence between evaluations from the same episode or level.

  3. The diagnostic analyses provide useful insights beyond overall performance. Norm-matched comparisons help distinguish limitations in correction magnitude and direction. Component-restoration experiments further examine which state components carry intervention effects into later predictions, revealing different patterns across the evaluated architectures.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Is the research question itself first introduced in this paper? I am curious about the distinction from Liu and Chen (2026), which already studies a single hidden-state intervention followed by a 12-step autonomous rollout. Section 2.2 seems to overlook this overlap when describing previous work. If the question has already been explored, the authors should state more clearly what this paper adds, beyond evaluating more models and tasks.

  2. The small training and validation sets make the generalization results difficult to interpret. It is unclear how much of the observed failure comes from the editing methods and how much comes from limited data or validation-based selection. Larger training sets and repeated data splits would help. Beyond the single-intervention setting, I would also be interested in whether several corrections along one rollout can better address accumulated errors, or whether the edits themselves introduce further errors. Comparing one larger correction with several smaller ones, as well as fixed versus error-triggered correction schedules, under matched observation and edit budgets would make the analysis more informative.

  3. Are the improvements from Delayed LoReFT consistent and substantial across settings? The improvement on DIAMOND–Cartpole is clear, but several other gains are small, and some tasks become worse. For example, SSG@8 on STORM–CoinRun falls from +0.08 to −1.06 percentage points. I would suggest testing different training horizons and a combination of immediate and future losses, which could clarify whether the current failures arise from sacrificing the edited frame for later predictions.

Questions for authors

My questions are outlined in the Critical Weaknesses section. I would appreciate clarification on the distinction from prior work, how repeated interventions might affect accumulated rollout errors, and how consistent the benefits of Delayed LoReFT are across settings. If the authors can address most of my concerns, I would be open to raising my score.

Reviewer_dcUcOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposed an evaluation framework, RolloutFaith, which includes three world models and defines two criteria for evaluating the effects of interventions on long rollout: Immediate Semantic Gain (ISG) and Sustained Semantic Gain (SSG). The authors benchmarke 10 baseline methods and propose a new variant delayed LoReFT that are trained with signals from further timestamps.

Critical strengths
  • Targeting long term behaviors is an interesting problem: The problem covered in the evaluation framework RolloutFaith, i.e., targeting long rollout is interesting, and in many sense understudied in the literature.
  • Benchmark is well grounded in world models: The choice to ground the evaluation framework in world model is well motivated: world model naturally has dependencies over time. The three world models introduce different types of dependencies in the rollout.
Critical weaknesses

Table 2 may not be a fair comparison over baseline methods and Table 3 only shows marginal improvement of Delayed LoReFT:

  • Table 2 mixes in intervention methods with different expressivity: Methods like diffmean has no learnable parameter and optimization involved; yet methods like Nonlinear MLP and Immediate LoReFT has additional learnable parameters. Is it meaningful to even compare these interventions together?
  • The difference between Immediate vs. Delayed LoReFT appears to be marginal in Table 3. Also, only a single seed is used, so we can't tell what is the natural variance here. This weakens the conclusion "future transition supervision can improve sustained effects"

The interpretability framing is too broad and the connection to interpreting world models is weak:

  • While the paper frames the broader goal as "developing interpretability tools that target the long term behavior of model predictions", it is unclear what interpretability insights the proposed Delayed LoReFT method brings. The proposed method is a steering method that introduce additional learnable parameters, basically does parameter efficient fine-tuning. While it can induce intended model behaviors under appropriate learning signals (as most fine-tuning would do), it is unclear how much does the induced behavior brings insights into the internal mechanisms of the world model itself. For example, does the fact that at h=0 one can learn an intervention to control the next 8 steps tell us something about how the world model work? How do we know the computation pathways that control the next 8 steps exist in the world model naturally or get induced by the intervention? It might be better to drop the interpretability framing and focus on controlling the model behavior.
Questions for authors

In addition to the weaknesses above,

  • Related to the framing question, the paper briefly mentioned "the usefulness of a WM depends on how faithfully its predictions evolve over time", what does faithful mean here? How does the proposed benchmark RolloutFaith help with the faithfulness in this context?
  • There are quite a few cases in Table 2 that has SSG@8 > ISG? Does it mean the method somehow does better on longer range, but not shorter range? If so, why? If not, are they all noises, in which case, maybe it would be good to report results over multiple seeds?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.