W1. The share of the margin over TAFAS and PETSA that comes from the architecture, rather than from the objective and tuning, is not yet isolated. The headline gap is about two points (6.20% vs 4.07%). DBCM's partial loss averages the revealed steps of every window, about 300 step pairs, while the released baseline code supervises only the first window's 24 pairs (tta/tafas.py, line 253). This is not a protocol violation, but the difference is not yet disclosed or ablated. In the released scripts, PETSA's gating initialization, rank and alpha are fixed across all 144 settings, while DBCM's learning rate differs from TAFAS's in 88. The selection split is not specified, and the LoRA rank sweep (Fig 3b) is reported on test MSE. Settling this point is the main step toward a clear contribution.
W2. The shared branch is shown to buy parameter efficiency; its contribution to accuracy, and theoretical backing for the low-rank premise, are not yet shown. In Fig 3a the shared adapter gives parity with TAFAS (0.3531 to 0.3530), and the accuracy gains come from the LoRA branch, the mixer and the gate. The ablation is incremental only, is run on iTransformer alone, and includes no variant without the shared branch. App G treats residual low-rankness as an empirical hypothesis, and no result yet links the degree of concentration to the size of the gain. Traffic (C=862), which would stress both the premise and the C x C mixer, is not evaluated. Because the components are individually standard and follow the TAFAS template, the conceptual step beyond TAFAS and PETSA is modest until this link is shown.
W3. The comparison with the most recent methods is not yet brought into the main protocol or the cost analysis. The 144-cell comparison uses only TAFAS and PETSA, both from 2025. DynaTTA, COSA and DynaME appear only in Appendix C on three or fewer backbones, and DynaTTA as run is worse than no adaptation (0.4977 vs 0.3687 on iTransformer). COSA is not run under the paper's protocol; instead, DBCM is moved into COSA's protocol (Table C.4). The efficiency analysis (Tables C.7 to C.9) includes only TAFAS, PETSA and DBCM. ADAPT-Z (Huang et al., ICLR 2026) is not yet cited or compared, and ELF (Lee et al., ICML 2025) is cited but not compared, although Table C.2 is exactly its setting.
W4. Reproduction from the paper alone is not yet possible, and the released material covers the main table but not the appendix. No anonymous repository is provided, and code is promised upon publication. The paper omits the selected per-setting hyperparameters and the initialization of the module's weights. Both matter here, because in the supplement the module does not start at the identity and the learning rate and gate initialization are tuned per setting. The supplementary code reproduces the 144-cell main table, which is valuable, but not the appendix experiments, including the comparisons with recent methods and the efficiency measurements.
Minor points, listed separately from the weaknesses above and not weighed in the assessment:
- The OneNet reference should be cited as Zhang et al., 2023, not with Qingsong Wen as first author.
- Sec 5.2 reports 4.07% for TAFAS while the per-backbone values in Table 2 average to 4.08%; please harmonize the rounding.
Further requests, not decisive for the assessment:
- Please explain why DBCM falls below the frozen forecaster at ETTh2-192 and ETTm2-720 on all three backbones in Table C.4, and whether it was re-tuned for COSA's protocol.
- Please explain the zero-shot ETTm1 numbers for Chronos (1.5167) and Moirai (1.0543) in Table C.2, and extend that experiment beyond H=96.
- Please report paired significance tests and additional seeds on Exchange at long horizons, where DBCM's seed standard deviation reaches 0.1460 at Exchange-720.