- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
SkillRubric represents reusable skills through two aligned views: actor-facing guidance for planning and tool use, and evaluator-facing rubrics for assessing intermediate progress. A multimodal verifier uses tool outputs and visual evidence to assign turn-level process rewards alongside outcome rewards. During training, the framework alternately revises guidance and rubrics, validating guidance through paired frozen-policy rollouts and rubrics through offline evaluation of identical trajectories. Experiments across eight benchmarks and two trained backbones report consistent improvements over skill-based baselines, including on held-out benchmarks and without inference-time skill guidance.
Critical strengths
- The method improves over the strongest skill-based baseline across all eight benchmarks for both trained backbones. Comparisons share SFT initialization, training tasks, tools, and initial actor-facing skills. Gains also persist without inference-time guidance, supporting a benefit from training beyond prompt augmentation
- Deriving procedural guidance and evidence-based evaluation criteria from reusable skills provides a practical way to iterate the model update. The separate validation procedures control for changes in behavior and evaluation, while ablations show that evolving both components performs better than fixing either one. These results support the framework’s practical usefulness.
Critical weaknesses
-
I find the conceptual advance relatively incremental. Reusable skills that evolve alongside policy training have been studied in SkillRL [1], step-level rubric supervision in Step-wise Rubric Rewards [2], and adaptive rubric–agent co-evolution in ARCO [3] and EvoRubrics [4]. SkillRubric’s more distinctive contribution is deriving actor guidance and evaluator rubrics from a shared procedural abstraction and validating their revisions separately. However, the ablations leave two questions unresolved. First, does deriving guidance and rubrics from the same skill improve performance compared with generating them separately from the same training trajectories? Second, does updating guidance and rubrics in separate stages work better than updating them together? Comparisons using similar rollout and external-model budgets would help establish the value of these specific design choices.
-
Moreover, controlling policy rollout budgets does not establish comparable total training expenditure when the method adds synthesis, verification, and validation. The interaction-efficiency comparison against the original backbones also does not establish efficiency relative to the trained baselines. These gaps limit confidence in the magnitude and cost-effectiveness of the improvements.
[1] Xia et al., 2026. SkillRL: Evolving Agents via Recursive Skill-Augmented Reinforcement Learning.
[2] Xie et al., 2026. Step-wise Rubric Rewards for LLM Reasoning.
[3] Tian et al., 2026. ARCO: Adaptive Rubrics with Co-Evolution for Multi-Step LLM-Based Agents.
[4] Ding et al., 2026. EvoRubrics: Dynamic Rubrics as Rewards via Adversarial Co-Evolution for LLM Reinforcement Learning.
Questions for authors
- Under comparable rollout and external-model budgets, how does shared-source guidance–rubric construction compare with independently constructing guidance and rubrics from the same teacher trajectories? This would help determine whether the claimed alignment drives the gains.
- Does alternating guidance and rubric validation outperform joint revisions under comparable budgets? The existing component ablations establish the benefit of adapting both components, but do not isolate the proposed update procedure.
- How stable are the main improvements and the differences between evolution variants across repeated runs or paired confidence intervals? What is the total training cost relative to the strongest baseline, including synthesis, verification, and validation?
- Is there quantitative validation of the multimodal verifier’s criterion judgments and turn attribution, such as agreement with human annotations? In particular, how reliably does it recognize valid partial progress in trajectories with incorrect final answers?
6 comments
Q3(a): How stable are the main gains and evolution-variant differences across repeated runs or paired confidence intervals?
