- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3(+1)
- Presentation
- 3(+1)
- Soundness
- 3(+1)
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes RES, a framework for increasing the difficulty of long-horizon agent tasks while preserving their original objectives and completion requirements. RES recursively transforms information access, resource relationships, and operational dependencies through proposer-guided modifications and execution-grounded validation. Accepted transformations are inherited across rounds, progressively increasing environmental complexity. Experiments across multiple benchmarks and models demonstrate that RES effectively increases task difficulty while generating valuable trajectories for agent training. Ablation studies further highlight the importance of recursive inheritance and dependency composition.
Critical strengths
-
A novel perspective on scaling agent environments. Unlike existing approaches that focus on generating new tasks or constructing environments from scratch, this paper proposes scaling existing environments while preserving the original task objectives and completion requirements. This offers a meaningful alternative for increasing benchmark difficulty and enables more controlled comparisons of agent capabilities.
-
An effective recursive environment scaling framework. The proposed method progressively increases environmental complexity through recursive inheritance and dependency composition. Extensive experiments demonstrate its effectiveness in increasing task difficulty and improving agent training, while ablation studies provide evidence supporting the importance of its key components.
Critical weaknesses
-
Increased difficulty does not necessarily imply more challenging reasoning. The performance degradation observed in scaled environments may largely stem from increased operational overhead—such as additional tool calls and execution dependencies—rather than from more demanding planning or reasoning requirements. Further analysis is needed to disentangle these factors and clarify which agent capabilities are actually being evaluated.
-
Reliance on manually designed transformation operators. The framework depends on a predefined library of transformation operators and benchmark-specific adaptations, which may limit its generalizability and scalability to unseen environments. It remains unclear to what extent RES can be applied to new domains without substantial manual engineering.
Questions for authors
- The evaluation uses a fixed 50-turn limit, while RES substantially increases the number of required interactions and tool calls. How sensitive are the reported performance drops to this execution budget? Would the scaled environments remain significantly more challenging with larger turn or token budgets?
- The original training trajectories are generated by DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash, whereas RES trajectories are collected using GPT-5.6 Sol. How can the authors disentangle the benefits of RES from differences in teacher model capabilities and trajectory quality? Would the improvements persist if the same teacher model were used for both settings?
- To what extent does RES increase the complexity of planning and reasoning rather than simply introducing additional operational overhead? Could the authors provide a more detailed analysis of agent failure patterns to clarify the sources of increased difficulty?
- RES relies on a predefined transformation library and benchmark-specific adaptations. How much manual engineering is required to extend the framework to new environments, and how well does it generalize beyond the evaluated benchmarks?
4 comments
Thank you for the detailed response and additional experiments, which have largely addressed my concerns regarding execution dependencies, generalizability, execution budgets, and the teacher model used for trajectory generation.
However, due to my personal research taste, I still view environment synthesis primarily as an engineering challenge rather than a scientific problem that I find particularly exciting. Therefore, I will maintain my overall rating while increasing my scores for Presentation, Informativeness, and Soundness.
Nevertheless, I consider this paper a solid piece of work, and I would have no objection if the AC recommends acceptance. I wish the authors all the best in their future research.
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the careful reading, for raising the Presentation, Informativeness, and Soundness scores, and for the candid assessment. We respect the reviewer’s view on environment synthesis. Our aim in this paper is to use environment scaling as an instrument for studying agents: with task objectives held fixed, it lets us measure how success depends on execution dependencies. The reviewer’s comments helped us state this more clearly, and we thank the reviewer again for the time and effort.
Follow-up
Thank you again for raising the sub-scores. Should you find that the revision also merits a change in the overall rating, we would be grateful; we respect your judgment either way.
Response to Reviewer eiSB
We thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback. We address each point below; key manuscript revisions are highlighted in blue.
Q1: About Operational Overhead versus Planning and Reasoning.
