- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a stable probabilistic emulation framework for partially observed dynamical systems. Based on stochastic interpolants, the authors construct a stochastic generative process by learning a drift function to model the transition distribution of dynamical systems. To address the instability caused by accumulated approximation errors during long-term rollouts, the authors introduce forced-dissipative stochastic interpolants, where the drift function is parameterized with a structured decomposition into forcing, antisymmetric, dissipative, and nonlinear dissipative components. This design constrains energy growth while preserving flexibility for modeling complex dynamics. The paper further provides theoretical analysis based on Foster–Lyapunov conditions to establish stability and ergodicity properties of the proposed stochastic process. Experiments on Lorenz–96 systems demonstrate improved long-term statistical consistency and response under external forcing.
Critical strengths
- The paper provides a relatively rigorous theoretical analysis. The authors formally define stability conditions and establish stability and ergodicity guarantees of the proposed stochastic process based on Foster–Lyapunov theory.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper lacks a clear problem formulation and methodological narrative. It does not sufficiently explain the limitations of existing stochastic interpolant-based emulators and why the proposed drift parameterization can address instability during long-term rollouts, making the motivation and contribution less clear.
- The main novelty mainly lies in the structured parameterization of the drift function. However, the authors should better clarify the generality and broader impact of this design beyond the specific stochastic interpolant framework.
Questions for authors
The motivation for introducing the structured drift parameterization needs further clarification. What specific limitations arise when using conventional neural networks to parameterize the drift function? Compared with an unconstrained neural network drift, what theoretical or practical advantages does the proposed parameterization provide?
2 comments
Follow-up response to Reviewer xcaz
Dear Reviewer,
As the discussion period ends on November 18, we would like to know whether our reply addresses your concerns. In particular, the reply clearly explains the benefits of our forced-dissipative architecture, and the revised introduction states this motivation more explicitly. The new comparison with a simpler damped drift baseline and the new Marshall–Molteni experiments, described in the general comment, also support this motivation.
We would be glad to clarify any remaining point before the deadline, and we would be grateful if you would reconsider your assessment in light of these answers.
Response to Reviewer xcaz
We thank the reviewer for the careful reading and for noting the rigor of the stability and ergodicity analysis. We agree that the presentation can be clearer, and the revised introduction states the motivation more explicitly. We respectfully disagree that the problem formulation is missing from the submission, and summarize it below.
Problem formulation
A generative emulator is a Markov chain: each new state is sampled from a learned transition kernel given the previous state. Climate emulators are run over long times, so the emulator must converge to a unique stationary distribution, which defines its climate (Definition 1). It must also remain stable under an external forcing that drives it out of its training distribution (Section 2.2). Accurate one-step transitions imply neither property, and the existing remedies for unstable rollouts do not guarantee them for probabilistic emulators (Section 1). The paragraph "Problem statement" at the end of Section 2.2 states the problem formally.
The failure of unconstrained neural networks
The introduction of the submission identifies the cause of this failure: small one-step errors accumulate over long rollouts and can lead to finite-time blow-up (Ainslie et al., 2026). A detailed analysis of this failure is a research question of its own, which requires dedicated tools. The submission takes this failure as its starting point and focuses on enforcing stability. The revised introduction adds the following explanation of the failure.
Training fits the drift only near the training data. Far from it, the drift is set by the architecture, whose extrapolation is not controlled (Xu et al., 2021). Accumulated errors then push the state out of distribution. Classical stochastic climate models show the same failure, which is addressed with energy-constrained models (Majda and Harlim, 2013).
Our experiments confirm this failure on all three systems (see the general comment above). On two-layer Lorenz-96, the diffusion model with the lowest validation loss is also unstable, so a better fit does not ensure stability.
The role of the forced-dissipative drift
The Foster–Lyapunov condition (Proposition 4.1) is a standard sufficient condition for the stability of a Markov chain (Meyn and Tweedie, 2009). It requires the energy to decrease in expectation whenever it is large, at all states. The forced-dissipative drift b=F+Ax+Dx+S(x)x satisfies this condition for any trained weights. The terms A and S conserve the energy, which enters only through the bounded forcing F and the noise and is removed by the dissipation D at a guaranteed minimum rate (Proposition 3.1). This energy budget gives stability and ergodicity, with and without external forcing (Propositions 4.1 to 4.4).
This structure also matters for accuracy. We compare it with a simpler damped drift with a bounded network (see the general comment above). This drift also satisfies a Foster–Lyapunov condition, but its stationary distribution is inaccurate despite a lower validation loss. In the forced-dissipative drift, the energy-preserving structure of the transfer (A+S)x is imposed everywhere. In the simpler drift, the bounded network can only learn these transfers near the data. Dissipation and bounded forcing alone are thus not sufficient, and the energy-preserving structure is a key physical prior for accurate emulation.
Generality
The Foster–Lyapunov condition involves only the transition kernel, so it applies to any probabilistic emulator. The forced-dissipative constraint acts on the drift of a generative SDE, so it could also be imposed on other drift-based generative models, such as flow matching and diffusion models. We chose stochastic interpolants because their formulation makes the condition easier to establish. In all cases, the constraint requires no knowledge of the modeled equations.
The drift structure follows a design pattern used for deterministic models, such as stable port-Hamiltonian neural networks (Desai et al., 2021; Roth et al., 2025). The submission extends this pattern to probabilistic emulators, where it guarantees a unique stationary distribution, which is the climate of the emulator.
In the revision, the introduction and the end of Section 4 better explain why unconstrained drifts fail, and Appendix D.4 adds the comparison with the damped drift.
References