Answer: We evaluated the main comparison, evolution variants, and Figure 3(a–b) SkillBank versions with seeds 42, 43, and 44, fixing each trained checkpoint. Mean ± sample SD measures evaluation variability, not independent-training variability. Overall averages eight benchmarks equally per seed. Scores are percentages; differences are percentage points.
| Backbone | Method | Seed 42 | Seed 43 | Seed 44 | Mean ± SD |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Qwen3-VL-8B | SkillRL | 13.12 | 13.25 | 12.88 | 13.08 ± 0.19 |
| Qwen3-VL-8B | SkillRubric | 17.88 | 17.64 | 17.38 | 17.63 ± 0.25 |
| Qwen3.5-9B | SkillRL | 25.24 | 24.56 | 24.72 | 24.84 ± 0.36 |
| Qwen3.5-9B | SkillRubric | 28.79 | 28.35 | 28.03 | 28.39 ± 0.38 |
SkillRubric wins on every seed for both backbones. Within-seed gains average 4.55 ± 0.19 points on 8B and 3.55 ± 0.24 on 9B, ranging 4.39–4.76 and 3.31–3.79, respectively.
Evolution variants.
| Variant | H | Qwen3-VL-8B | Qwen3.5-9B |
|---|---|---|---|
| GRPO-Rubric | 13.38 ± 0.46 | 25.27 ± 0.21 | |
| Guidance evolution only | 10 | 16.94 ± 0.24 | 26.43 ± 0.34 |
| Rubric evolution only | 10 | 16.17 ± 0.48 | 26.49 ± 0.56 |
| Joint revisions | — | 14.56 ± 0.26 | 26.72 ± 0.23 |
| Ours | 5 | 14.27 ± 0.32 | 26.46 ± 0.38 |
| Ours | 10 | 17.63 ± 0.25 | 28.39 ± 0.38 |
| Ours | 20 | 16.25 ± 0.42 | 26.87 ± 0.29 |
GRPO-Rubric fixes the SkillBank; H follows the manuscript’s alternating-update definition. Joint revisions propose both components every 10 policy-optimization steps. Default H=10 achieves the highest means, exceeding joint revisions by 3.07/1.67 points on 8B/9B, and both single-component variants and alternative intervals, supporting alternating validation across these settings.
SkillBank versions, Figure 3(a–b).
| SkillBank version | Qwen3-VL-8B-Instruct | Qwen3.5-9B |
|---|---|---|
| Without skill guidance | 7.37 ± 0.33 | 18.68 ± 0.37 |
| 10.23 ± 0.28 | 22.54 ± 0.38 | |
| 11.92 ± 0.49 | 23.56 ± 0.29 | |
| 12.72 ± 0.24 | 24.34 ± 0.13 | |
| 14.45 ± 0.18 | 25.16 ± 0.07 | |
| 16.06 ± 0.11 | 26.12 ± 0.12 |
Cross-seed mean Overall increases monotonically from to , gaining 5.83/3.58 points on 8B/9B, preserving progressive improvement across versions.
Q3(b)&W2: What is the total training cost relative to the strongest baseline, including synthesis, verification, and validation?
Answer: We compare SkillRL, the strongest baseline, across synthesis, verification, validation, and shared RL workload, using logged step timings, trajectory statistics, validation budgets, and API/tool pricing assumptions.
| Cost component | Unit | 8B: SkillRL | 8B: SkillRubric | 9B: SkillRL | 9B: SkillRubric |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Synthesis — teacher data, initial SkillBank, evolution proposals | $ | 2,250 | 2,248 | 2,250 | 2,248 |
| Verification — outcome and process judging | $ | 9 | 279 | 9 | 321 |
| Validation — API/tools | $ | 85 | 35 | 117 | 40 |
| Validation — GPU overhead | GPU-hours | 224 | 92 | 201 | 31 |
| Shared RL — rollout tools | $ | 418 | 418 | 577 | 577 |
| Shared RL — training compute | GPU-hours | 1,157 | 1,157 | 1,144 | 1,144 |
| Combined at $1/GPU-hour | $ | 4,143 | 4,229 | 4,298 | 4,360 |
| Relative combined cost | — | 1.000× | 1.021× | 1.000× | 1.014× |
8B/9B denote Qwen3-VL-8B/Qwen3.5-9B.
