acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

EMERGE-Policy: A Robot Mind Emerges Beyond a Single Policy

Abstract

A robot's effective “mind” need not reside in a single policy. It can emerge when specialized components perceive, reason, predict, act, verify, and remember within a shared orchestration process. EMERGE-Policy turns this perspective into a graph-structured agentic framework that coordinates both capability invocation and information exchange. A Main Agent retains task-level state within an active context window, while role-specific Sub Agents process perception, execution monitoring, verification, and memory consolidation in isolated contexts and return structured, task-relevant evidence. Role-specific contexts control information load by exposing only decision-relevant evidence to the Main Agent, while the functional Skill interface composes heterogeneous backends as Operational, Imagination, and Evaluation Skills. Criterion-grounded verification, textual failure diagnosis, and Branch Stack recovery provide localized correction, with token-aware external memory preserving task-relevant state. Together, their closed-loop interaction realizes the system-level policy captured by the name EMERGE-Policy. Without additional fine-tuning, we achieved outstanding performance on several public benchmark that have had a wide-reaching impact, and conducted a series of real robot experiments. These system-level results suggest that through the division of different functional sub-tasks among multiple agents and their concurrent collaboration, as well as the technical paradigm where the model is regarded as a skill and called within the framework, EMERGE-Policy can extend the robust robot policies beyond isolated runs.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
embodied intelligent system, embodied agent, graph-structured agentic framework

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 15%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 3.00 over 3 reviews, above 85% of the others.
Reviewer_9eASOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

The paper introduces EMERGE-Policy, a graph-structured agentic framework for robot manipulation that coordinates a Main Agent, role-specific Sub Agents, a unified Skill library, and external memory. The framework treats heterogeneous components such as VLAs, world models, verifiers, and motion primitives as callable skills, while using context-isolated sub-agents for perception, monitoring, verification, and memory consolidation. It also incorporates criterion-grounded subgoals, local Branch Stack recovery, and token-aware memory for long-horizon execution. The method is evaluated on LIBERO, LIBERO-Plus, RoboDojo, and real-robot long-horizon manipulation tasks, showing improvements over strong policy baselines without additional fine-tuning.

Critical strengths
  1. Well-designed system integration for long-horizon manipulation. The framework brings planning, perception, verification, recovery, heterogeneous robot skills, and memory into a single closed-loop architecture with explicit interfaces between components. This is practically useful for robust long-horizon execution, even if the individual ingredients are not new.

  2. Broad empirical validation across multiple settings and backends. EMERGE-Policy is evaluated on LIBERO, LIBERO-Plus, RoboDojo, and real-robot tasks, and is designed to work with different VLA and world-model backends. The consistent gains across these settings provide evidence that the framework is useful beyond a single benchmark or policy.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited conceptual novelty. The paper mainly integrates existing ideas, including hierarchical agent orchestration, specialized sub-agents, tool and skill invocation, verification, recovery, and external memory, into a unified robotics framework. The main novelty therefore appears to lie in system organization and interface design rather than a fundamentally new algorithm or principle.

  2. The source of the gains is still somewhat difficult to isolate. EMERGE-Policy combines several mechanisms simultaneously, including evaluation skills, world-model imagination, sub-agents, memory, and recovery. Although the paper provides ablations, these mostly remove relatively large components, so it remains unclear which specific orchestration choices are essential and whether comparable gains could be obtained with a simpler agentic baseline.

Questions for authors
  1. How does EMERGE-Policy compare against a simpler single-agent baseline using the same skills, memory, verifier, and recovery mechanisms? This would help determine whether the multi-agent orchestration itself is responsible for the gains.

  2. Which design choices are essential to the framework’s advantage beyond simply combining more components? More targeted ablations of context isolation, Branch Stack recovery, and structured evidence passing would help clarify the main source of improvement.

