- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
To retain the behavioral implications of users’ concerns in memory, the paper proposes MAC (Memory as Affective Control), which complements semantic memory with a compact, updateable representation of action constraints. MAC selects affect-derived implications, revises them as new evidence arrives, and activates them on relevant steps. In addition to maintaining these memories at inference time with frozen models, the paper trains Qwen3.5-9B using SFT and DPO to better construct and use MAC memories.
The paper evaluates MAC on MAC-BENCH, a constructed benchmark of 200 coding and research scenarios, and on Terminal-Bench 2.1 and a 200-question BrowseComp subset with synthetic affective context. With matched memory budgets, MAC improves behavioral-alignment scores across four memory backbones. Blinded comparisons also favor MAC over a structured-control baseline with the same gating and update opportunities.
Critical strengths
- The paper addresses a practical limitation of agent memory. Remembering task facts does not necessarily preserve how users want the task to be carried out. Representing users’ concerns as action constraints, with conditions for updating or expiring them, is a useful approach to maintaining behavioral continuity in long-horizon tasks.
- The comparison with SCS+Gate is a meaningful control. Both methods receive the same information, memory budget, gating, and update opportunities. Blinded evaluations also favor MAC without exposing its memory cards or preferred paths to the evaluator.
Critical weaknesses
- The generalizability of the approach is not sufficiently established. MAC-BENCH uses predefined behavioral targets, and the public-task evaluations introduce synthetic affective context. These settings do not establish whether MAC can reliably infer appropriate action constraints from naturally occurring user concerns, particularly when those concerns are ambiguous or unfamiliar. The evidence therefore supports following specified constraints more strongly than alignment with users’ actual intentions.
- The dependence on model capability and the benefit of training remain unclear. MAC relies on the underlying model to extract actionable constraints, interpret the memory representation, and follow its gating and update rules. Its effectiveness may therefore depend substantially on instruction-following ability. Although the frozen-model evaluations cover multiple model families, only Qwen3.5-9B is trained, without a same-model comparison before training, after SFT, and after DPO. This leaves unclear whether training provides a generalizable improvement, compensates for limitations of this particular model, or enables a smaller model to match larger models under comparable task and compute settings.
Questions for authors
- Validity of inferred constraints: How were the control objectives and preferred behavioral paths generated and validated? Is there evidence that the constraints inferred by MAC reflect users’ actual intentions, rather than merely plausible interpretations of their concerns?
- Dependence on model capability and training: Do you have same-model results for Qwen3.5-9B before training, after SFT, and after DPO? How does the trained model compare with larger frozen models under matched conditions, particularly on independently verified task outcomes? This would help distinguish the benefit of training from differences in underlying model capability.
- Contribution of affective information: What distinguishes MAC’s processing from a generic method that extracts, updates, and applies action constraints? Do you have a matched comparison that isolates the contribution of affective information beyond the shared control fields and update opportunities in SCS+Gate?
- Real-world user alignment: Provide case studies or user evaluations, such as an A/B test or an Arena-style blinded comparison between MAC and the baseline? Allowing users to compare the resulting agent behaviors would help establish whether MAC’s inferred constraints match their actual intentions and improve their experience.