- Rating
- 4
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper argues that LLM alpha miners, which recombine predefined bar features, cannot express hypotheses that depend on how trades are timed and sized inside a bar. It formulates tick-level mining as a joint search over event aggregation and factor composition, and proposes CARTS, a two-level domain language plus an agent that revises measurement or expression according to stored evidence and a multi-view screen. On the Chinese A-share market the system is competitive as a bar-level miner, and a one-day study reports a large correlation gain over external miners that lose accuracy when they are handed tick data. A costed long-short-constrained portfolio, a growing library, and a direct transfer of mined factors to two other equity markets are used as further support.
Critical strengths
-
The problem is the critical one for this area. Automated miners that only recombine open, high, low, close, and volume cannot represent trade clustering, signed flow, or order lifetime, and those are exactly the measurements a tick tape is for.
-
The two-level language is a sensible response to that task. Event filters, measurements, and reductions are separated from the later expression, so a revision can in principle touch one without rewriting the other. The work also shows, under a shared factor budget, that two existing agentic miners get worse when their inputs are switched to tick data. That negative result is informative and is reported clearly.
-
The bar-level study is broader than a single correlation. It includes a constrained portfolio with stated buy and sell costs, a comparison against both standard libraries and learning-based predictors, and ablations of the search guidance and the multi-view screen.
Critical weaknesses
-
The economic evidence does not attach to the tick claim. The costed portfolio, with its high annualized return, is the ten-day bar library on one Chinese test window, 2024 through 2025. That window contains a violent regime break, no second split is reported, and no uncertainty across mining runs is given. The tick experiments stop at correlation. Individual discovered tick factors sit near an information coefficient of 0.02. Nothing in the work shows that the event-level variables, rather than the combiner and the bar features, are what a portfolio would pay for.
-
The search credit and the acceptance decision are not identified. The agent decides whether a failure came from the event definition, the expression, or the hypothesis, and it designs its own follow-up comparisons. There may need to check that those attributions are correct. Separately, an external model judges whether the program matches the stated hypothesis, and that binary judgment is a hard gate on acceptance. The ablation that removes the multi-view screen removes this semantic veto together with the redundancy filter, so the large drop in correlation cannot be assigned to either one.
-
The generalization claim may outrun the evidence. Transferred factors produce a rank correlation near 0.02 on the US universe. On the Japanese universe a static library has higher rank correlation than CARTS. The paper does not show that trade sign, cancellations, and passive-order time exist in comparable form on those tapes, so it is unclear whether any tick-specific variable survived the transfer.
Questions for authors
-
Under one horizon, one universe, and one label, what is CARTS's own tick-minus-bar difference in correlation and in the costed portfolio, across independent mining runs?
-
Do the factors transferred to the other two markets still depend on event-level variables that have comparable definitions there?
-
If acceptance keeps only the leakage and redundancy checks, what happens to test correlation and the costed portfolio?
Thank you for the detailed rebuttal and additional experiments. I appreciate the authors' efforts to address my concerns, particularly the matched-token comparisons, clarification of baseline implementations, and fine-grained ablations.
The new evidence substantially alleviates my original concern about unequal search budgets. However, I remain somewhat unconvinced about the independent contribution of evidence-guided credit assignment. Under the matched 30M-token budget, removing credit assignment changes IC only from 0.0811 to 0.0798. While this suggests a positive contribution. I also note that the cross-market experiments, as clarified in the responses to another reviewer, use only OHLCV-dependent factors. Consequently, these experiments do not directly establish cross-market generalization of the proposed tick-level variable construction.