Reviewer_apbyOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
4(+1)
Informativeness
3(+1)
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents EMERGE-Policy, a graph-structured multi-agent orchestration framework for robot manipulation. Rather than relying on a single end-to-end policy, the framework coordinates specialized components for high-level planning, perception, action execution, outcome verification, and failure recovery.

Specifically, EMERGE-Policy employs a Main Agent for task decomposition and orchestration, context-isolated Sub Agents for perception, monitoring, and verification, and a unified Skill interface that organizes VLAs, world models, and evaluation models into Operational, Imagination, and Evaluation Skills. The framework further introduces criterion-grounded subgoals, Branch Stack-based localized recovery, and external memory for task-state management and closed-loop execution.

The authors evaluate the system on LIBERO, LIBERO-Plus, LIBERO-Pro, RoboDojo, and real-robot cup-stacking tasks. The results demonstrate improvements across multiple settings, particularly in robustness to environmental perturbations and implicit-instruction following.

Overall, the main contribution is a system-level framework for coordinating heterogeneous robotic capabilities, rather than a new low-level action policy or training algorithm.

Critical strengths
  1. A practically meaningful and relatively comprehensive system-level architecture for robotic manipulation.

The paper addresses an important challenge in long-horizon robot manipulation: strong low-level execution policies alone do not necessarily guarantee reliable completion of complex tasks. A robotic system must also coordinate planning, perception, outcome verification, and failure recovery.

EMERGE-Policy provides a reasonably comprehensive approach to this problem. In particular, criterion-grounded subgoals establish a shared basis for planning, execution, and verification. The division into Operational, Imagination, and Evaluation Skills enables heterogeneous models to participate in a unified execution protocol, while Branch Stack provides an explicit mechanism for localized correction when execution deviates from the intended outcome.

Furthermore, specialized Sub Agents and external memory help separate complex perceptual and execution evidence from high-level decision-making contexts. Although these mechanisms are not individually entirely novel, their integration forms a coherent and practically useful architecture. I consider this a meaningful systems contribution toward building reliable robotic agents on top of existing policies and world models.

  1. Broad experimental evaluation with meaningful real-robot validation.

The evaluation covers not only standard LIBERO manipulation tasks but also environmental perturbations, implicit language instructions, bimanual manipulation, and real-world robotic execution. This breadth allows the authors to examine the framework from several complementary perspectives.

In particular, EMERGE-Policy with the world-model pathway improves the average success rate on LIBERO-Plus from 82.2% for the corresponding Cosmos Policy backend to 93.9%. The substantial improvements on several implicit-instruction tasks in LIBERO-Pro are also encouraging, suggesting that high-level reasoning, perceptual grounding, and closed-loop feedback can effectively complement existing low-level policies.

Additionally, the results on the Memory and Open dimensions of RoboDojo, together with the failure detection and recovery examples in real-robot cup stacking, demonstrate the potential benefits of the framework for task-state management and complex execution workflows. The authors also include component ablations rather than relying solely on full-system performance. Although some attribution issues remain, the experimental coverage and implementation effort are important strengths of this work.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The independent technical contribution of the core architecture and its advantages over existing approaches are not sufficiently established.

The paper's main contribution lies in combining multi-agent organization, context isolation, unified Skill interfaces, external memory, and localized recovery. While this integration has practical value, many of these mechanisms are closely related to existing hierarchical robotic control and agentic harness frameworks. The paper explains the responsibilities of individual components but does not sufficiently establish why the proposed organization is preferable to existing architectures or simpler alternatives.

For instance, context-isolated Sub Agents are presented as an important architectural choice, yet there is no direct comparison against a functionally equivalent single-agent system. The w/o Sub ablation in Table 4 removes the functionalities of the Verification and Monitor Sub Agents along with the multi-agent structure, making it difficult to separate the benefits of these functionalities from those of context isolation and agent specialization. Similarly, Branch Stack provides a structured implementation of localized recovery, but its advantages over conventional action retries or global replanning have not been sufficiently demonstrated. The description of graph-structured orchestration also focuses primarily on component invocation and information flow, while the distinctive structural design principles could be better articulated.

