- Rating
- 4(+1)
- Confidence
- 3(−1)
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces Causal Contribution Profiling (CCP), a framework for characterizing how task-related causal contributions are distributed across MLP neurons in large language models and how this organization changes during post-training. The method ranks neurons using attribution patching and progressively expands activation-patching interventions, with size- and layer-matched random controls to estimate contribution density. Experiments cover 31 models from five model families, 36 tasks, and three training trajectories. The results reveal a task-selective core–periphery organization, in which a small subset of neurons accounts for a disproportionately large share of positive causal contributions. The authors further show that core membership is generally more stable than peripheral membership, that future core neurons can contribute before full behavioral success, and that attribution scores from earlier checkpoints can predict newly recruited core and support members. Overall, the paper provides a systematic framework for studying the organization and evolution of task-related causal contributions in LLMs.
Critical strengths
-
The paper introduces a principled framework that combines attribution-based neuron ranking, progressively expanded activation-patching interventions, and matched random controls. This goes beyond identifying highly ranked neurons by quantifying how causal contribution density varies across the neuron ranking.
-
The experimental evaluation covers a relatively broad range of model families, model scales, and tasks. The analysis also extends beyond static neuron localization to investigate membership stability, contribution changes, and the predictability of organizational remodeling across training checkpoints.
Critical weaknesses
-
The related-work discussion appears to miss relevant research on causal identification of critical neurons. In particular, https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.10238 investigates perturbation-based identification of critical neurons and reports highly sparse critical neuron sets whose disruption can cause substantial degradation in language-model performance. This work is closely related to the present paper's investigation of causal neuron contributions and their concentration. The current manuscript should better position its contribution relative to this line of research and clarify what is novel beyond identifying sparse, causally important neurons.
-
The conclusions about core–periphery organization are based on interventions over a limited scanned range of MLP neurons (approximately 1.6% of the population). In addition, the core and periphery are defined using positive-contribution coverage thresholds. Although this operational definition is reasonable, it remains unclear how robust the organizational findings are to different scan ranges, coverage thresholds, and neuron-ranking choices.
-
The membership-forecasting results are promising, but their practical predictive value remains somewhat unclear. The evaluation uses the observed size of the future target set to determine the number of neurons selected. Moreover, although early-stage attribution outperforms matched random baselines in most eligible cases, the recovery rates for newly recruited core and support members vary considerably across training trajectories. Stronger comparisons and a clearer assessment of the limitations of this forecasting setup would help establish the significance of the results.
Questions for authors
-
The authors should conduct sensitivity analyses to assess the robustness of the core–periphery structure. These could vary the coverage thresholds used to define the core and periphery, expand or alter the scanned neuron range, and compare alternative attribution rankings. It would also be useful to examine whether the main stability and forecasting conclusions persist under these choices.
-
The authors should strengthen the membership-forecasting evaluation by comparing early-stage attribution against more informative baselines, such as rankings based on existing core or peripheral membership and layer-specific statistics. Where feasible, the authors should also evaluate settings in which the future target-set size is not assumed to be known. Reporting recovery distributions and effect sizes across tasks, rather than primarily the proportion of cases exceeding a random baseline, would provide a clearer picture of the method's practical predictive value.
4 comments
Response to Reviewer csz6 [Part 2/2]
We appreciate the reviewer's specific suggestions for evaluating the practical value of membership prediction. We added stronger baselines, evaluations independent of future set size, and task-wise results, and explored a pruning application.
Q3: What is the practical value of membership prediction under stronger baselines, unknown future set sizes, and task-level variation?
(a) Predictive information beyond existing membership. Using the same earlier checkpoint and samples, we compared attribution with a membership-and-layer prior, EAP, and EAP-IG. Results on seven OLMo2-1B Base–SFT tasks show that earlier contributions provide predictive information beyond existing membership and layer statistics, supporting the prioritization of future high-contribution neurons (Table R7; Appendix D.4).
Table R7. Mean AP across Seven Tasks (%).
| Method | Whole core | New core | New support |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ours | 68.57 | 31.19 | 25.75 |
| Membership + layer prior | 55.02 | 6.65 | 1.99 |
| EAP (Syed et al., 2024) | 67.25 | 29.47 | 21.82 |
| EAP-IG (Hanna et al., 2024) | 58.10 | 17.61 | 15.12 |
(b) Unknown future set size and task-wise results. We added AP and recovery at ten prespecified selection fractions (0.01%–5%), making selection budgets independent of future set size. The mean recovery advantage over EAP-IG is more pronounced at smaller budgets, supporting contribution-based prioritization of future high-contribution neurons. Our method also outperforms EAP-IG on most tasks. For example, new-core and new-support AP improve by 36.81 and 41.87 percentage points on noun agreement. Complete task-wise results are reported in Appendix D.4.
