- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
So the autoencoder learned The Overcomplete Dictionary from the Medium of the Activation. In this paper, authors are talking about a solution to make this problem being resolved efficiently. by using the residual stream, The model will be able to confine the advance and the direction or subspace, fix it by the weights. The author concluded that geometry nominates and the intervention sign meaning and the WDD distinctive value is the mechanistic content attachd to each nominations.
Critical strengths
This paper provided an honest report of the negative result. It also has a very rigid and well-designed control group that considers about exact ground truth and carefully separates the conceptual idea and the statistical ideas. This paper also included a decent amount of breath.
Critical weaknesses
However, this paper also have limited practical value and it is not talking about a clear contribution. Consider about the top one record is only 0.46 to 0.69 below 1 billion parameters. The channel of the 447 study is narrow and WDD's necessity isn't shown. Also, I think the presentation of this paper is kind of bad. There are way too many tags. Without the bigger explanation and equation, it's hard to read through and understand.
Questions for authors
Do the results hold at early and late layers, for models beyond 7B, or for MoE architectures? What ground truth exists for attention and embedding atoms (20–40% of the support)? Could you build an oracle for heads, e.g., the true per-head output projected into its row space?