- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes PhysRepair, a method for repairing physical errors in generated videos following a new paradigm of repairing videos after they have been generated. The contributions lie in two modules: 1) spatiotemporal causal constraints – identify the first frame where an error occured and connecting it with errors in the following frames to fix them locally and consistently; 2) in-context learning augmented by experience – use previous successful fixes to guide the current fix.
PhysRepair can be thought of as a component adapted to a pretrained video generator to improve its physical plausibility. Experiments on the Physics-IQ Verified benchmark show that PhysRepair improves the video generator's physical plausibility metrics. However, there are concerns about the advantages of PhysRepair compared to existing physical plausibility methods for video generation, as well as whether the extra computation imposed by PhysRepair is justified.
Critical strengths
-
PhysRepair can fix physical errors in generated videos after they have been generated (which can be thought of as post-processing). This is somewhat different from previous works that attempt to constrain physical plausibility before or during generation. This has two pros: it can fix all errors in the video if detected; it can fix errors locally without having to regenerate the whole video multiple times.
-
The proposed method is intuitive and reasonable. Identifying spatiotemporal causal errors and fixing them together makes sense, and leveraging past experience to guide the current fix helps reduce solution exploration.
-
The results seem pretty good, especially when compared to the baseline generator PhysRepair is attached to.
Critical weaknesses
-
The comparison with physics-aware methods is not clear: which paradigms (as illustrated in Fig. 1) do the two physics-aware methods in Table 1 belong to? PhyCo in Table 1 does not seem to be described in Related Work (or any other section of the paper). A more detailed comparison with them is needed to showcase the superiority of PhysRepair, especially a comparison of computational costs, since the paper claims PhysRepair can help reduce unnecessary video regeneration compared to existing physics-aware paradigms.
-
PhysRepair's generalization ability seems limited. It seems that PhysRepair has to be trained using the output of a specific generator and can only fix that generator's errors. The trained PhysRepair does not seem to be able to fix physical errors in a randomly generated video. Also, the extra training/computational cost of PhysRepair should be discussed to justify the performance gain.
-
The qualitative results are not convincing. Fig. 3 is very confusing, as all the baseline frames have red boxes, which prevent me from focusing on the actual errors. In Fig. 4, example 2, why does the new error (no foot–ball contact) appear compared to the MiniMax H3 baseline (column 2)? Isn't the model supposed to fix only the errors starting from the first frame where they are detected? Why does the model turn a frame without an error into a new frame with a physical error, which seems to contradict the description of the proposed method?
Questions for authors
-
I would appreciate if the authors can respond to the weaknesses I have identified above.
-
It would be good to differentiate the proposed method from simulator based methods such as "Physical Simulator In-the-Loop Video Generation" CVPR'26.
8 comments
Response to Reviewer RFCK (2/3)
W2: PhysRepair may be tied to videos from a specific generator, and additional training and inference costs may offset its gains.
R2: Cross-generator video repair and transfer of long-term experience. PhysRepair is an inference-time physics-repair framework, rather than a model trained exclusively on errors produced by one particular source generator. We apply the same repair pipeline to videos initially generated by Wan2.2-I2V-14B, rather than H3. We also evaluate whether repair experience acquired on H3-generated videos can be reused for Wan2.2 inputs without updating that experience during Wan2.2 evaluation.
Table R2. Cross-generator generalization to Wan2.2-I2V-14B videos. The unrepaired input has zero repair calls by definition; call efficiency is compared between the repaired settings. Bold indicates the best repaired setting.
| Setting | Physics-IQ ↑ | Mean Repair Calls ↓ |
|---|---|---|
| Original Wan2.2-I2V-14B | 32.20 | 0.00 |
| Wan2.2 + PhysRepair, without long-term memory | 37.30 | 10.81 |
| Wan2.2 + PhysRepair, frozen H3 experience | 38.70 | 7.24 |
Even without long-term memory, PhysRepair improves physical correctness on a different source generator. Moreover, reusing frozen repair experience accumulated from H3-generated videos further improves Physics-IQ and reduces mean repair calls. This indicates that previously learned repair strategies can be useful across source video generators; the framework does not require that all input videos originate from H3.
Training and Computational Cost. PhysRepair uses frozen pretrained video-generation and control modules, requiring neither source-generator-specific retraining nor parameter updates to learn new repair strategies. The additional computational overhead primarily comes from physical failure diagnosis, perception tool calls, local physics simulation, and iterative video repair. Our cross-generator experiments further show that reusing accumulated long-term experience reduces redundant repair attempts and lowers the average number of repair calls. Together with the comparisons against Resampling, Prompt Refinement, and Simulation Refinement, these results demonstrate that PhysRepair achieves higher physical correctness with greater repair-call efficiency.
