- Rating
- 1(−1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
AdaGEPA starts from GEPA’s prompt optimization strategy. Both study providing feedback form improvements in prompt. GEPA provides overall mechanism. 1) direct an AI to solve a problem 2) show another AI and let it revise the prompt 3)solve other problems based on the revised prompts. AdaGEPA adds more details in the step 2. Rather than showing random samples to another AI, a selective choice based on the content is proposed.
Critical strengths
GEPA introduced a simple yet powerful approach to reflective prompt optimization. AdaGEPA builds on this framework with a targeted modification to feedback selection, preserving most of the original minibatch while directing one example toward the current prompt’s weaknesses. This makes the intervention easy to integrate into GEPA’s existing search procedure without additional model calls for online feedback selection.
Critical weaknesses
The methodological novelty beyond GEPA appears limited. AdaGEPA retains GEPA’s prompt revision and search procedures, modifying feedback selection through at most one task-specific replacement per minibatch. While potentially useful, this is an incremental extension, and much of the selection logic relies on separately designed task adapters. The empirical gains also vary across settings, with additional SGD studies showing little or no final performance advantage over GEPA. Stronger evidence of consistent benefits would help establish the significance of this modification.
Questions for authors
Could you provide a practical criterion, based on the search budget and feedback pool size, for deciding when to use AdaGEPA instead of default GEPA?