- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies e-commerce creative generation: given product images, design requirements, and product information, the model generates renderable and editable HTML/CSS. The method first performs supervised fine-tuning of Qwen3.5-9B, followed by GRPO optimization using two types of feedback: checks of text, products, and layout based on the rendered structure, and VLM assessments of visual and commercial quality. The paper constructs a benchmark containing 1,300 cases and reports that the combined-feedback model improves the automatic score from 87.3 for SFT to 94.0, and the score from a blind evaluation by five experts from 81.6 to 90.0.
Critical strengths
1.The problem has clear practical value, and the representation is well suited to the task. Directly referencing product images and using native HTML text helps avoid errors caused by regenerating product appearance and text, while supporting element-level editing and structural checks.
2.The experiments support the effectiveness of combined feedback. The three RL variants share the same initialization and training configuration, with the feedback source being the primary difference. Table 1 shows that combined feedback outperforms both single-feedback variants, with larger gains on the Multi subset, providing evidence that structural constraints and visual preferences are complementary.
Critical weaknesses
1.The core technical novelty is limited, with the contribution primarily consisting of engineering integration and task-specific adaptation of existing methods. DesignAsCode already formulates design as HTML/CSS synthesis; AeSlides already uses rendered geometric constraints and GRPO; AesthetiQ already performs aesthetic preference optimization; and Learning to Present already combines structural, rendering, and screenshot-based aesthetic rewards. In addition, the supplementary experiments of PosterReward already combine text correctness and visual preference rewards. This paper adopts standard GRPO and an equally weighted reward combination, with the additions primarily involving e-commerce constraints and Single/Multi rule adaptation. The experiments demonstrate that this combination is effective, but do not establish technical contributions or research insights beyond combining existing feedback signals and adapting them to the task. I therefore consider the novelty insufficient for an ICLR-level research contribution. 2.The choice of comparison methods is insufficient to establish advantages over existing creative generation approaches. The authors propose an RL-based fine-tuning method, yet Table 1 compares general-purpose large models and variants of their own training approach without including the most relevant alternative methods for commercial design. Consequently, the comparison does not establish whether the proposed method outperforms existing mainstream optimization approaches, and it also weakens the novelty argument. The authors should include adaptable methods mentioned in Weakness 1 as baselines, or specifically explain why they are not comparable. The current comparison is insufficient to establish the method’s advantages over existing creative generation approaches. 3.The coverage and reliability of the custom evaluation framework are insufficiently validated. Automatic evaluation reuses the rule dimensions and weights employed during training. Although the model used for visual evaluation is different, the scoring dimensions remain the same; expert scoring also follows the corresponding evaluation framework. Public resources such as Graphic-Design-Bench, PosterReward/PosterBench, and ProductWebGen already provide evaluations of design quality or instruction following, but the paper does not use these resources for cross-validation. Developing task-specific e-commerce metrics is reasonable; however, the paper lacks validation of detection accuracy and the robustness of method rankings to thresholds and weights. The evaluation may therefore favor models specifically optimized for this reward framework. It does not provide a sufficient, independent, and fair comparison of overall creative quality, nor does it comprehensively and concretely establish whether the method delivers strong results in practice.
Questions for authors
1.Regarding novelty: Prior works including DesignAsCode, AeSlides, AesthetiQ, Learning to Present and PosterReward have explored HTML generation, GRPO, aesthetic rewards and multi-signal reward fusion. Beyond e-commerce adaptation and Single/Multi rules, what unique technical designs or new insights does this paper introduce? 2.Regarding baselines: The experiments only compare general LLMs and internal training variants, without the closely related creative-generation baselines listed above. Could you add comparisons against these works, or clearly explain why they are not suitable for a fair comparison?
2 comments
Thank you for the detailed response. I have read the rebuttal and the other reviews.
-
Novelty. The rebuttal restates the components, but does not explain what is technically different from prior work that already combines structural/rendering rewards with aesthetic rewards under GRPO (e.g., AeSlides, Learning to Present, PosterReward). The finding that the two feedback types complement each other more on the Multi subset is useful, but it is already in Table 1 and is an empirical observation, not a new method or insight that carries over to other tasks.
-
Baselines. I understand that the specialized methods use different pipelines. Still, at least one of them could be compared under a controlled setting. Without such a comparison, the paper cannot show that its feedback design beats existing alternatives, and not only general-purpose LLMs and its own variants.
-
Evaluation reliability. The high ICC shows that the experts agree with each other, but it does not address my concern: the training reward, the automatic metric, and the expert rubric all share the same dimensions.
Since no analyses were provided for these points, I will keep my original rating.
Methodological Novelty, Comparative Evaluation, and Evaluation Reliability
Thank you for recognizing the practical value of our work and the effectiveness of dual-feedback optimization. We appreciate your comments on methodological novelty, comparisons, and evaluation reliability.