Response to Reviewer RFCK (3/3)
W3: Red boxes obscure the qualitative comparison in Figure 3; in Figure 4, a previously valid foot–ball contact seems to disappear after repair.
R3: Figure 3. To improve the clarity of the comparison, we have replaced the two comparison panels with the annotated cue-ball and wrench--box cases and updated the caption in Figure 3 (refined, page 7) of the revised manuscript.
Figure 4. The missing foot–ball contact in Figure 4 is produced by the Without Causal Constraints ablation, not the complete PhysRepair method. In that ablated variant, the repair focuses on the visible soccer-ball/blue-ball collision and can improve the downstream collision while failing to preserve the earlier, physically valid foot–ball contact. The resulting ball trajectory no longer has a valid kick as its cause. This is the failure mode illustrated by the ablation: fixing the immediate error without maintaining the whole interaction's causal structure can disrupt valid preceding states.
The full method explicitly represents the chain foot–ball contact → soccer-ball motion → soccer-ball/blue-ball collision. It treats the valid kick and trustworthy pre-collision motion as states to preserve, while the incorrect collision and its affected descendants constitute the repair target. Thus, the same object can be subject to preservation constraints at one time and repair constraints at another, allowing PhysRepair to correct subsequent physical errors while preserving previously valid interactions as much as possible.
Manuscript revisions. In the revised manuscript, red marks changes to the original content, and blue marks newly added content.
To address W1/Q2, we have integrated PhyCo and PSIVG into the existing discussion of physics-aware video generation in Section 2.1 (page 3), updated the baseline metrics in Table 1 (updated, page 6), and explained how the added iterative controls relate to the prompt- and simulation-refinement strategies in the original Figure 1. Sections 4.1–4.2 define these controls and analyze Table 2 (newly added, page 8).
To address W2, Appendix C.2 (page 14) clarifies the frozen generation/control modules, while Appendix A.4 (page 13) and Table A.4 (newly added, page 14) provide the complete Wan2.2 repair results and discussion of frozen H3 experience transfer without source-specific retraining.
To address W3, Figure 3 (refined, page 7) uses the updated cue-ball and wrench--box comparison panels with per-row failure descriptions, with the corresponding qualitative analysis aligned to those annotations; Figure 4 (refined, page 9) and Section 4.3 (pages 8–9) identify the missing kick as an ablation failure and explain preservation of valid preceding states, with the added cup/basin example showing correction of both physical inconsistencies.
Response to Reviewer RFCK (1/3)
We thank the reviewer for the constructive questions about the positioning of physics-aware methods, cross-generator generalization, computational overhead, and the qualitative examples. We combine the comparison question with the related simulator-based-method question.
R1: We clarify that VLIPP and PhyCo, as reported in the original Table 1, are not direct implementations of the two iterative paradigms shown in Figure 1. VLIPP predicts coarse physical motion trajectories using visual-language planning and injects those priors before generation, making it closer to pre-generation planning. PhyCo uses physical supervision and VLM feedback to learn controllable physics-aware priors, with feedback used for training rather than an inference-time loop that diagnoses and repairs particular errors. PSIVG reconstructs a scene from a template video, uses simulation to guide motion, and optimizes texture consistency. PhysRepair instead begins with a specific physical failure in an already-generated video, identifies the first invalid state and its causally affected descendants, and constructs a repair specification containing both editable and preserved object–space–time states. This distinguishes post-generation, evidence-grounded causal repair from pre-generation simulator-based guidance and from global prompt/simulator refinement.
To examine those strategy differences under aligned experimental settings, we additionally compared Resampling (new noise and repeated regeneration), Prompt Refinement (revised prompts and global regeneration; representative of Fig. 1(a)), and Simulation Refinement (updated global simulation conditions and regeneration; representative of Fig. 1(b)). All use the same maximum of 20 iterations.
Table R1. Iterative baselines on Physics-IQ Verified, with a 20-round maximum. Lower P-LPIPS indicates better preservation of unaffected content; bold marks the best result.
PhysRepair achieves the highest Physics-IQ and best preservation with the fewest mean calls among these controlled strategies. Relative to Simulation Refinement, its mean calls fall by 35.9%, while achieving comparable physical correctness and better content preservation. Unlike broad regeneration, PhysRepair uses a causal specification to restrict which physical states should change and which valid states should remain.