- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 1
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies rare precipitation recognition under limited supervision from the perspective of representation accessibility. The authors argue that frozen 3DMAE radar representations already retain useful evidence for high-threshold precipitation events, while standard readouts fail to effectively expose it. To address this, they propose PatchShot, which keeps the weather encoder frozen and learns a lightweight support-supervised contrastive adapter, followed by prototype-based prediction and support-only threshold calibration. An extension, PatchShot-Env, further conditions the readout on matched ERA5 environmental context through lightweight expert routing. Experiments across different precipitation thresholds and support budgets show improved rare-event recognition, with additional probe and intervention analyses used to support the representation re-access interpretation.
Critical strengths
The paper studies a problem of rare precipitation recognition under limited supervision and provides a clear distinction between representation failure and readout failure. The proposed PatchShot framework is simple and parameter-efficient, keeping the pretrained weather encoder frozen while adapting only a lightweight readout. I also appreciate the case-disjoint evaluation protocol and the effort to analyze the proposed “accessibility gap” beyond predictive performance.
Critical weaknesses
The main limitation is that the algorithmic novelty appears relatively modest. PatchShot largely combines supervised contrastive adaptation, prototype-based classification, and support-set calibration, and its advantage over some strong support-aware baselines is fairly small. In addition, the interpretation of the results as “recovering hidden information” is somewhat stronger than what the experiments directly establish, since the accessibility measure depends on the chosen readout family. For PatchShot-Env, it is also not entirely clear how much of the improvement comes from better access to radar representations versus additional predictive information introduced by ERA5 context. Finally, the method uses patch-level supervision derived from precipitation targets, so the practical meaning of the claimed few-shot setting could be clarified further.
Questions for authors
Could the authors clarify whether PatchShot requires dense patch-level precipitation labels for the support cases, and how the method would perform if only case-level rare-event labels were available?
For PatchShot-Env, can the authors disentangle the benefit of improved radar representation access from the additional predictive information directly provided by ERA5, e.g., with an ERA5-only or simple radar–ERA5 fusion baseline?
Supervision and Environmental Contributions
We thank the reviewer for recognizing the distinction between representation failure and readout failure.
Scope and contribution. We agree that PatchShot's advantage over strong support-aware baselines is modest and that accessibility depends on the readout family. Our contribution is not a new algorithmic component but a controlled study of whether readout failure necessarily means that rare-event information is absent from a frozen weather representation; PatchShot is a lightweight instrument for this study. The empirical envelope in Table 6 is defined by three probes, not an information-theoretic bound. “Hidden” refers only to evidence not exposed by the original QPE head or direct prototype readout. Matched CE also improves accessibility (0.981/0.987 versus 0.981/0.996 for PatchShot), indicating that task-aligned supervision, rather than a uniquely contrastive mechanism, drives much of the improvement.
Q1. Does PatchShot require dense patch-level labels?
No manual patch annotation is required. Precipitation targets originate from regional automatic weather station (AWS) observations provided by CMDSC. After quality control, observations from 2,856 stations are interpolated via Kriging into 700 × 900 precipitation grids spanning 108.50°–117.50°E and 19.04°–26.04°N. Patch event labels are generated automatically using Eq. (2).
“Few-shot” refers to 19–959 labeled radar support cases, each paired with a spatial precipitation target, not to a small total number of annotated patches. Gridded targets are used to derive labels for support cases; query targets are withheld from training and inference and used only for evaluation. This is denser supervision than a single binary event label per case. The gridded targets permit spatial alignment of radar structure and rainfall, although interpolation introduces uncertainty. Learning from case-level labels alone, e.g., through multiple-instance learning, remains future work.
Q2. Radar accessibility versus additional ERA5 information
We agree that ERA5 supplies additional predictive information, which must be distinguished from improved access to radar representations. Table 4 already includes simple radar–ERA5 fusion. At H5/H10, radar-only PatchShot achieves CSI of 23.29/16.65, simple fusion 30.27/24.30, PatchShot-Env 30.95/25.59, and case-shuffled routing 30.01/23.58.
The substantial gain from simple fusion supports an important contribution from additional environmental inputs. Moreover, ERA5-conditioned adapters use 3,000 separate development cases, so the total gain cannot be attributed to environmental inputs alone. Routing adds a modest improvement over simple fusion; case-shuffled routing performs worse, consistent with the usefulness of case-aligned conditioning. An ERA5-only readout, which we have not yet evaluated, would further isolate the independent contribution of atmospheric context. Neither comparison establishes that the environmental gains arise from improved radar representation access. We therefore ground our accessibility conclusions in radar-only experiments and present PatchShot-Env as a complementary extension.
ERA5 provides humidity, temperature, winds, and geopotential (q, t, u, v, z) at pressure levels, but it is a delayed reanalysis product. Real-time AWS, radiosondes, and NWP analyses or forecasts are potential operational substitutes; whether they reproduce these gains remains unverified.
We also examine AGRI geostationary satellite observations. In Table 5, matched cloud states outperform month-shuffled controls, suggesting useful case-aligned information, but gains over the unconditioned readout are modest and nonuniform (H5 CSI: 28.94 versus 28.43). We treat AGRI as a complementary extension, not part of the final model.
Summary. Radar-only experiments support readout-dependent recoverability under a restricted empirical accessibility measure. Spatial precipitation targets provide support-case supervision; ERA5 and AGRI add complementary context. We do not attribute their gains exclusively to improved radar access.