- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes NavGround3D for aerial vision-and-language navigation. Frozen CLIP and VGGT encoders extract semantic and geometric features from five RGB views. Semantic-Geometric Visual Consolidation (SGVC) selects attention-based anchors and merges remaining tokens using joint semantic–geometric similarity. UAV-Centric Directional Grounding (UCDG) transforms patch viewing rays into the UAV body frame, encodes their directions, and models cross-view interactions with a Transformer. A LoRA-tuned Qwen3 backbone predicts local motion direction and distance. Validation comprises simulated navigation on TravelUAV and UAV-ON, two backbone sizes, and module/design ablations.
Critical strengths
-
The architecture addresses a meaningful aerial-navigation problem by combining semantic and geometric features with explicit patch-level directions in a common body frame, while using RGB observations rather than requiring measured depth as an input.
-
The experimental design includes two navigation benchmarks, two backbone sizes, and module comparisons with a fixed visual-token budget. These are useful controls, although the reporting issues currently limit their evidential value.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited novelty of SGVC. Its attention-based anchor selection and semantic–geometric token assignment closely follow Merge3D’s SemGeo Merger. The identified differences—cosine similarity, modality projections, and per-view budgets—are not sufficiently justified as substantive methodological advances. The feature aggregation rule is also unspecified.
-
Internally inconsistent results. In Table 7, the baseline’s Full OSR (53.78%) exceeds both Easy (50.91%) and Hard (42.78%), which is impossible when aggregating the same episode outcomes. Similar inconsistencies occur in SPL and Table 8, undermining confidence in the main comparisons and ablation conclusions.
-
Potential test-set-driven model selection. All ablations use Test-Seen, while Table 6 explicitly motivates selecting K=16 from these results. This appears to reuse the test set for hyperparameter selection, weakening the independence of the reported evaluation.
-
No real-world UAV validation. All experiments are conducted in simulation. No physical-UAV experiment establishes whether the method remains effective under real camera calibration errors, pose uncertainty, sensing noise, and execution constraints.
Questions for authors
- Can you reconcile the Full/Easy/Hard inconsistencies in Tables 7–8 and provide the episode counts and aggregation procedure? Were Full and subset results computed from identical rollouts or separate runs? Which corrected values should replace the corresponding entries in Tables 1 and 3?
2 comments
Thank you for the clarification. The aggregation rule is now clear, but I still find the differences from Merge3D’s SemGeo Merger relatively minor and am not convinced that they establish sufficient novelty for SGVC.
I also remain concerned about the lack of real-world UAV experiments. I understand the practical difficulties, but acknowledging this limitation and planning future experiments do not show how well the method handles calibration errors, pose uncertainty, sensor noise, or actual flight constraints.
While I appreciate the authors’ responses, these concerns remain, so I am keeping my score.
W1. We thank the reviewer for the valuable comments. We acknowledge that SGVC shares similarities with Merge3D's SemGeo Merger in anchor selection and token assignment mechanisms. However, the two methods differ in their design objectives. SGVC is tailored to multi-view UAV navigation, performing independent aggregation within each view to reduce redundant information while preserving spatial coverage across different viewing directions. Furthermore, the token assignment relationships established by SGVC are reused for viewing-ray aggregation in UCDG, enabling continuous directional modeling within a unified UAV body coordinate frame.Regarding the feature aggregation rule, we compute the mean of the non-anchor token features assigned to each anchor and add it to the anchor's own feature to obtain the aggregated representation. For anchors without any assigned non-anchor tokens, the original anchor features are retained. We have supplemented the revised manuscript with these aggregation details. We sincerely thank the reviewer again for the careful evaluation and constructive suggestions.
W2 & Q1. We sincerely thank the reviewer for pointing out this issue. This discrepancy resulted from a formatting error introduced during multiple rounds of table revisions throughout the manuscript preparation process. To improve evaluation efficiency, some results were obtained by independently evaluating separate subsets. In the revised manuscript, we have updated the tables with the complete results, which are consistent with those reported in the current version. We assure the reviewer that the submitted code can reproduce these experimental results. We sincerely appreciate the reviewer's careful examination and valuable suggestions.
W3. We thank the reviewer for the valuable comments. We acknowledge that selecting hyperparameters based on test-set performance may compromise the independence of the evaluation. In this study, we conducted only a coarse-grained exploration of the anchor budget (K) ((K=8,12,16,24,32)), rather than performing fine-grained hyperparameter tuning on Test-Seen. Nevertheless, we recognize that this approach may still introduce model selection bias. In future work, we will conduct a more systematic hyperparameter sensitivity analysis on an independent validation set to further assess the appropriateness of the selected configuration and ensure the independence and reliability of the evaluation.
W4. We thank the reviewer for this valuable comment. We agree that real-world UAV flight validation is important for assessing the robustness and applicability of the proposed method under practical conditions. Our current study primarily focuses on algorithmic evaluation in standardized simulation environments, and physical UAV flight experiments have not yet been conducted. Due to local low-altitude airspace regulations and geographical constraints, conducting field experiments remains challenging at this stage. To address this limitation, we have added a corresponding discussion in the revised manuscript. In future work, we plan to conduct experiments on a physical UAV platform, with particular emphasis on evaluating the effects of camera calibration errors, pose uncertainty, sensing noise, and flight execution constraints on navigation performance, thereby further assessing the robustness and applicability of our method in complex real-world environments. We sincerely thank the reviewer again for the constructive suggestion.