(c) Pruning application. Contribution information also provides a practical basis for model pruning. By preserving the main positive-attribution support and removing weakly attributed channels, we constructed separate OLMo2-1B Instruct variants for three tasks. Without retraining, each variant removes 5.42% of parameters, with BF16 accuracy gains of 2.95–8.77 percentage points and improvements also observed in FP32. All three achieve higher observed accuracy than the full model and the mean of layer-matched random prunings (Appendix E). We hypothesize that removing weakly attributed channels may reduce task-irrelevant interference while preserving the main task support. These results demonstrate the potential of contribution information to reduce model size and improve task performance. We will further investigate this explanation and evaluate contribution-guided pruning across a broader range of tasks and models.
I thank the authors for their detailed rebuttal. Since my concerns have been fully addressed, I have decided to raise my rating.
We sincerely appreciate your positive evaluation. Your valuable suggestions are essential to the improvement of our manuscript.
Response to Reviewer csz6 [Part 1/2]
We sincerely appreciate the reviewer's thoughtful assessment and constructive suggestions, particularly the recognition of CCP's principled design, the breadth of our experiments, and the value of studying contribution dynamics across training.
Q1: What does this study contribute beyond existing work on critical neurons?
We have added The Achilles' Heel of LLMs to Section 6 of the main text and clarified its relationship to our study. Qin et al. demonstrate that perturbing an ultra-sparse set of critical neurons can severely impair language abilities, revealing models' strong dependence on these small sets. From a cross-task perspective, Han et al. establish functional differentiation: neuronal recruitment overlaps more within cognitive domains and is more distinct across domains. We further examine how causal support is distributed within individual tasks and changes during training, revealing a small, high-density core and broader, lower-density support. Core membership is generally more stable than peripheral membership, while remodeling involves strengthening or weakening existing contributions and exchanging high-contribution members.
We appreciate the suggestion to examine how these measurement choices affect our findings. We added scan-range and coverage-threshold sensitivity analyses and compared alternative attribution rankings for prediction.
Q2: How robust are the findings to the scan range, coverage thresholds, and attribution ranking?
(a) Scan range. Extending the scan from 1.6% to 3.2% and 5% preserved contribution concentration: at the 5% limit, 0.109% of all MLP neurons accounted for 50% of the contribution within the scan (Appendix B.4). Across 90 common checkpoint comparisons, mean core stability exceeded peripheral stability in all three trajectories at every limit (Appendix C.1). Recovery rates varied with the target sets redefined at each limit; at 5%, whole-core recovery ranged from 66.33% to 77.88% and new-core recovery from 23.19% to 30.36% across trajectories (Appendix D.3).
(b) Coverage thresholds. We crossed core thresholds of 40%, 50%, and 60% with support thresholds of 80%, 90%, and 95%, yielding nine settings. Across the same 190 primary comparisons, each trajectory retained a positive mean core-minus-periphery stability difference under every setting. Equal-size windows of 20 or 25 neurons also showed greater average stability near the ranking's beginning (Appendix C.1).
(c) Alternative attribution rankings. We adapted EAP (Syed et al., 2024) and EAP-IG (Hanna et al., 2024), originally developed for circuit discovery, to neuron-level scoring for future-member prediction. Using the same checkpoint and samples across seven OLMo2-1B Base–SFT tasks, our method, EAP, and EAP-IG achieved mean average precision (AP) of 31.19%, 29.47%, and 17.61% for new-core prediction, respectively (Appendix D.4). These comparisons evaluate prediction against the same CCP-defined target memberships. The organizational profiles remain conditional on CCP's task-specific ranking.
References
Zixuan Qin, Qingchen Yu, Kunlin Lyu, Zhaoxin Fan, and Yifan Sun. 2026. The Achilles' Heel of LLMs: How Altering a Handful of Neurons Can Cripple Language Abilities. International Conference on Learning Representations (ICLR).
Pengrui Han, Jacob Andreas, Evelina Fedorenko, and Andrea Gregor de Varda. 2026. Modular Cognitive Architecture Emerges in Large Language Models. arXiv:2608.13567.
Aaquib Syed, Can Rager, and Arthur Conmy. 2024. Attribution Patching Outperforms Automated Circuit Discovery. Proceedings of the 7th BlackboxNLP Workshop: Analyzing and Interpreting Neural Networks for NLP, pp. 407–416.
Michael Hanna, Sandro Pezzelle, and Yonatan Belinkov. 2024. Have Faith in Faithfulness: Going Beyond Circuit Overlap When Finding Model Mechanisms. First Conference on Language Modeling (COLM).