- Synthesis: Both share teacher collection and initial SkillBank construction; evolution proposals add a few dollars. Each configuration includes $2,247 one-time preparation for standalone comparison, though artifacts are reused across runs.
- Verification: Both use the same outcome judge. SkillRubric adds GPT-5-mini coarse matching and Gemini 3.5 Flash fine verification: $270/$312 extra for 8B/9B, estimated from sampled text lengths and a 2,048-token output budget per stage, excluding image tokens.
- Validation: SkillRL uses periodic rollouts with tool/judging costs; SkillRubric uses cached rescoring for rubric calibration and paired frozen-policy rollouts for guidance validation. GPU overhead covers extra co-evolution time; API/tools cover both validation stages. Savings are 132/171 GPU-hours for 8B/9B.
Shared SFT compute is excluded. SkillRL validation time uses ordinary-step rollout timings. Totals precede rounding, so displayed components may differ from totals by one unit. At an illustrative $1 per H20 GPU-hour, combined cost rises 2.1% on 8B and 1.4% on 9B, with process-verification costs partly offset by validation savings.
The breakdown and assumptions appear in Appendix B.9, “Training Cost Analysis” (page 27, lines 1420–1449; Table 8 on the same page), highlighted in blue.
W2: The interaction-efficiency comparison against the original backbones also does not establish efficiency relative to the trained baselines.
Answer: Following the reviewer’s suggestion, we expanded the original comparison to include SkillRL, XSkill, Skill-SD, and Skill0. The tables below report average interaction turns on each benchmark, with Avg. denoting the unweighted average across all eight benchmarks.
Qwen3-VL-8B
| Model | AgentVista | BrowseComp-VL | VDR-Bench | VisualToolBench | VisBrowse | MMSearch+ | MMSearchExam | TIR-Bench | Avg. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Qwen3-VL-8B-Instruct | 6.7 | 4.6 | 3.9 | 8.4 | 5.8 | 5.0 | 4.6 | 7.9 | 5.9 |
| SkillRL | 5.5 | 3.6 | 4.0 | 6.2 | 4.2 | 3.3 | 3.8 | 6.7 | 4.7 |
| XSkill | 5.6 | 4.5 | 4.8 | 6.5 | 6.0 | 4.6 | 4.7 | 6.9 | 5.5 |
| Skill-SD | 4.2 | 4.3 | 4.2 | 5.1 | 5.6 | 5.0 | 4.4 | 3.8 | 4.6 |
| Skill0 | 5.3 | 3.9 | 5.6 | 6.3 | 4.2 | 4.4 | 3.4 | 5.4 | 4.8 |
| Ours (w/ skill) | 5.9 | 3.3 | 3.1 | 6.1 | 5.2 | 3.2 | 3.1 | 6.0 | 4.5 |
Qwen3.5-9B
| Model | AgentVista | BrowseComp-VL | VDR-Bench | VisualToolBench | VisBrowse | MMSearch+ | MMSearchExam | TIR-Bench | Avg. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Qwen3.5-9B | 10.7 | 6.8 | 9.6 | 9.5 | 11.3 | 9.7 | 9.6 | 8.9 | 9.5 |
| SkillRL | 7.9 | 7.7 | 8.7 | 11.7 | 8.8 | 9.2 | 8.8 | 9.3 | 9.0 |
| XSkill | 7.9 | 5.4 | 6.9 | 10.9 | 9.7 | 5.6 | 6.7 | 4.3 | 7.2 |
| Skill-SD | 6.6 | 7.3 | 9.6 | 5.4 | 10.4 | 9.6 | 10.1 | 4.4 | 7.9 |
| Skill0 | 2.5 | 8.4 | 7.4 | 2.7 | 3.1 | 11.2 | 4.5 | 2.0 | 5.2 |
| Ours (w/ skill) | 4.8 | 4.7 | 5.7 | 3.1 | 6.4 | 4.6 | 5.5 | 1.6 | 4.6 |
As shown in the tables above, SkillRubric achieves the lowest average interaction count on both backbones. On Qwen3-VL-8B, it averages 4.5 turns, compared with 4.7, 5.5, 4.6, and 4.8 for SkillRL, XSkill, Skill-SD, and Skill0, respectively. On Qwen3.5-9B, it averages 4.6 turns, compared with 9.0, 7.2, 7.9, and 5.2. The reductions are modest on 8B and larger on 9B, with benchmark-specific variation. Together with the higher success rates in Table 1, these results support improved task performance with fewer interactions on average relative to the trained baselines.
