- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SAGE, which models long-term memory as a learnable system for graph-based memory writing and reading.
Critical strengths
I appreciate the idea of linking the quality of memory writing to its subsequent use. This is better aligned with the needs of long-term memory systems than optimizing information extraction or retrieval in isolation.
Critical weaknesses
1.The writer already has access to the current query when constructing the graph. There are two different tasks here: organizing historical information first and subsequently answering questions that were not known in advance, and organizing historical information specifically for a query that is already known. Does graph construction at test time depend on the current query? Under this design, is the same graph reused across multiple queries? Can an improvement in the writing policy benefit previously unseen queries? The authors need to evaluate these aspects to demonstrate the generality and effectiveness of the memory, as well as the method’s potential applicability to real-world scenarios. 2.The paper presents a relatively comprehensive system design, but the main text does not clearly focus its core contribution. I suggest that the authors clarify the new mechanisms and their necessity in relation to the most closely related graph foundation model-based retrieval methods and trainable memory-writing approaches. For a framework that repeatedly emphasizes self-evolution, what exactly is distinctive about the writer and reader? These are common components in memory systems, and I would like the authors to clarify this point. For example, where do the core additional capabilities come from compared with existing GFM-based retrievers?
Questions for authors
Please see the specific concerns and questions raised in the Weaknesses section.