- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a variance-based Markov-switching model for multi-regime temporal causal discovery, where a shared latent Markov state selects regime-specific causal models. Specifically, VBMSM adopts an additive structural equation framework and learns independent edge functions for each candidate edge to quantify its contribution. The core insight of VBMSM is that edge functions corresponding to true causal edges exhibit non-zero variance. Building on this observation, VBMSM introduce a novel penalty term that enables the model to jointly infer causal regimes and regime-specific causal relationships.
Critical strengths
- This paper correctly identifies the positive-variance property of edge functions under additive structural equation models. It further innovatively proposes a variance-based penalty term over edge functions to infer causal regime and regime-specific causal relationships.
- VBMSM has a reasonable model design. The introduced additive edge function adhere to the assumptions of the additive structural equation models and facilitate the model to independently quantify the contribution of candidate causal edges.
- This paper is clearly written. It elaborates on model parameters, experimental settings, and releases the algorithm codes, leading to strong reproducible.
Critical weaknesses
- The motivation of this paper is insufficiently clear. Multi-regime temporal causal discovery and Markov-switching models have both been extensively investigated in prior literature. While the authors introduce a variance-based penalty term, it remains unclear what unique advantages or distinguishing properties this penalty brings to VBMSM.
- VBMSM only accounts for lagged causal relationships, which constitutes a notable limitation of the method.
- The paper proves that edge functions corresponding to true causal edges must exhibit positive variance. Nevertheless, the penalty term in Equation (13) sums the variances across all candidate edge functions. There lacks a rigorous theoretical guarantee that minimizing this objective correctly recovers causal relationships and causal regimes. In my view, the penalty in Eq. (13) may merely serve as an alternative to standard sparse regularization. Worse still, it imposes extra constraints such as the additive model assumption and appears more sensitive to noise.
- The scalability of the proposed algorithm is not validated. The experiments are limited to datasets with only 8 variables and first-order lags, with no results reported for larger-scale systems or time series with longer lag orders.
- The experimental baselines are incomplete. Existing methods targeting multi-regime time-series causal discovery, such as FANTOM and RPCMCI, are omitted from comparisons.
- The benefits of the proposed variance-based penalty are not substantiated. The ablation study only includes the case with \lambda=0, and VBMSM achieves only marginal performance gains. As noted above, the variance-based penalty appears to be merely a substitute for sparse regularization. The authors should add a baseline where the variance penalty is replaced by standard sparse regularization and report corresponding experimental results.
Questions for authors
- What advantages or distinguishing properties does the variance-based penalty offer for multi-regime temporal causal discovery?
- How scalable is VBMSM when applied to higher-dimensional data?
- Is there rigorous theory proving that minimizing the variance-based penalty enables the model to recover causal regimes and regime-specific causal relationships?