Scope of the claim. The paper's claim concerns execution demand in long-horizon tasks, as its title and Figure 2 state. Section 3.1 now makes this explicit: RES scales the execution demand of a task rather than the difficulty of the underlying reasoning problem, and the objective, underlying facts, and completion requirements stay fixed. What RES scales is how information is organized, how resources are connected, and how earlier actions constrain later ones (Section 1).
This is not mere per-operation overhead. When cross-operator dependencies are removed but all atomic transformations are kept, agents still perform 12.8× the tool calls of the original tasks and pass 15/15 (new Table 4); they fail only when operations depend on one another. In the case study (Section 5.4), the agent issues 171 tool calls and reaches the turn limit while still acquiring evidence, without completing the reconciliation report. Partial completion declines as well (Workspace RPR falls by 5.52–10.81 points, Table 1). Finally, Table 2 evaluates on the original benchmarks, which contain no RES operators, and RES trajectories improve all nine comparisons. If RES added only overhead tied to its operators, no gain would be expected on benchmarks without them.
Revisions. Section 3.1: p. 4, lines 170–173; Table 4: p. 9, lines 433–444.
Q2: About Predefined Operators and Generalization.
What is predefined and what is automated. The transformation library is predefined by design, and the paper reports its effect directly: restricting it to six basic operators raises Pass@1 from 6.7% to 80.0% (Table 3B). What is predefined is the operator library and the benchmark adapters (Appendices A and D.1). Selecting operators, binding them to concrete resources, and composing them are done by the proposer for every task (Section 3.2), at a mean cost on Claw-Eval-Live of 1.45 proposer executions and 112.6 seconds per accepted child (Table A2).
New environments. The resource bindings and the transformation library are benchmark-specific, as Section 3.2 now states: Claw-Eval-Live transformations act on files and service records, Workspace transformations on files, structured records, and workflow dependencies, and Terminal transformations on container files, build configurations, database states, and service inputs. Extending RES to a new environment therefore requires transformations for its resource types, while the framework itself is shared. The three benchmarks cover different environments, and scaling lowers success for all six models on each of them (Table 1).
Revisions. Section 3.2: p. 4, lines 181–184.
Q3: About Sensitivity to the Execution Budget.
The comparison is paired under one budget. Each model receives the identical 50-turn attempt in the original and the scaled environment, and Section 4.2 now states that the results measure difficulty under this matched budget. The budget is not tight relative to the tasks: 50 turns is 14× the mean turn usage on the original tasks (3.55 turns), and a turn may contain several tool calls.
Path length versus dependencies. The new Table 4 shows that, with composed dependencies removed but all atomic transformations kept, environments need 6.6× the turns and 12.8× the tool calls of the originals, yet 15/15 tasks pass, and the 50-turn budget is 2.6× their mean usage (19.1 turns). Substantially longer execution alone therefore does not cause failure. Under the same budget, Pass@1 still ranges from 5.71% to 28.57% across models on scaled Claw-Eval-Live and from 39.33% to 47.19% on scaled Terminal-Bench.
Revisions. Section 4.2: p. 6, lines 316–318; Section 5.2: p. 8, line 431, and p. 9, lines 460–469; Table 4: p. 9, lines 433–444.
Q4: About the Teacher Model in the SFT Comparison.
Both settings use the same teacher, DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash. We apologize for the description error in Section 4.1 and Appendix B of the submitted version, which named GPT-5.6 Sol as the model collecting the RES trajectories; it is now corrected. In the training pipeline, GPT-5.6 Sol serves only as the proposer that constructs the scaled environments and never produces a training trajectory. The original ClawGym trajectories were generated by DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash, and the same model collects the trajectories in the RES-scaled environments built from the same training task pool, under the same selection and supervision rules. The improvements in Table 2 are therefore obtained with the same teacher model in both settings, and all numbers are unchanged.
Revisions. Section 4.1: p. 6, lines 300–304; Table 2 caption: p. 6, lines 273–274; Section 4.3: p. 7, lines 356–358; Appendix B: p. 15, lines 793–794.