- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces RGDT-Bench to evaluate LLM reasoning completeness across four dimensions: rule use, condition assessment, evidence support, and decision aggregation. Experiments reveal that 40.2% of correct responses have incomplete warrants, which existing evaluators struggle to detect. A warrant-supervised reward model substantially improves completeness assessment and downstream response selection.
Critical strengths
- The paper addresses an important limitation of outcome-based evaluation, showing that correct answers can conceal incomplete or unsupported reasoning.
- RGDT-Bench provides fine-grained reasoning diagnostics across four process layers and multiple task domains, enabling systematic analysis of reasoning failures.
- Extensive experiments with 17 existing evaluators demonstrate the difficulty of assessing warrant completeness. Warrant supervision improves AUROC by 10.37 percentage points over the matched outcome-supervised baseline among correct answers.
Critical weaknesses
- The connection between warrant completeness and decision reliability remains unclear. The paper shows that correct answers can contain incomplete warrants, but does not establish whether improving warrant completeness leads to more reliable decisions. The downstream evaluation is limited to Best-of-N selection on the same benchmark tasks, without validation in independent decision-making scenarios.
- The benchmark has limited case diversity. Despite collecting 86,784 model responses, RGDT-Bench contains only 452 original cases, including 90 test cases (
Table 6). This raises concerns about whether the findings generalize to more diverse rules, documents, and decision scenarios. - The reliability of automatic warrant annotations remains a concern. Warrant labels depend on LLM-based claim extraction, yet only 360 responses are manually validated, with a Krippendorff's α of 0.687. Potential annotation errors may propagate into both benchmark evaluation and reward-model supervision.
- The practical benefits of warrant supervision are limited. Despite substantial improvements in AUROC, Warrant-RM achieves only a 1.23 percentage-point gain in warrant completeness and a 0.46 percentage-point gain in answer accuracy over Full-response ORM in the Best-of-16 evaluation across all response groups (
Table 4). These modest gains leave the practical value of warrant supervision insufficiently demonstrated.
Overall, the paper systematically quantifies incomplete warrants in correct answers, but their practical significance remains insufficiently established. Although the proposed framework identifies reasoning deficiencies and warrant supervision improves response selection, it remains unclear to what extent warrant incompleteness reflects consequential reasoning failures or predicts decision reliability. Moreover, the modest gains in Best-of-N selection provide limited evidence of substantial downstream benefits. Thus, the connection between warrant completeness and reliable decision-making remains insufficiently validated.
Questions for authors
Please refer to Weaknesses.
9 comments
M1. Checking Explanations and Comparing Candidates Reveal the Value of Warrant Supervision
Response
To connect warrant completeness to practical review, we test whether the same learned signal helps assess one explanation, compare alternatives and retain or select candidates. Thank you for asking us to clarify this connection. Sections 5.4–5.5 now follow this pointwise → pairwise → listwise progression with the same fitted models.
1. Pointwise: identifying reasoning errors that outcome checks miss
Consider the Regulation example in Appendix F.6. The evidence reports a leg injury but says nothing about discharge from military service. The response infers “He lost a leg, likely discharged,” yet returns the correct answer because another eligibility condition remains unresolved. Checking only the final answer misses this unsupported judgment. Warrant supervision makes such stated grounds available for checking. Section 3 defines the coverage target, and Appendix F.6 illustrates rule-scope, evidence and decision-consistency failures across the four tasks.
A reviewer deciding whether to accept an explanation therefore needs a signal about its grounds. To isolate the supervision target, Section 5.4 matches the backbone, data, weights and training budget (Appendix D.3). We test discrimination across all responses, then hold outcome correctness fixed in the correct-only view to ask whether the score still distinguishes complete from incomplete grounds. Table 4 shows the advantage in both views.
| Completeness AUROC (%) | Final-only ORM | Full-response ORM | Warrant-RM | Gain over Final / Full (pp) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Full | 67.31 | 72.99 | 79.93 | +12.62 / +6.94 |
| Correct-only | 51.86 | 58.87 | 69.24 | +17.38 / +10.37 |
The gains also extend to AUPRC and balanced accuracy. Relative to Full-response ORM, these improve by 10.16 and 3.13 pp in the full view, and 9.59 and 5.00 pp among correct answers. Because Warrant-RM and Full-response ORM receive the same explanation, the advantage identifies the value of warrant supervision even when the final answer is already correct.
2. Pairwise and listwise: using the assessment signal to choose responses
Because assessment and selection place different demands on a score [1,2], we test transfer explicitly with the same models. Warrant-ranking AUROC improves by 7.486/3.799 pp over Final-only/Full-response ORM, with statistical support for both comparisons. Outcome ranking has positive mean gains of 4.694/0.472 pp (Section 5.5, Table 5).
When review capacity is limited, retaining k=1, 2, 4 or 8 of 16 candidates increases mean warrant precision by 1.685–4.405 pp over Final-only ORM and 0.866–1.265 pp over Full-response ORM. Gains are positive at every evaluated k<16 (Table 6), supporting prioritization of explanations for review.