I do not believe that a systems paper necessarily requires a new model architecture or learning algorithm. However, its key system-level design choices should constitute identifiable and empirically supported technical contributions. The current paper does not fully establish this distinction, which remains my main concern regarding novelty and significance.

  1. The experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of the complete system, but provide limited analysis of the underlying mechanisms, sources of improvement, and system costs.

The paper presents extensive experimental results and several ablations. However, much of the analysis focuses on final task success rates, with limited direct validation of some central methodological claims.

First, context isolation is motivated by reducing information overload and improving long-horizon execution, but the paper provides limited measurements of context length, token consumption, or information retention. Second, although Branch Stack is one of the more distinctive components, its triggering frequency, recovery success rate, execution overhead, and advantages over global replanning are not systematically quantified.

Furthermore, the existing ablations primarily demonstrate the importance of functional components rather than establishing specific interaction effects among them. In particular, the w/o WM configuration also involves a change in the execution backend, so the corresponding performance differences should be interpreted carefully. The relatively strong performance on RoboDojo Memory and Open tasks, compared with more limited results on Precision and Long-Horizon tasks, also deserves further analysis to clarify the framework's strengths and limitations.

Regarding evaluation protocols, the additional camera views and extended episode limits described in Section 4.1, as well as the use of environment-state information in Appendix A.5, require clarification. Since the framework involves multiple agent and model calls, a more comprehensive analysis of end-to-end latency and computational overhead would also be valuable.

Overall, these limitations do not negate the reported improvements, but they make it difficult to fully understand their sources and whether the benefits justify the additional architectural complexity.

Questions for authors

Overall, I consider this a borderline submission. The paper presents a practically meaningful system with broad experimental validation and encouraging real-robot results. However, some concerns remain regarding the independent contributions of its core architectural choices and the empirical support for several key mechanisms.

I hope the authors can substantively address most of the major concerns raised below during the rebuttal, particularly by clarifying the independent benefits of their architectural choices and providing stronger empirical evidence or analysis. If the authors provide convincing responses, I would be happy to maintain my positive assessment. Conversely, if most of the key concerns remain unresolved, I would also consider lowering my score.

  1. Independent contribution and necessity of the multi-agent architecture

The paper presents context-isolated Sub Agents as a central architectural design, but their independent contribution remains unclear. In particular, the w/o Sub ablation in Table 4 removes the functionalities provided by the Verification and Monitor Sub Agents, making it difficult to distinguish the benefits of these functionalities from those of multi-agent organization and context isolation.

Could the authors clarify the specific advantages of the proposed architecture over a single Main Agent equipped with the same perception tools, evaluation mechanisms, external memory, and recovery capabilities? Are there functionally matched comparisons or other evidence demonstrating the additional benefits of specialized agents with isolated contexts?

  1. Practical contribution of Branch Stack-based recovery

Branch Stack enables localized recovery before resorting to global replanning. However, the current evaluation primarily reports overall success rates and selected recovery examples, without systematically quantifying the contribution of this mechanism.

Could the authors report how frequently Branch Stack recovery is triggered, its success rate, the average number of recovery attempts, and the associated execution overhead? Appendix A.2.2 specifies a threshold of two consecutive failed recovery attempts before global replanning. What motivates this choice? Furthermore, how does Branch Stack compare with simple action retries or direct global replanning in terms of task success and execution efficiency?

  1. Effectiveness of context isolation and external memory

The paper motivates context-isolated Sub Agents and external memory as mechanisms for reducing information overload and supporting long-horizon task execution. However, the current experiments primarily demonstrate these benefits indirectly through task performance.

Could the authors quantify the effects of context isolation on Main Agent context length, token consumption, model invocation costs, and long-horizon state retention? Additionally, what are the respective contributions of PLAN.md, HISTORY.md, and MEMORY.md? Could targeted ablations or case studies clarify the advantages of the proposed structured memory over directly maintaining execution history?