We have expanded Table 4 (page 10) and updated the “Interaction efficiency” paragraph in Section 4.4 (page 10, lines 506–512) to include the trained-baseline comparisons. The additions and revisions are highlighted in blue.
We thank the reviewer for the positive assessment and constructive feedback. We address each question below.
Q1&W1: Under comparable budgets, does shared-source guidance–rubric construction outperform independent construction from the same teacher trajectories?
Answer: Deriving guidance and rubrics from the same skill offers two benefits:
To isolate the benefit of shared-source construction, we compared rubric sources on both backbones, fixing actor guidance, the verifier, and reward formulation under comparable rollout and external-model budgets. GPT-5.5, the SkillBank synthesizer, generates independent rubrics from each task, its reference answer, and nine teacher trajectories (three per teacher), including reasoning, tool calls, observations, and final responses. Inputs include image references but no pixels or additional outcome labels. Without access to the extracted skill, guidance, or existing rubric, it generates three to five method-agnostic checkpoints, permitting valid alternatives and excluding task-specific answer values. Both approaches use the same teacher evidence, testing rubric construction through the procedural abstraction shared with guidance. Co-evolution is disabled in both conditions, keeping guidance and rubrics fixed during training. The skill-derived condition is the original GRPO-Rubric ablation (H=∞).
Skill-derived rubrics improve Overall by 1.71 percentage points on Qwen3-VL-8B and 1.50 on Qwen3.5-9B, with higher IID and OOD averages on both, supporting rubric construction through the abstraction shared with guidance.
We expanded Table 2 (page 8) and updated Section 4.3, “Component contributions” (page 8, lines 417–424). Construction and training protocols appear in Appendix B.8, “Independent Rubric Construction” (page 26, lines 1380–1403). Changes are highlighted in blue.
Q2&W1: Does alternating validation outperform joint revisions under comparable budgets, beyond the benefit of adapting both components?
Answer: Guidance shapes trajectories; rubrics evaluate them. Revising both changes behavior and evaluation criteria simultaneously; a rubric validated under previous guidance may inadequately assess revised executions. Our procedure validates guidance through paired frozen-policy rollouts, then delays rubric calibration until trajectories are available under the associated guidance.
We compared joint revisions under comparable rollout and external-model budgets. Every 10 policy optimization steps, the coach proposes guidance and rubric changes together. Candidate rubrics are validated by offline rescoring of existing trajectories under active guidance, using Appendix B.4’s outcome-alignment and pass-rate criteria. If all rubric revisions pass, candidate guidance is compared with current guidance through frozen-policy rollouts on paired tasks with identical sampling seeds. Guidance acceptance uses the fixed outcome reward, not candidate-rubric scores. Both revisions are released together only if both stages pass; otherwise, both are rejected. No subsequent calibration cycle precedes release.
Alternating validation improves IID and OOD averages on both backbones, increasing Overall by 3.11 percentage points on Qwen3-VL-8B and 2.13 on Qwen3.5-9B. Since both procedures adapt both components, these results support staged validation and release over this joint baseline, consistent with calibrating rubrics on trajectories generated under their associated guidance.
We added the baseline to Table 2 (page 8) and updated Section 4.3, “Component contributions” (page 8, lines 424–431). The protocol appears in Appendix B.5, “Joint-Revision Baseline” (pages 23–24, lines 1231–1266). Changes are highlighted in blue.