Returning only the highest-scored answer is a more demanding transfer test. In Best-of-16 opportunity pools, completeness/accuracy gains are +11.02/+8.11 pp over Final-only ORM and +2.18/+1.66 pp over Full-response ORM. Across all groups, the corresponding gains remain +4.40/+1.69 and +1.23/+0.46 pp (Table 7). Opportunity pools contain both target labels. The all-group view also includes uniform-label pools, where selection leaves the target unchanged. These differences use the displayed means.
These results connect the assessment signal to improved candidate prioritization and positive mean final-selection gains on held-out RGDT tasks. M4 presents the full ranking and selection tables. Further source collections and decision environments would extend this validation.
Conclusion: On held-out RGDT tasks, warrant supervision connects identifiable reasoning errors to better assessment, comparison and candidate retention.
References
[1] Zhou, E., et al. (2025). RMB: Comprehensively Benchmarking Reward Models in LLM Alignment. ICLR.
[2] Kim, S., et al. (2025). Rethinking Reward Model Evaluation Through the Lens of Reward Overoptimization. ACL, pp. 13252–13280.
M2. Four Distinct Rule Settings Enable Controlled Tests of Reasoning and Supervision
Response
To make reasoning failures verifiable, we organize the benchmark around four distinct decision settings, each with source-grounded requirements for its judgments, evidence and decision logic. Thank you for raising case diversity. Sections 3–4 and Appendix B now clarify how the sources and controlled comparisons support the findings.
1. Grounding each decision makes the reasoning question testable
Our motivating question is whether an answer's stated grounds are complete and supported even when its final decision is correct. Answer labels alone cannot resolve this question. Each case therefore needs a reference warrant specifying the required judgments, their supporting rules and evidence, and how they combine into a decision (Section 3.2). This structure makes it possible to locate an omitted condition, an unsupported inference or an incorrect aggregation, and then turn those diagnoses into supervision. This design makes variation in the governing rules and required reasoning observable at the source-case level. The probes and generated responses then allow controlled comparisons within those cases.
2. The four tracks vary the rules, evidence and decisions being assessed
The task coverage extends from applying policies to questions, through inference from contracts and administrative rules, to checking basketball transactions against a rule manual. These settings require different judgments, support and decision logic. Sections 3–4 and Appendix C.2 specify how the common evaluation framework preserves these task-specific requirements.
| Track and source | Rule and evidence setting | Distinct reasoning demand |
|---|---|---|
| Policy / ConditionalQA | Policy rules and question-specific evidence | Establish whether the supplied grounds justify the answer to the policy question |
| Contract / ContractNLI | Contract clauses and annotated support | Judge multiple inference conditions, use required or accepted alternative evidence, and combine the judgments |
| Regulation / ShARC | Administrative rules and case evidence | Resolve required conditions, retain unresolved judgments, and apply conjunctions or alternatives in the decision logic |
| Transaction / RuleArena–NBA | Transaction facts and a basketball rule manual | Identify the proposed action, apply an accepted governing rule and justify overall compliance |
These differences matter because a score that recognizes a well-supported policy answer must also handle clause-level evidence, unresolved regulatory conditions and action-specific compliance. The shared representation makes these distinct demands comparable while preserving their source-specific requirements.
3. Repeated cases isolate support-access and model effects
The probes ask how reasoning changes when the same decision requires locating support in different contexts. P1 supplies matched support, P2 introduces confusable passages, and P3 retains longer natural document context. All four tracks support P1. Contract and Transaction additionally support P2/P3 because their documents contain the relevant distractors and surrounding material. The construction preserves the facts, required support and correct decision (Section 4.1 and Appendix B.3). Comparing six generators on these shared inputs then separates model differences from changes in the underlying problem. Repeated responses provide the candidates needed to test whether warrant supervision improves assessment, comparison and selection. This connects support-access diagnosis to downstream evaluation.
4. Source-level separation tests the signal on held-out cases
To prevent related cases from leaking across splits, cases sharing documents, related operations or similar content are grouped first, with every probe and response kept in its group's split (Appendix B.1). Test data remain separate from fitting and model selection. To account for dependence among responses, uncertainty analyses retain these groups as the resampling units (Appendix D.1). The revised audit supplies a separate reliability check across every test case, with balanced task and generator coverage (Appendix C.3).
Expanding to additional policy collections, contracts and rule manuals is the next step toward broader source-level generalization, using the same reference-grounded framework.
Conclusion: Across four task families and controlled support settings, held-out comparisons connect identifiable reasoning failures to useful supervision.
Opening response
To test the practical value of warrant supervision, we test transfer of the learned scoring signal from pointwise assessment to pairwise comparison and listwise selection on held-out RGDT tasks. M1 connects concrete reasoning failures to assessment, M2 explains case coverage and split design, M3 checks the findings through balanced human review, and M4 examines ranking, candidate retention and final selection. Together, these tests connect the supervision signal to successive decisions in a response-review workflow.