- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces FCSNet for sequential prediction. It considers both user action sequences and evolving environmental context, which are not always well aligned. The method encodes the two sequences separately and combines their representations for prediction. It also includes dual prediction heads, adversarial prior regularization, and a similarity-adaptive contrastive objective (CCR). The experiments cover Outbrain and two large industrial datasets, with additional ablation studies and alignment perturbation tests. An online A/B test is also reported.
Critical strengths
- The problem seems well motivated. Separating user actions from environmental context is reasonable, particularly when the two sequences are not well aligned.
- The experimental evaluation is relatively comprehensive. The paper includes industrial datasets, ablation studies, and an online A/B test.
Critical weaknesses
- Figure 1 uses behavior-related icons to represent environmental context, which may be misleading. Besides, the overall architecture does not clearly show the dual prediction heads or the similarity-adaptive weighting mechanism of CCR.
- The captions of Tables 2 and 3 explicitly state that the checkpoint and test-split provenance of historical results “remains under verification.” Such an admission is inappropriate in a submitted paper, as the authors should verify these details before reporting the results.
- Most baselines are relatively outdated. (The latest method considered is from 2024 and appears only in the appendix.)
- It seems that the contributions of the auxiliary objectives are not sufficiently demonstrated. The ablation results show inconsistent benefits from LAPR and CCR. For example, removing LAPR improves NDCG@5 on Outbrain, while CCR provides only marginal gains on some datasets.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors clarify the use of behavior-related icons to represent environmental context in Figure 1? Would it be possible to better illustrate the dual prediction heads and the similarity-adaptive weighting mechanism of CCR?
- Why do the captions of Tables 2 and 3 state that the checkpoint and test-split provenance remains under verification?
- Could the authors include more recent baselines from 2025 and 2026?
- Could the authors further clarify the contributions of LAPR and CCR?
6 comments
Response to Weakness1 and Question1 of Reviewer wkrZ
Thank you for pointing out the ambiguity. We have replaced ambiguous channel symbols with explicit page labels on both the input and output sides: Recom Page, Search Page, and Live Page. The revised figure shows the item head and channel head separately; both receive fused representations and contribute to . The green and red CCR insets illustrate and : lower-similarity positives and higher-similarity negatives receive larger weights, emphasizing harder pairs.
Response to Weakness2 and Question2 of Reviewer wkrZ
The statement about checkpoint and test-split provenance was introduced in error during AI-assisted proofreading. We take responsibility and have corrected both captions. All methods use the same fixed test partition within each dataset. Correcting the captions did not change the original numerical results. Thanks for pointing out this error, we have updated the manuscript.
Response summary of Reviewer wkrZ
Thank you for your careful review and valuable suggestions on the presentation and experimental evaluation. Your comments have guided the revised architecture figure, clearer reporting of the comparisons, the additional TCLARec comparison, and a more detailed explanation of the auxiliary objectives. We have also added three-seed KuaiSAR results. The response of each concern is listed below.