  1. Evaluation protocol, performance differences, and system overhead

Section 4.1 states that EMERGE-Policy uses five additional camera views and extended episode step limits for the LIBERO benchmarks. Could the authors clarify whether the compared methods have access to equivalent observation and execution budgets, and to what extent these differences might affect the reported improvements?

Additionally, the RoboDojo execution workflow in Appendix A.5 involves reading ENVIRONMENT.md, which contains fields such as done and success. Are these signals available during policy execution, and do the baselines have access to equivalent information?

Finally, it would be helpful to report end-to-end execution latency and model invocation costs, and to further discuss the varying performance across RoboDojo capability dimensions. These analyses would help clarify the practical strengths, limitations, and deployment costs of the framework.

Reviewer_mQ61OpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper presents EMERGE-Policy, a graph-structured agentic framework for robotic manipulation that coordinates multiple specialized components instead of relying on a single end-to-end policy. The proposed framework consists of a Main Agent responsible for high-level planning, task decomposition, and failure recovery, together with specialized Sub-Agents for perception, execution monitoring, and verification. It introduces a unified Skill interface that organizes heterogeneous models into Operational, Imagination, and Evaluation Skills. Additionally, the framework incorporates structured memory management and a Branch Stack mechanism for localized failure recovery. The authors evaluate EMERGE-Policy on LIBERO, LIBERO-Plus, LIBERO-Pro, and RoboDojo, as well as real-world multi-step robotic manipulation tasks. The framework achieves an average success rate of 99.2% on standard LIBERO and 93.9% on LIBERO-Plus when using the world-model pathway. Ablation experiments indicate that evaluation, world-model prediction, and specialized Sub-Agents contribute to the overall performance. Overall, the paper demonstrates the potential of modular multi-agent orchestration for improving the robustness of existing robotic policies without additional fine-tuning.

Critical strengths
  1. A flexible and modular framework for integrating heterogeneous robotic capabilities. The paper presents a unified framework that integrates high-level planning, perception, action execution, future prediction, verification, and memory management. The separation between the Main Agent and specialized Sub-Agents provides a practical mechanism for organizing complex robotic tasks while reducing the amount of information processed by the high-level planner. Furthermore, the unified Skill interface allows different VLA and world-model backends to be incorporated without additional fine-tuning. This modular design could be useful for developing extensible robotic systems.
  2. Extensive experimental evaluation demonstrating improvements in manipulation robustness. The authors evaluate their framework across several widely adopted robotic manipulation benchmarks, including LIBERO, LIBERO-Plus, and LIBERO-Pro, as well as real-world manipulation experiments. The reported improvements are particularly notable under environmental perturbations and implicit instructions. For example, the world-model variant achieves 93.9% average success on LIBERO-Plus, compared with 82.2% for its underlying Cosmos Policy backend. The ablation studies further provide evidence that evaluation, prediction, and specialized Sub-Agents contribute to the overall system performance.
Critical weaknesses

Limited methodological novelty compared with existing robotic agent frameworks. While EMERGE-Policy presents a comprehensive framework for robotic manipulation, its main components, including hierarchical task planning, multi-agent collaboration, skill orchestration, external memory, and failure recovery, have been explored in previous studies. The paper appears to primarily integrate existing techniques into a unified system, rather than introducing fundamentally new algorithms or mechanisms. Although such integration can have practical value, the methodological contributions beyond existing agentic robotic frameworks, such as RoboHarness and HarnessVLA, are not sufficiently clear. Consequently, I find it difficult to assess whether the proposed framework represents a substantial methodological advance over prior work.

Questions for authors

Clarification of methodological novelty.

  1. Could the authors clarify the key methodological innovations of EMERGE-Policy compared with existing robotic agent frameworks, particularly RoboHarness and HarnessVLA?
  2. Specifically, which components or mechanisms represent genuinely new contributions, rather than adaptations or integrations of existing techniques?
  3. Additionally, what fundamental advantages does the proposed framework offer over existing approaches beyond the reported empirical performance improvements?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.