- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SegErase for concept unlearning in text-prompted segmentation. It combines attention-weighted suppression of target mask logits with teacher-relative reduction of emission scores, while constraining changes to retained predictions.
Critical strengths
- The distinction between spatial mask prediction and mask emission is well motivated. The evaluation extends beyond final emitted masks. Pre-NMS query leakage and unseen prompt reformulations provide useful evidence about residual target responses. The broader category and multi-target experiments in the appendix also strengthen the evaluation.
- The mean-matched weighting experiment is a useful control for CAGU. The score-objective comparison further examines the proposed rationale for limiting target-score suppression.
Critical weaknesses
- The practical motivation is underdeveloped. The introduction states that a deployed text interface should not return sensitive, private, or proprietary concepts, but does not establish a concrete deployment scenario or explain the additional harm caused by segmentation. It is also unclear why model-level unlearning is necessary rather than prompt or output filtering, and what protection remains if the same region can be recovered through generic or spatial prompts. A clearly defined threat model is needed to connect the proposed technical objective to its claimed practical value.
- The methodological advance over SCU needs sharper isolation. SCU already combines attention-level suppression, target-background supervision, and non-target preservation. SegErase differs through attention-weighted mask supervision and assignment-aware, teacher-relative score reduction, but additional controls would help establish why these particular choices are necessary. Mean-matched uniform weighting controls loss magnitude, but does not establish that the semantic information in the attention map drives the improvement.
- In Table 5, could the authors explicitly define AULC, Q.3, Q.5, and U.3, including their thresholds, aggregation, and normalization? Please also report score-independent residual mask overlap alongside AULC to distinguish removal of target-shaped masks from suppression of their scores.
Questions for authors
- In Figure 5, the identity mask includes clothing, so target-negative supervision also acts on regions that are not identity-specific. How do the authors distinguish removal of the name–identity association from suppression of the entire person mask? Please compare full-person and face-restricted unlearning masks, and evaluate preservation using both “person” and “shirt” prompts on the same images.
- Could the authors compare CAGU with spatially shuffled or reversed attention weights, while keeping the target-region mean weight and overall loss scale unchanged? This would help clarify whether the benefit comes from meaningful attention locations rather than nonuniform weighting alone.
- Could the authors evaluate SCU with its attention suppression replaced by CAGU, with TRSU added separately, and with both changes combined under the same training protocol? Comparing these variants at matched retained performance would help isolate each component’s contribution beyond SCU.